When Danielle Smethers moved into her new home while 7.5 months pregnant with twins, painting was impossible. Matthews' Painting stepped in and went "above and beyond to not only help fix a crack in the drywall but did a fantastic job painting." This willingness to help customers in challenging situations defines how owner Jason Matthews has operated his veteran-owned painting company since 1998.
The fully insured team carries $2 million in general liability coverage plus workers' compensation on all painters. Every painter is a W2 employee (not a subcontractor) who undergoes background checks and drug screening before and during employment. Crew leaders Amanda, Jamey, Roger, and Trevor handle projects ranging from single-room refreshes to complete commercial transformations, with a foreman present on each job site from start to finish.
Based in Leesburg, Indiana, the company serves Warsaw, Winona Lake, Syracuse, Columbia City, Goshen, Fort Wayne, and surrounding lake communities. Matthews' Painting offers a seven-year labor and material warranty plus four hours of free touch-up painting per year for life. The team is a member of Painting Contractors Association and holds registration as a painting contractor with the State of Indiana.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Customers consistently praise the communication systems. Team Jamey "kept us updated of what rooms they were doing that day" and "verified work order instructions with us so nothing misunderstood." The owner personally shares his cell phone number with clients, and crew leaders leave daily notes or send text updates with progress reports and photos for out-of-town homeowners.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple reviews highlight punctuality as a standout quality. William Jennings noted the crew was "very punctual on time" during a three-week project where they arrived "every day." Jake Odom confirms the crew was "punctual" throughout his project. Once work begins, crews stay until completion rather than starting and stopping for other jobs.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers mention thorough protection practices. Gary Petelle describes crews as "extremely careful with our furniture, flooring and trim work" while Crystal Darnell notes William and his team "took great care covering furniture, floors, counters, etc to protect from getting paint on them." Rebecca Smith's crew showed "extra cleanup effort" so her cats would not get into open paint cans.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Repeat business appears frequently in reviews. Jennie Rhea states "this is the 3rd time I have used Matthew's Painting and I will never use any other company." Caleb Niemi returned after three years, Steve Friedberg hired them again after nine years because their previous work "lasted 9 years (we were expecting 7)," and Deron Datzman notes it was his "second time" hiring them with plans for future projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Reviews highlight preparation as a distinguishing factor. Toby Popenfoose describes Rob and Jamey doing "a stupendous job on surface prep with techniques I have never been aware of and the phenomenal quality of their work shows." Dustin Albert mentions "meticulous planning was put into the job" to ensure alignment on expectations before work began.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Kay Mac specifically praises precision work, stating "I am so particular about attention to detail and perfect lines and Matthews painting exceeded my expectations." Hillary Pohl describes the crew's "attention to detail" during drywall restoration, and Karen Rust notes Amanda and her crew were "always consistently attentive to even the smallest details."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Several reviews address value directly. Clive Scott acknowledges they are "not the cheapest option but well worth the extra cost." Multiple customers tag their reviews with "reasonable price" or "great price" including Jake Odom, Linda Ellison, and Joe Glaser. Cristal Hall appreciated that Jason "was able to work with me on staying in our budget."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Kim Herbster's employer hired them to paint an entire office during business hours, describing how "the Matthews' team got the job done painlessly through clear communication and a cooperative spirit." Danielle Smethers praises the team for working around her family's situation while moving in, noting "they were clean and very professional."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Updated: 04-07-2026