4 Best Painters Near Montville, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Montville, NJ have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with deep roots in northern New Jersey and strong track records across multiple review platforms. What stands out across all the top-rated companies is the consistency of five-star reviews and the frequency with which customers mention returning for second, third, or even fourth projects.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Touch Of The Brush Painting had over 220 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This family business earned a Chooz Score of 89.2% and has been serving the area for over 45 years since 1980. Father Jack Sciueche and son Victor run the operation together, and their longevity shows in the number of customers who describe using them at multiple homes over the years. The company also holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Reviews span over 230 reviews on Angi at 5.0 stars and over 65 Yelp reviews at 4.9 stars. If you have an older home with challenging prep work like wallpaper removal or extensive spackling, Touch Of The Brush is a good choice.

• One reviewer notes that a contractor working in their home asked for Touch Of The Brush's contact info after seeing the quality of their work
• Customers frequently mention the crew finishing ahead of schedule, with one estimated two-week job completed in under five days
• Named crew members like Marco, Edison, and Walter appear in reviews spanning different years, suggesting low turnover

"My husband has been in the construction business for 40 years and he is very picky about contractors that we hire for our own home. We had a great experience with Jack and his crew!" - Haylee Bell, Google Review

For homeowners seeking a true one-man operation where the person giving the estimate is the same person painting the walls, Elkins Painting and Wallpapering offers that hands-on approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.5% with over 225 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Elkin has been in business for over 30 years since 1995 and maintains 4.6 stars on Yelp. His specialty in wallpaper installation and removal makes him particularly valuable for jobs involving cathedral ceilings, stairwells, or vintage wallpaper from the 1970s and 80s. If you want guaranteed consistency and a craftsman who treats each project like artwork, Elkin is a good fit.

• Multiple reviewers describe wallpaper pattern matching as "perfect" even on challenging surfaces
• Customers praise his ability to provide accurate estimates based solely on photos, saving time on in-person visits
• Several reviews mention projects completed in a single day that other contractors quoted for multiple days

"Elkin completed the herculean effort of removing the 1980's wallpaper from the kitchen, stairwell and hallway. He then spackled where needed, and painted. If I tell you all the great things about the job, I would be sitting in front of this keyboard all day." - Mike Murphy, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Montville, NJ, N&C PAINTING handles both residential and commercial work with a focus on responsiveness. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.7% with over 85 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Owner Manuel Castro has built the company over the past 10 years and was named one of the "7 Best Morristown Painters" by Expertise.com. What distinguishes N&C is Manuel's accessibility - reviewers consistently note that he answers his phone, responds to texts quickly, and provides color consultation to help homeowners who struggle with design decisions. If you need a contractor who communicates clearly and stays involved throughout the project, N&C Painting is a strong option.

• One customer needed a tight turnaround of less than a week from estimate to completion, and N&C delivered
• Reviews mention the crew arriving promptly at 8:30 AM and working until 6:30 PM with minimal breaks
• Repeat customers describe using N&C for both interior and exterior projects across multiple years

"Incredible service and quality. The team was great. They worked so clean and quickly so as to create minimal disruption to our lives. We plan to use them on a few more jobs in the spring." - Tom Magistro, Google Review

A family-owned operation with EPA lead-safe certification, JNG Painting, LLC specializes in older homes that require careful handling of lead paint or asbestos. They earned a Chooz Score of 82.0% with over 135 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 12 years in business, owners Jamie and Gladys Toledo have assembled a dedicated team that handles everything from Victorian homes with extensive trim work to commercial gymnasium painting. If you have a pre-1978 home or a property with complex exterior details, JNG Painting is equipped to handle the specialized requirements.

• One reviewer with a 100-year-old home praised their hand sanding and attention to period details
• The team painted a school gymnasium during spring break, demonstrating flexibility with scheduling around client needs
• Multiple reviews mention Jamie providing honest assessments and working within homeowner budgets

"His company is EPA certified so they are the company to use if you have lead paint or asbestos on the outside of your house! Highly recommend!" - Amanda Gardner, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Quality and attention to detail appear in nearly every positive review for painting contractors in Montville, NJ. Customers consistently describe work that exceeds their expectations, with many noting that the finished results look better than when their homes were new.

For Touch Of The Brush Painting, reviewers emphasize the extensive prep work that precedes any painting. "Their prep was thorough, and the painting and attention to detail were very thorough. Jack frequently checked on progress to make sure the quality met his standards." - Marcy Benson, Google Review. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering draws particular praise for wallpaper pattern matching. "He is nothing short of a perfectionist and the pride he has for his craft is reflected in his work." - Grace C., Google Review. N&C PAINTING customers highlight the seamless drywall repairs. "They replaced all the rotten planks, sanded to reveal the new surface before painting. The deck looks beautiful now." - Howard Wang, Google Review. JNG Painting, LLC receives praise for handling older homes with care. "My very old house was in dire need of attention. Every detail I wanted done, he completed." - Jane Petriello, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Professionalism and clear communication rank among the most frequently praised qualities for painters serving Montville, NJ. Reviewers describe contractors who answer calls promptly, provide detailed updates, and maintain courteous behavior throughout each project.

Touch Of The Brush Painting customers note the family's responsiveness. "Victor is extremely responsive and we were updated every step of the way." - Kim Stein, Google Review. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering stands out for streamlined quoting. "He asked for pictures of the space before he quoted us to ensure he was giving us as close to an accurate quote as possible." - Bill Thomas, Google Review. N&C PAINTING draws praise for owner availability. "Manuel almost always answers his phone - a rare quality in contractors these days." - Howard Wang, Google Review. JNG Painting, LLC customers appreciate the scheduling flexibility. "So nice to work with someone who actually answers the phone!" - Arianna Constantino, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing and value appear frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Montville, NJ, with many customers noting that quotes came in lower than competitors while the quality matched or exceeded more expensive options.

Touch Of The Brush Painting customers describe competitive pricing. "Pricing was less than half of another highly rated painter. I was lucky to find them." - CJ Grenner, Google Review. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering receives consistent praise for value. "After getting 3 estimates, Elkin's price was by far the best with high quality results." - Debbie Orme, Google Review. N&C PAINTING customers highlight fair quotes. "The price is reasonable, even a little bit lower than the market price. The owner is honest, kind, and professional." - Wenjiao Hu, Google Review. JNG Painting, LLC draws similar feedback. "Great workmanship. Was on time, quality work at a reasonable price." - Adrian, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and preparation rank among the most appreciated qualities for painting contractors in Montville, NJ. Reviewers consistently describe crews who protect furniture, cover floors, and leave homes cleaner than they found them.

Touch Of The Brush Painting customers emphasize thorough prep. "Their prep was more than thorough, and the painting job was to perfection. All the rooms look fantastic." - Lynn R., Google Review. Elkins Painting and Wallpapering receives praise for neat work habits. "He was also incredibly neat, bringing his own booties to wear in the house and taking all the garbage with him when he finished." - Peter Sherry, Google Review. N&C PAINTING customers note the daily cleanup routine. "They left our house cleaner than they found it." - Tina Welles, Google Review. JNG Painting, LLC draws similar feedback. "They were very neat, taped everything off, and cleaned up completely when done." - David Sabagh, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google