Millburn, NJ Painting Contractors
Showing 0 painters servicing Millburn, NJ
About Simply Painting LLC
When Margaret Maziarz needed her home painted for the second time, she didn't shop around or get multiple quotes. She went straight back to Simply Painting LLC, later taking time to write they were "exceptional; neat, punctual, polite, and responsive." This loyalty pattern emerges repeatedly through their over 100 Google reviews, revealing something beyond typical contractor relationships in the Howell Township painting market.
The numbers present a compelling surface story: 135 Google reviews maintaining a perfect 5.0 rating, 25 years of experience claimed on their website, coverage across six New Jersey counties. But dive into the actual customer narratives and a different picture emerges. Rob, the owner, personally moves schedules around to accommodate urgent timelines (like the townhome that needed painting between closing and move-in with just 12 days notice). His crew protects furniture without being asked, fixes trim while painting walls, sends morning confirmation texts. None of these extras appear in their marketing.
What's curiously absent shapes this company as much as what's present. No BBB accreditation. No Angi presence. No Facebook business page despite having an Instagram account. Their state contractor license shows as inactive on BuildZoom, though they continue operating. It's as if Simply Painting deliberately sidesteps the traditional contractor marketing apparatus, relying instead on word-of-mouth from customers like Thom Rittenhouse who wrote a 301-word review calling their work "simply outstanding craftsmanship" with "flawless attention to detail." From their base on Abraham Drive, Rob and his regular crew (Frank, Kyle, Jim repeatedly mentioned) have built something that feels more like skilled neighbors than a traditional painting contractor.
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICESpartan Painting and Renovations LLC
About Spartan Painting and Renovations LLC
When Sandra S. hired Spartan to paint her entire basement in late summer 2024, she expected the standard contractor experience. What she got instead was a crew that showed up on time every day, kept her workspace immaculate, and finished faster than quoted without sacrificing quality. This wasn't an outlier. It's how Niko Konstantoulakis and his father Gus have built their operation since earning New Jersey Home Improvement Contractor License 13VH08583800.
The numbers paint one picture. Over 75 Google reviews averaging 4.8 stars. Work spanning from single-room refreshes to complete kitchen transformations. Projects completed in Livingston, North Caldwell, and across Essex County. But the reviews reveal something more specific. A pattern emerges around what's not advertised. Crews who protect furniture without being asked. Painters who fix door frames while handling trim work. Teams who send morning arrival confirmations and stay late on Fridays so clients have their kitchens back for weekends.
Spartan operates as a family business in the truest sense. Niko and Gus personally oversee projects, with Niko often spending hours at completion addressing imperfections customers haven't even noticed. The company claims two generations of experience, evidenced by their Best of Essex recognition from 2022 through 2024. From their base on West Mount Pleasant Avenue, they handle everything from historic 1752 home interiors (requiring delicate expertise) to modern commercial spaces, though residential painting remains their primary focus. Multiple reviewers mention being referred through town Facebook groups rather than traditional advertising, suggesting a business sustained almost entirely by word of mouth.
Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC
About Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC
When Danielle Palmadessa from DRP Interiors in Franklin Lakes needs a painting contractor she can trust with her high-end design clients, she calls Mark Tirondola Jr. This isn't just professional courtesy speaking. After years of collaboration, she knows her clients will be "thrilled" because, as she puts it simply, "he never disappoints." This level of trust from interior designers reveals something deeper about how this Montclair-based operation functions: less like a typical contractor relationship, more like an extension of their clients' own exacting standards.
The numbers suggest a successful painting business: over 100 five-star Google reviews, 40 years in operation since 1985, projects ranging from Victorian restorations to modern cabinet refinishing. But dive into what customers actually write and a different pattern emerges. Peter Weedfald doesn't just hire them; he's used them for three separate homes and even called Mark personally to help with a bird trapped in his roof a year after painting (Mark came, saved the bird, fixed the roof). Dave Varga has hired them three times for his 100-year-old Montclair house. Multiple reviews mention Mark Tirondola Sr. alongside Jr., suggesting this isn't just a business but a generational craft being passed between father and son.
