One word surfaces again and again in Mario's reviews. Meticulous. Mario's is a family-run crew, led by Mario alongside Luis and his father, and they keep the work in-house rather than handing it off to subcontractors. That consistency shows in the finish. Reviewers point to careful prep as the reason a paint job holds up, and painters like Wilfro and Fernando get singled out by name for it. The detail work is where it lands. On one garage job, the crew pulled down shelves, storage, and a large pegboard, then patched and filled every hole before a drop of paint went on. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators back this up, with reviewers naming specific projects, crew members, and realistic timelines. "Wilfro and Fernando painted my entire garage... They carefully removed everything, properly patched and filled all holes and gaps, and thoroughly prepped the surfaces before painting. The finished result is flawless." - Catherine J., Google Review
What sets Mario's apart isn't a giant pile of reviews, it's how consistent the ones they have are. The last time we ran our Chooz Score analysis, the company held a 4.9-star rating on Google and a social following most local painters never build, with nearly 8,000 Facebook followers and an active Instagram. Neighbors voted them a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2023. All of it added up to a Chooz Score of 87.5%. They're an established, registered North Carolina business entity (No. 2549723) in Clayton, and the roots show in the referrals. One neighbor sends the next, and one longtime client has kept them on across several properties for more than seven years. That is the kind of reputation that grows by word of mouth. "We have been working with Mario for probably over 7 years now and he and his team have done multiple projects for us on multiple properties... In a sea of incompetence Mario is the shore. Highly recommend." - Robert B., Google Review
Mario's backs its repaints with a written one-year workmanship guarantee and a promise of 100% satisfaction, and the reviews show it isn't just fine print. When a leak scarred a customer's fresh paint near a foyer window, Mario came out, tracked down the leak, patched it, and redid the whole wall in an afternoon for a reasonable price. Even the company's one tough review drew a prompt, courteous reply and an offer to make things right. That kind of accountability is exactly what the Chooz Score's negative review resolution component rewards. "When a leak near my foyer window scarred the new paint job, Mario came out, found the leak and patched it, and completely redid the wall in an afternoon for a very reasonable price. I will hire them again for my future painting needs and highly recommend them!" - Christine T., Google Review
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICERead through the reviews and one thing keeps happening. People don't hire Grady Jones once. They hire them, wait a few years, and hire them again. Anne Dunlap has used the company for 15 years across exterior and interior work. Danny Page's family is on their third job. Darlene Creech first hired them in 2015, called them back in April 2025, and now calls them her painters for life. The company earned full marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators, and it shows in how often reviewers describe returning for a 2nd, 3rd, or 4th project instead of shopping around again. They're not just satisfied with one job. They've decided to stop looking. "We've been working with Grady Jones Paint for several years and they will remain the only painting company we work with." - K D., Google Review
The owner, Clee, responds to virtually every review that comes in, and not with copy-paste thank-yous. He signs off with customers' names, references the specific rooms he painted, and mentions the families he worked alongside. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators reflect exactly this kind of personal involvement. That same presence shows up on the job. On one interior project that involved scraping and flattening popcorn ceilings before repainting, Clee stopped by every time his crew was on site, and a two-man team of Tim and Eddie handled the work. Grady Jones keeps its painters in-house and never uses subcontractors, which is why the same names, Fred and Chris on one job, Tim and Eddie on another, keep surfacing across reviews. "Clee was very responsive and visited the project every time his workers were on site. Tim and Eddie made up the crew who did the work. They were amicable, professional, courteous and did a GREAT job." - Mark H., Google Review
Painting the Triangle since 1980. Forty-five years, still family-run. That kind of tenure is rare in this trade, and the current numbers hold up next to it. The last time we ran our Chooz Score analysis, Grady Jones Paint carried nearly 30 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and had earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%. Beyond Google, more than 50 neighbors have marked the company a favorite on Nextdoor, where it holds a Neighborhood Favorite painter recognition, and it's proudly Army veteran-owned. It's been in business since 1980, serving Garner and the surrounding Wake, Johnston, Harnett, and Durham counties. "First class all the way when you hire someone to come in your home it's always a very personal thing. I cannot tell you how professional they were from A-to-Z all the work in my home looks phenomenal and I would highly recommend." - Jacob O., Google Review
Every painter listed on this page has been evaluated using the Chooz multi-step quality process. We combine data analysis with human review to identify companies that consistently deliver strong results for property owners in Wilson S Mills, NC.
The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating built on platform reviews, review quality and engagement, website and digital presence, and business authority and operations. We use the same scoring framework nationwide while evaluating each contractor's performance specifically within Wilson S Mills, NC.
