Best Painters Near Chatham, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Chatham, NJ have earned strong reputations through consistent quality and personalized service. Local homeowners praise these companies for skilled craftsmanship, clear communication, and work that exceeds expectations.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Elkins Painting and Wallpapering had over had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. They've earned the top spot in Chatham, NJ with a Chooz Score of 88.3%. What sets this company apart is that owner Elkin personally handles every project himself. He doesn't just manage crews - he does the painting and wallpaper installation with his own hands. If you want an owner-operator who takes pride in every brushstroke, Elkins Painting is an excellent choice.

Looking through the reviews, a clear pattern emerges: customers keep coming back years later for additional projects. Several reviewers mention this is their second or third time hiring Elkin, and many describe him as their go-to painter for life. His ability to provide accurate estimates through photos sent via text makes the quoting process remarkably convenient, and customers consistently note he finishes exactly when promised.

• Specializes in both painting and wallpaper installation, with reviewers calling him a master at pattern matching
• Provides estimates remotely through photos and text, often responding the same day
• Repeat customers return years later, still praising the original work
• Known for tackling challenging projects like cathedral ceilings and 30-year-old wallpaper removal

"We chose this painter because he had excellent reviews and, after he painted our very large bedroom and walk in closet, we know why. He is the best painter we have ever used." - Barbara F., Google Review

Customers consistently mention the same thing about Daisy Home LLC: reliable service and careful attention to finishes. They've earned a Chooz Score of 85.5% with over 70 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Owner Sam is frequently mentioned by name for his hands-on approach and clear communication throughout projects. If you're looking for a team that handles both painting and light renovation work, Daisy Home delivers on both fronts.

What comes through in the reviews is how well this company handles older homes with plaster walls and imperfections. Multiple customers describe situations where walls needed significant prep work before painting, and Sam's team took the time to repair cracks, smooth surfaces, and ensure a flawless finish. They also receive praise for keeping job sites clean throughout multi-day projects.

• Strong reputation for plaster repair and wall prep before painting
• Sam personally checks in throughout projects to ensure customer satisfaction
• Customers praise the team for leaving spaces spotless after completion

"Sam and his team did a great job repairing old plasterwork and painting walls, ceiling and trim! The old house needed some TLC and Daisy Home made it look great!" - Rebecca Golden, Google Review

With over 70 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, Paint Plus Home Remodeling has built a loyal following in the Chatham, NJ area. They've earned a Chooz Score of 84.1% and stand out for their kitchen cabinet painting expertise. Owner Jhon is mentioned throughout reviews for his responsiveness and willingness to help customers select colors and finishes. If you need cabinet refinishing or a whole-house interior refresh, Paint Plus is worth considering.

The reviews reveal a company that goes beyond basic painting. Customers describe Jhon and his crew handling wallpaper removal, drywall repair, and even floor refinishing alongside painting projects. First-time homeowners specifically mention how Jhon took time to explain processes and set realistic expectations, making the experience less stressful for those new to home renovation.

• Kitchen cabinet painting is a specialty, with multiple reviewers showing before-and-after results
• Crew members Cesar and Mario receive individual praise for their skill and professionalism
• Handles multi-service projects including painting, drywall, and flooring
• First-time homeowners appreciate Jhon's patience in explaining every step

"His whole staff's actually amazing. My kitchen looks absolutely beautiful and he also painted a desk for me which is flawless. Professional, fast, courteous and affordable!" - Crystal Palmieri, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Painting contractors serving Chatham, NJ consistently receive praise for their careful preparation and quality finishes. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering earns recognition as a true craftsman, with one customer noting "He is a perfectionist and took almost 2 days to prep the uneven walls before applying the new wallpaper. It looks amazing." Another homeowner shared that "His attention to detail and conscientiousness is unique among contractors."

Paint Plus Home Remodeling receives similar praise for thorough prep work. One reviewer explained "Their prep work is excellent, which makes all the difference of a quality job." Daisy Home LLC customers highlight the team's focus on finishes, with one noting "The quality of work is outstanding - clean lines, smooth finishes, and no missed spots." Another customer added "They repaired all the imperfections on our walls and gave our home a fresh, flawless finish."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Homeowners in Chatham, NJ consistently praise local painters for keeping them informed throughout projects. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering customers appreciate how Elkin explains every step of the process. One reviewer noted "He explained the whole process in great detail and kept me in the loop throughout the entire project." Another shared "Expect daily updates with pictures. He wants and appreciates input."

Daisy Home LLC earns recognition for clear communication, with one customer stating "Sam's communication was excellent. Always on-time and stayed until the job was done." Paint Plus Home Remodeling customers describe Jhon as highly responsive. One homeowner explained "He was constantly in touch with us while the crew was working" while another added "Jhon and his team were terrific. Excellent workmanship, reasonable prices, and cooperative service!"

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors in Chatham, NJ have built strong reputations for reliability and efficient project completion. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering customers frequently mention quick turnaround times. One reviewer shared "He literally came back the same day as the estimate to get started and was done quicker than we expected." Another noted "He gave a timeline and budget and stuck to that exactly."

Daisy Home LLC receives praise for punctuality and keeping promises. One customer stated "Daisy Home LLC comes to your appointment on time, provides quality workmanship, and delivers on time as promised." Paint Plus Home Remodeling customers describe the crew as fast without cutting corners. One homeowner explained "They kept the project within our agreed budget and finished on time" while another added "The crew was polite, timely, and efficient."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Homeowners in Chatham, NJ appreciate the transparent and convenient quoting process offered by local painters. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering stands out for remote estimates. One customer explained "He simply asked that I send him a few pictures of my deck and within a couple of hours he provided a competitive price." Another reviewer shared "Getting a quote from Elkin was SO easy, and he was so flexible in terms of timing and what we wanted done."

Daisy Home LLC earns recognition for fair pricing without surprises. One homeowner noted "One of the few contractors that stayed to original estimate and didn't add on any surprise cost during the project." Paint Plus Home Remodeling customers describe competitive pricing combined with quality results. One reviewer stated "From the beginning of the process to the end, Jhon delivered on every part of the project including competitive pricing" while another mentioned "Understood my budget while doing a fantastic job."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google