About McCarthy Painting Co
Older homes in Marin County and San Francisco present challenges that go well beyond a fresh coat of paint. Moss, mildew, lime deposits, and hidden lead paint require a contractor who knows how to identify problems before they become costly failures. McCarthy Painting Co. has handled these conditions across hundreds of residential and commercial properties since the company opened its doors in 1969.
The crew teams, several with tenures spanning decades, take a preparation-first approach to every project. Surface contaminants are addressed, dry rot is repaired, and the right coatings are selected for each substrate before any brushwork begins. Homeowners in San Rafael, Mill Valley, Sausalito, and surrounding communities work with dedicated painter pairs who stay on-site from start to finish.
On the commercial side, the company serves clients including Autodesk, GitHub, BioMarin, and Nike, handling office complexes, retail spaces, and multi-unit buildings throughout the greater Bay Area. An EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm and California CSLB License holder, McCarthy Painting backs its work with the same integrity its founder Fred McCarthy built the business on.
Updated: 06-10-2026
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
What sets McCarthy Painting apart when handling complex exterior projects on older Marin County homes?
Homeowners describe thorough surface preparation that goes beyond a basic wash. CB Bohn noted that the estimator tested the existing paint for lead before quoting the job and explained the full containment and disposal process. Lynne Smith reported that the crew spent an entire week on prep, replacing damaged wood and shingles before any paint was applied. Victoria Sturiale observed the team was very detail oriented with the prep work on the exterior which was significant.
How do the husband-and-wife and long-tenured painter teams affect project quality?
Customers frequently name specific crews and their impact on the finished product. Kate Mailbox described Miguel and Griselda working so quietly, at times I forgot there was someone at the house. Kimberley Marquis noted that Miguel has been with us about 20 years, Nelson about 5. Multiple reviewers praise the consistency and craftsmanship that comes from experienced, dedicated pairs rather than rotating subcontractors.
How responsive is the McCarthy Painting office team when questions come up during a project?
Reviewers mention office staff by name. Lisa Beckstead wrote that Mariah in the office was on top of everything, calls returned promptly and that Robbie was responsive in overseeing the job. Chris Ward confirmed that Robbie and Mariah were very responsive when we had questions. Josiah Thompson added that Mariah and Robbie were so awesome and helpful throughout the process.
Can McCarthy Painting help homeowners who need both painting and structural repair on the same project?
Several reviews confirm combined painting and repair work. Patrice Taylor described receiving painting, wood rot repair, power washing in a single project that exceeded expectations. Bill Wilhelm noted that Nelson did an excellent job replacing dry rot along with anything else we needed. Anne Sparler reported the crew removed a door and replaced a window with expert care alongside the painting work.
What do customers say about color selection guidance and working within tight timelines?
Aisha Stephenson described how the team helped select the right shades for the trim and cabinets to match our chosen wall colors and even worked long hours and a weekend to meet a move-in deadline. Cynthia Trader noted the painters provided 4 color samples after the sanding and offered their professional opinion. Patrick D. recalled a painter who suggested reversing his color choices, and he was glad he listened.
How do returning customers describe their experience compared to the first project?
Nina Sky, a returning customer, wrote that the experience was smooth, professional, and stress-free and that she already knows exactly who to call for the next job. Isae Wada stated simply, We always go with McCarthy. Their care and attention sets them apart. Paul Hall, who had previously used the company for interior and exterior work, called the additional deck refinishing work superb.
How does McCarthy Painting handle negative feedback or disputed reviews?
The one substantive negative review from Lily, claiming a rude interaction, received a measured professional response stating the company cannot find any record of an interaction and inviting direct contact to understand the situation. Two additional 1-star ratings were left without text or context. The overall pattern shows a 4.8-star average across 70 Google reviews with 67% of reviews receiving owner responses.
What is the current licensing and business entity status for McCarthy Painting?
McCarthy Painting holds California CSLB License #268819 with a C-33 Painting and Decorating classification, active through 10/31/2026. The entity is registered as MC CARTHY PAINTING INC, a Corporation, at 126 Front St, San Rafael, CA 94901. The California Secretary of State lists McCarthy Painting, Inc. (Entity #2111982) as Active with Good standing, formed in California, with initial filing date 6/11/1998.
-Verification Sources: CSLB, California Secretary of State