3 Best Painters Near Millburn, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Millburn, NJ and the surrounding Essex County communities have access to several highly regarded painting contractors. These companies have built strong reputations through consistent quality, responsive communication, and crews that treat homes with care. Whether you need interior work, exterior painting, or deck restoration, the contractors below have earned loyal followings in the area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. had over 250 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.7%, the highest in the Millburn, NJ area. Owner Tony DiGrezia has been running the company for over 28 years, and project manager Danny serves as the primary point of contact during jobs, checking in regularly and addressing concerns same-day. If you value having a dedicated contact person who keeps you informed throughout your project, Elite is a strong fit.

What stands out in the reviews is how many homeowners call Elite back for additional projects. Second-time and third-time customers appear frequently, describing experiences that prompted them to expand their original scope of work. The company holds a 5-year warranty on cabinet painting and uses Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams products exclusively.

• Multiple reviewers mention calling Elite back after being impressed with initial work, expanding to additional rooms or exterior projects
• The crew receives consistent praise for protecting floors, furniture, and belongings during interior work
• Several reviews highlight the company's ability to handle complex repairs alongside painting, including plaster restoration and water damage

"We contracted with Elite Painting & Power Washing to paint our first floor of our home. They did such a good job that we called them back to do additional work. Elite Painting has the best painters that we have ever used." - D Keller, Google Review

With nearly 40 years in business, Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC brings generational expertise to every project. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.4% with over 130 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company is EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified, making them particularly suited for work on older homes built before 1978. If you own a historic property in Montclair or the surrounding towns, Mark's team understands the unique challenges of century-old construction.

What distinguishes this contractor is the longevity of their paint jobs. Customers describe exterior work lasting a decade or more, and the company backs their work with an 8-year warranty that includes touch-ups at no additional cost. The team uses a four-level sanding technique that takes surfaces down to bare wood before applying primer and finish coats.

• An architect among the reviewers specifically praised the attention to detail
• The company has won Best of Essex six times and been featured in Design NJ magazine
• Customers with older homes appreciate the team's experience with challenging surfaces like plaster and weathered shingles

"Over the past 34 years we have painted the interior and the exterior of our 120 year-old shingle style house several times. Mark Tirondola is by far the best painting contractor we have ever used." - Stuart Rubin, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Millburn, NJ, N&C Painting offers a more hands-on, owner-operated experience. Owner Manuel Castro earned a Chooz Score of 84.7% with over 85 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 10 years in business, Manuel has built a reputation for being personally accessible throughout each project, often helping homeowners with color selection and responding to calls and texts quickly.

Reviewers consistently describe Manuel as warm, honest, and transparent about costs. When his crew discovers additional repairs needed during a project, Manuel explains options clearly without surprise charges. The company handles both residential and commercial work, and several reviewers note that N&C's pricing came in lower than competing quotes without sacrificing quality.

• The crew receives praise for working long hours to meet tight deadlines when needed
• Homeowners appreciate the thorough prep work, including sanding, patching, and priming
• Manuel personally responds to nearly every review, demonstrating ongoing engagement with customers

"N&C is an amazing painting service. We needed a tight turn around of less than a week from estimate to completion and N&C delivered. The owner is a true delight. Prompt, professional, excellent communicator for timing, invoices, etc." - Lex Minniti, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors in Millburn, NJ consistently receive praise for the quality of their finished work. Reviewers frequently describe paint jobs as flawless, with clean lines, even coverage, and careful attention to edges and trim. Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. earns particular recognition for their prep work, with customers noting that the crew takes time to properly protect floors and furniture before starting. One homeowner described how Elite handled a library full of books during an interior project, keeping everything organized while delivering excellent results.

Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC has built a reputation for tackling difficult projects that other contractors might avoid. A reviewer described a four-story Victorian painted in 12 different period-correct colors, calling the finished building a landmark. N&C Painting customers highlight the crew's thorough approach to surface preparation, including sanding, patching, and priming before applying finish coats. One homeowner noted that after a DCA inspection required repainting, the inspector returned and remarked how beautiful the work looked.

"The job was a difficult one. A four story victorian in period correct colors consisting of 12 different colors. The building is now nothing short of a Landmark thanks to the outstanding one of a kind paint job." - Roy R Macaluso Esq, Google Review

"Tirondola Painting Contractor repaired and painted my wood deck. The exceptional quality of the workmanship has the deck looking like it is brand new." - Sam Scherzo, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication stands out as a strength among the top-rated painters in Millburn, NJ. Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. assigns a dedicated project manager named Danny who checks in regularly during active jobs. Reviewers describe receiving confirmation texts before crew arrivals and having a single point of contact for any questions or concerns. Owner Tony DiGrezia handles estimates personally and remains accessible throughout projects.

N&C Painting owner Manuel Castro receives consistent praise for his responsiveness. Customers note that he answers calls and texts promptly, often the same day, and provides clear explanations about costs and timelines. When unexpected issues arise during projects, Manuel explains options and pricing upfront. Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC maintains strong communication from estimate through completion, with reviewers appreciating the team's willingness to discuss color choices and project details at length.

"Everyone we interacted with at the company was kind, responsive, and professional. The work done was excellent and completed in a timely manner." - Lauren K, Google Review

"The price is reasonable, even a little bit lower than the market price. The owner is honest, kind, and professional. He can give you some good advice on painting." - Wenjiao HU, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality appears consistently in reviews for Millburn, NJ painting contractors. Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. crews arrive when scheduled, with the project manager sending morning texts to confirm timing. Reviewers note that jobs start and finish according to the agreed timeline, with crews working full days to stay on track. Several customers mention being pleasantly surprised when projects completed ahead of schedule.

N&C Painting receives praise for meeting tight deadlines when homeowners need quick turnarounds. One reviewer described needing a complete paint job in less than a week from estimate to completion, and the team delivered. The crew consistently arrives by 8:30 AM and works until evening to maintain momentum. Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC also earns marks for timely completion, with one customer noting their deck project finished sooner than originally promised.

"The team was great. They worked so clean and quickly so as to create minimal disruption to our lives. We plan to use them on a few more jobs in the spring." - Tom Magistro, Google Review

"Excellent experience with Elite! Tony and his crew delivered on time with high quality at a reasonable price to paint the exterior of my house." - Todd S., Yelp Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Customers in Millburn, NJ describe the top painting contractors as fairly priced for the quality delivered. Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. provides detailed quotes that include paint costs, and reviewers note that pricing remains consistent with no surprise charges at the end. One customer compared six different companies before choosing Elite, citing Tony's professionalism and competitive estimate as the deciding factors.

N&C Painting frequently comes in lower than competing quotes while maintaining high quality. Multiple reviewers specifically mention receiving the most reasonable price among several bids. Owner Manuel Castro is transparent about costs when additional repairs are discovered during projects, explaining options clearly before proceeding. Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC customers describe the pricing as fair for the exceptional workmanship, particularly given the team's expertise with older homes and complex projects.

"Besides power washing, I also had them polymer sand a huge patio of pavers. I can tell you first hand that these guys are true professionals." - Sal Gencarelli, Google Review

"The owner, Manuel, was professional and fairly priced. His team was always there on time, stayed late, worked carefully, and cleaned up after each job." - Mark S, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google