Conley Brothers Painting
About Conley Brothers Painting
When a property management company needed their rental turnovers completed faster without compromising quality, they found Conley Brothers Painting. Based in Mishawaka, Indiana, this family-owned company has served the greater Michiana region since 2015, building a reputation across Elkhart, St. Joseph, LaPorte, and Porter Counties.
Owner Tim Conley leads a team that includes Sales Coordinator Scott and experienced crew members Rusty, Josh, Dave, Chris, William, and Juan. The company handles interior and exterior residential painting, kitchen cabinet refinishing, deck staining, wallpaper removal, drywall repair, and commercial projects ranging from apartment complexes to medical facilities.
The fully insured team uses Sherwin-Williams products and focuses on both high-end residential transformations and high-volume property maintenance work. Conley Brothers Painting has been featured in Professional Painting Contractor magazine and on WSBT-TV for their community involvement, including donating painting services to local nonprofits. The company offers free estimates throughout their four-county service area.
Updated: 01-30-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Conley Brothers Painting
Q: Does Conley Brothers Painting show up on time and finish projects when promised?
Punctuality appears consistently throughout reviews. One customer noted the crew was "on time every day" while another emphasized they "SHOW UP ON TIME" for every project. A property manager who worked with them for nearly two years mentioned the "turnaround time has been a huge asset" for their business. Multiple reviews confirm projects finish on schedule or early.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: How does Conley Brothers Painting handle older homes with plaster walls or challenging surfaces?
Reviews show experience with historic properties. One homeowner with a 113-year-old home reported Conley Brothers "took the time to repair everything very well" on plaster walls with "small holes and some cracking/crumbling." The customer stated their "walls look brand new" after the work. The team handles drywall repair, wallpaper removal, and surface preparation as part of their painting services.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about Conley Brothers Painting's cabinet refinishing work?
Cabinet work receives strong praise. One repeat customer who used them "three times" specifically mentioned "they have painted our cabinets too" along with interior work. Another noted their kitchen cabinets were completed alongside exterior and interior painting, describing the team as "professional, friendly" throughout multiple projects. The company offers cabinet refinishing as a cost-effective alternative to full renovation.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Conley Brothers Painting work with real estate agents and property managers?
Yes, professional referrals appear frequently. One real estate agent stated they "have used their services for numerous projects" and remain "consistently impressed with their reliability and competitive pricing." A property manager handling apartment communities described the team as "extremely professional" with no resident complaints. Reviews mention pre-sale painting, rental turnovers, and investor properties.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Who are the crew members at Conley Brothers Painting and what do customers say about them?
Reviews frequently mention specific team members by name. Customers praise "Rusty, Juan and William" for being "prompt, professional" and doing "a great job." Others highlight Josh as a crew leader who was "very good and conscientious" and mention Dave completing projects quickly. Tim handles estimates and communication while Scott coordinates scheduling.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Conley Brothers Painting handle communication throughout projects?
Communication earns consistent praise. One customer described Tim and his team as "great communicators, so friendly and finished on time." Another noted Tim "communicated the details of the job clearly and was very responsive throughout the entire process." The company offers text messaging and phone consultations, with Tim personally handling quotes and project coordination.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Conley Brothers Painting handle commercial and multi-unit projects?
Commercial experience is well-documented. A former maintenance supervisor described using them for apartment properties across "Mishawaka, South Bend, Granger and Elkhart" where they could "turn out two units per day with outstanding work." One medical facility praised them for being "flexible with your schedules" and transforming "a boring ol' facility to a more fun and cheerful place."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about Conley Brothers Painting's pricing and value?
Value perception appears positive throughout reviews. One customer described their quote as "a reasonable price" while a property manager noted "the pricing is more than fair." Multiple reviews use phrases like "reasonably priced" and "competitive pricing." A customer who received exterior and deck staining work stated it was "well worth the money to get a quality job done fast."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 01-30-2026