Best Painters in Gilbertsville, KY - Chooz Score Ranked

Why Customers Choose Rodgers Painting

A Name People Trust

Sixty-two years in business builds something that can't be manufactured. Founded in 1964 by James "Buster" Rodgers and now led by the next generation, Rodgers Painting has become a fixture in both Paducah and Lexington. This company earned a Chooz Score of 89.8%:

• The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 95 Google reviews across two locations with ratings of 4.9 and 5.0 stars
• A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and 100% recommended on Facebook

"I have a 125 year old Victorian home in Paducah. I've dealt with a number of vendors for these services and somehow never heard of Rodgers. Their estimate was fair and they always stayed in touch. I will call Rodgers come the next work cycle." - William C., Google Review

Easy to Reach, Quick to Respond

Owner Bryce responds to every single review with personalized messages referencing specific project details and crew members. The Chooz Score's review response quality component reflects this commitment: 100% response rate with thoughtful, individualized replies:

• Customers consistently praise timely callbacks and clear communication throughout projects
• The team provides updates on progress and is responsive to questions

"Great communication, friendly service and some of the hardest working and skilled painters we have ever hired. They will always be our go-to painters from here on out." - Jon C., Google Review

Crews You Can Trust

Crews like Kyle, Austin, Christian, Jeff, Steven, and Thaddeus get called out by name across multiple reviews. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component shows consistency: the same crew names appear repeatedly, suggesting dedicated W2 employees rather than rotating subcontractors:

• Multiple reviewers mention leaving their homes with the crew while running errands
• A 2-year warranty on all work demonstrates confidence in their team's craftsmanship

"The Rodgers painting crew, Austin, Christian and Jeff were outstanding! I had no qualms of leaving them here if I had to run errands. They showed up on time, even called to let us know what time they would be here." - Teresa H., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Hernandez Painting

You'll Never Feel Left in the Dark

Customers consistently mention the same thing: Hernandez Painting keeps them informed every step of the way. From the initial quote to project completion, communication is a standout theme across reviews:

• Quick response to inquiries with detailed estimates that explain exactly what to expect
• Daily updates from project managers and crew leaders throughout the work

"From initial contact through completion, we dealt with five members of the team: Quotation, scheduling, office, pressure washing, painting. Each person was courteous and professional." - Jim F., Google Review

No Mess Left Behind

The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators show consistent mentions of cleanliness and protection of customer property. Reviewers repeatedly praise how the crew treats their home with respect:

• Daily cleanup at the end of each workday, with tools and equipment neatly stacked
• Careful protection of furniture, floors, and belongings throughout the project

"Their crew were so thorough and pleasant. They moved furniture and put it back where it belonged when they were finished. The project manager was in touch with us every day." - Randy J., Google Review

Hundreds of Happy Customers

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Hernandez Painting had over 125 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.1%. Reviews span multiple platforms with strong ratings:

• 100% recommended on Facebook with over 25 recommendations
• Active social media presence with over 700 Instagram posts showcasing their work

"Hernandez Painting Pros gave us the best quote, scheduled the job quickly and the work was impeccable. They finished a big job in just two days and the entire crew was kind and courteous." - Laura S., Google Review

Questions to Ask Hernandez Painting

Communication if you won't be home

One reviewer who was out of town during their project reported frustration with furniture not being returned to its original position and difficulty reaching the team afterward. The owner responded professionally and apologized. If you'll be away during the work, ask directly: "What's your process for communicating with homeowners who aren't on-site, and how do you handle final walkthrough if I can't be there?"

"I was out of town while they painted. They were supposed to put everything back in place like I left it because I told him up front I myself couldn't move the furniture." - Betty C., Google Review (owner replied with apology)