What's striking is what Tirondola doesn't advertise but consistently delivers. Reviews repeatedly mention unexpected repairs included without additional charges, creative solutions to century-old house quirks (including restoring a milk door), and the peculiar habit of leaving homes "cleaner than when they started." From their understated headquarters on Grove Street, Suite 11-2, Mark Jr. and his crew operate with an old-school sensibility. They honor 8-year warranties without question. They shield customers' vehicles without being asked. They stay late on Fridays to ensure kitchens are usable for the weekend. These aren't listed services on their website at tirondolapainting.com. They're simply how the Tirondolas work.
Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc.
About
When Steve Feldman's bedroom walls were crumbling plaster, Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. didn't just paint over the problem. Tony and Danny repaired cracks, spackled damaged areas, and installed sheetrock where patching wouldn't work, then delivered what Steve called exceptional painting with crews who "took pride in their work." This approach to addressing underlying issues rather than cosmetic fixes defines how Tony DiGrezia runs his painting operation, recognizing that behind every project is someone who saved money to improve their home.
That bedroom repair represents typical Elite execution. Owner Tony DiGrezia and project manager Danny have built their over 200 five-star Google reviews through consistent practices. Danny checking job sites twice daily, crews protecting floors with multiple layers, addressing discovered issues like roof vents without change orders. From their Roseland location, they handle everything from single-room refreshes to complete exterior transformations. Customers repeatedly mention the daily communication Danny provides, the cleanup that leaves homes "cleaner than when they started," and Tony's practice of focusing on one project at a time rather than juggling multiple jobs simultaneously.
Elite operates primarily through word-of-mouth referrals and repeat customers. Property owners like Cathryn Sachs hire them once, then call back for a third project because the professionalism exceeded expectations. The 5.0-star average across over 200 Google reviews reflects something more than technical painting skill. It captures a contractor who treats customer homes with respect, maintains constant communication through project managers rather than disappearing between start and finish, and consistently delivers the kind of quality that turns first-time customers into advocates recommending them to neighbors and friends.
About Wilber's Home Improvements
When Dan Sharp accidentally overpaid Rony by $1,000 in cash for a large exterior project, he figured the money was gone. No receipt, no way to prove the mistake. An hour later, Rony called from the office: he'd noticed the extra thousand while recording the payment and drove 30 minutes back to return it. This moment captures what investigating over 100 Google reviews reveals about Wilber's Home Improvements: beneath the typical contractor promises lies an operation where personal integrity drives business decisions.
The numbers paint one picture: well over 100 five-star Google reviews, projects from $820 newel post repairs to complete historic home restorations, EPA certifications, New Jersey contractor license #13VH06449500 active through 2026. But dive into the actual customer stories and something different emerges. Crews bringing their own microwaves to avoid using clients' kitchens. Foreman Dennis making cracked plaster disappear in 1930s homes. Workers returning unprompted to clean bird droppings off freshly painted siding. These aren't marketed services or upsells. They're simply how Wilber Vargas has run his Maplewood operation for 25 years.
What's notably absent tells its own story. No Instagram presence, basic Wix website missing phone number and address, no Houzz profile despite being perfect for that platform. Yet somehow 343 Angi reviews averaging 4.9 stars. This is word-of-mouth construction in its purest form, where Eduardo brings flowers when he learns a client is pregnant, where Cesar reinforces rotting deck joists without delaying timelines or demanding change orders. From their unmarked shop on Millburn Avenue, this team has built something that feels less like hiring a contractor and more like having skilled neighbors who happen to own professional equipment. The three negative reviews in two years all involve the same pattern: long-term customers shocked by sudden price increases or communication failures, suggesting even reliable relationships can fracture when business practices shift.
Other Reviews & Ratings
* Reviews Last Checked: 10-01-2025