3 Best Painters Near Forest Hills, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Forest Hills, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different strength to the table. Whether you need specialty decorative finishes, a full apartment repaint, or exterior work on a multi-story home, the top-rated companies serving this area stand out for their consistent quality, responsive communication, and fair pricing.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Interior Finishing NYC had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, the highest among contractors serving Forest Hills, NY. Owner Dorian Golemi trained at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in decorative applications like limewash, Roman clay, and Venetian plaster. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers came to Dorian after other contractors turned down their projects, whether due to tricky pre-war surfaces, unusual materials, or tight timelines. If you are looking for an artisan-level finish or a challenging decorative project, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong choice. With over 22 years in business and a three-year workmanship warranty, the company has deep roots in the NYC market.

Reviews reveal that Dorian and his crew routinely complete jobs faster than expected, with several customers noting entire rooms finished in a single day. Crew members like Jose and Amir show up consistently across feedback, suggesting a tight-knit team rather than rotating subcontractors.

• Customers frequently mention that Dorian offers quotes over the phone or video call, saving time on scheduling an in-person visit
• Several reviewers describe hiring Dorian for corporate office repaints, indicating commercial experience alongside residential work
• Multiple reviews highlight color-matching expertise, with customers saying finished walls matched their inspiration images precisely

"Dorian and his team are excellent. Superb attention to detail on wallpaper and painting job. On time, no hidden costs, did everything they said they would and finished ahead of schedule. 10/10!" - B Rauch, Google Review

For homeowners who want a hands-on owner running the show from estimate to final walkthrough, Outstanding Painting LLC is built around that model. Owner Milos earned a Chooz Score of 85.3% with over 60 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. What is notable when reading through the reviews is how often customers describe Milos walking them through every detail during the estimate, from color options to which walls need skim coating. If you are looking for a painter who treats even a one-bedroom apartment repaint as a serious project, Outstanding Painting LLC is a good fit. The company has over 4 years in business and is registered as an active domestic LLC in New York State.

A recurring theme across reviews is the range of work this team handles, from straightforward apartment repaints to specialty finishes like lime wash and spray-finished cabinet refinishing. Several customers describe the crew handling surprise wall damage and drywall repairs at no additional charge before painting.

• Crew members Freddy, Duber, and Ernesto are named repeatedly, pointing to a stable workforce
• Multiple co-op and condo owners mention that Milos handled COI paperwork and building coordination smoothly
• Cabinet spray refinishing gets specific praise from customers who say their kitchens look completely updated without the cost of new cabinetry

"My wife and I recently purchased an apartment in a cooperative building, and we knew that freshening up the space would be one of our first tasks. We decided to hire Outstanding Painting LLC based on their excellent reviews. The team was professional, punctual, and handled the COI process with our building seamlessly." - Ermis Escolastico, Google Review

With nearly 19 years in business since 2007, Precision Painting Plus of Queens is the most established local operation on this list, headquartered right in Forest Hills, NY. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 130 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, along with 4.4 stars on Angi across over 845 reviews. The company runs a structured operation where Brandon handles estimates, Amy manages scheduling and communication, and crew lead James runs the on-site work. If you prefer a company with a clear project management system and interest-free financing options, Precision Painting Plus is worth a call.

What shows up consistently across reviews is how seriously the crew takes property protection. Customers describe drop cloths on every surface, plastic sheeting over furniture, and spaces left cleaner than they were found. Several people who previously had bad experiences with other painters specifically highlight the difference.

• Matthew Lazarus notes the company is notably honest, describing an instance where they flagged an overpayment and issued a refund without being asked
• The team handles everything from single-room repaints to full houses, with Benjamin Moore paints used as standard
• Multiple reviewers mention the crew fixing plaster damage and patching walls before painting, included in the quoted price

"I've had several excellent experiences with Precision Painting. Notably, they are very honest - for a recent job I inadvertently overpaid, I did not realize but they made sure to follow up and correct it." - Matthew Lazarus, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Forest Hills, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings over 28 years in business and the kind of repeat-customer loyalty that is hard to manufacture. They earned a Chooz Score of 81.5% with over 190 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. The company holds active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor and Nassau County licenses. If you are looking for a team with deep Long Island roots that also serves Queens, Anthony's is a reliable option for both interior and exterior projects.

What makes this company unusual is the sheer number of customers who mention hiring them multiple times over many years. Reviewers describe returning for second, third, and even fourth projects, and several mention booking their next job before the current one wraps up. Crew lead Manny is mentioned by name in the vast majority of reviews.

• Several customers describe complex prep work including wallpaper removal, skim coating, and plaster repair before any paint is applied
• Exterior projects on multi-story homes are handled with the same attention as interior apartment repaints
• Multiple reviewers note the crew vacuums before starting, lays paper on floors, and covers everything with plastic before a single brush stroke

"I was very Lucky to have found Anthony's Painting and Decorating. The entire process of getting an estimate, picking out colors and setting a date, was very easy. The day my house was scheduled to start, they arrived right on time and went right to work. My house looks absolutely beautiful." - Andy Mcadam, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Customers across Forest Hills, NY consistently praise the finished results they receive from local painting contractors. Reviews for Interior Finishing NYC frequently highlight the precision of specialty finishes, with clients describing limewash walls that look exactly like their inspiration photos and wallpaper installations with no visible seams. "Absolutely five stars! Impeccable precision, a great eye for style, and top-quality work. The flowered wallpaper in our kitchen looks stunning, elegant and perfectly executed." - Bjorn de Carro, Google Review. Customers of Precision Painting Plus of Queens describe plaster repairs that made damaged ceilings look brand new, and shelly helfand called the work on four rooms "beautifully done" with "amazing plaster work." Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns similar praise, with Joseph Callesano sharing that he was "truly amazed at what a great job Manny and his entire team did at our house."

Several reviewers across companies specifically mention being impressed by the prep work that goes into achieving a quality finish. Customers of Outstanding Painting LLC describe skim coating, hole patching, and wall repairs done before any paint is applied, with one reviewer noting the crew fixed problems from a prior painter who had failed to show up. Hannah Dayton, a repeat customer, mentions using Outstanding Painting twice and being "always very happy with their work" across painting and floor staining projects. In Forest Hills, NY, the quality of prep work appears to be what separates these top-rated contractors from the competition.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Communication and scheduling are among the most frequently praised qualities in reviews for painting contractors serving Forest Hills, NY. Precision Painting Plus of Queens runs a structured system where estimator Brandon, coordinator Amy, and crew lead James each handle a specific part of the process. Tracy Ragin described meeting with Brandon, who gave a detailed quote with "an eye for detail" that she felt was beyond reasonable. Amy B. Goldberg needed a rush job before guests arrived and was told it would take one to two days, but the crew "completed the entire project in five hours." Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian earns consistent praise for fast response times, with Tony Algreen noting that Dorian "showed up within the same week I contacted him."

Outstanding Painting LLC owner Milos is described by multiple reviewers as one of the fastest to respond among all the painters they contacted. Maeve Martin specifically noted that Milos responded faster than the five other companies she reached out to and quickly scheduled an in-person estimate. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp also receives strong marks for scheduling reliability, with customers consistently noting crews arrive on time and finish within the quoted timeframe. Michael Grossberg emphasized that "there was never a concern" about the timeline during his full interior home paint. Across these Forest Hills, NY area contractors, the pattern is clear: responsive estimates, on-time arrivals, and efficient completion.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Cleanup and property protection are consistent highlights in reviews for painting contractors serving Forest Hills, NY. Precision Painting Plus of Queens receives some of the most detailed feedback on this topic. Aaron Thompson describes a thorough system of drop cloths and plastic covering every surface before work begins, and Alice deAlmeida confirms the crew "left no mess" after completion. Several customers contrast this directly with previous contractors, noting the difference was striking. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns similar praise, with Stuart Rock stating that when the crew finished, "there was nothing for me to clean up" and everything removed during painting was put back exactly as it was before.

Outstanding Painting LLC customers also highlight the crew's approach to protecting belongings. Kristina K. on Yelp appreciated how the team "spackled, primed and painted" while keeping everything covered and organized throughout the project. Interior Finishing NYC reviewers describe Dorian and his team leaving spaces spotless after complex decorative finish work, with Jen noting that "the place was spotless after the job was complete." For homeowners in Forest Hills, NY who worry about the disruption a painting project might cause, these contractors consistently demonstrate a commitment to leaving homes cleaner than they found them.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Forest Hills, NY. Interior Finishing NYC customers often describe the pricing as fair and competitive for the level of specialty work delivered. Jeff Ramras praised the "upfront and fair pricing" for his interior door and closet painting project. Precision Painting Plus of Queens receives similar feedback, with multiple reviewers describing the estimates as reasonable and transparent. Danielle Friedman found "working with Amy and Brandon was a pleasure" and highlighted the straightforward pricing with no surprises. The company also offers interest-free financing, which several customers mention as a helpful option.

Outstanding Painting LLC falls in what customers describe as the middle of the market, not the cheapest but offering strong value. Miguel noted the lime wash painting came with a fair price and thorough explanation of the process. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp consistently earns praise for affordable pricing on large projects, with Pamela Matzner calling the company "affordable, punctual and impeccable" when it comes to prep work and execution. Tim Cmmings, a long-time repeat customer, described the pricing as "extremely fair" across multiple projects. For homeowners in Forest Hills, NY comparing quotes, these contractors offer a range of price points while maintaining quality that reviewers describe as well worth the investment.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp