When commercial client McKenzie Harris needed her skilled nursing facility painted, Brothers Colors Painting delivered what she called a "5 star job service" with a team that was "detail oriented and efficient." This commitment to both residential and commercial excellence defines how owner Patrick Eby has built the company since 2015.
Brothers Colors Painting operates from their South Bend headquarters at 3921 Eastmont Dr, serving the greater St. Joseph County area including Mishawaka, Granger, Elkhart, Goshen, and Plymouth. The company handles everything from single-room refreshes to complete exterior transformations, with particular expertise in cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall repair, and pressure washing. Project estimators Nick and Mario coordinate scheduling while crew leaders Joel, Jamie, Chris, and Connor manage job sites.
The fully licensed, bonded, and insured team is BBB Accredited and maintains an A+ rating with zero complaints. They partner with premium paint brands including Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, Behr, and PPG.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Communication stands out as a defining characteristic. Ben Fouch noted their "average response time to inquiries was under an hour" and praised "unprompted daily updates on the project." Taryn DeBlaay echoed this, stating the "communication before, during and after was above and beyond." Owner Patrick and estimators Nick and Mario maintain direct contact with homeowners from estimate through completion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The team demonstrates flexibility when obstacles emerge. Kevin Ray shared that when an "unforeseen obstacle" occurred, instead of rescheduling, "they found a way to make it happen." Dennis Schoetmer experienced this firsthand when his crew discovered improperly installed seam tape. Rather than a quick fix, "they redid all the seams" to ensure lasting quality.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cleanup receives consistent praise across reviews. Taryn DeBlaay noted "they put everything back the way it was before they started the project." Mary Shoe confirmed the crew "took great care with my home, cleaned up afterwards and went beyond my expectations." Multiple reviewers mention the team protecting furniture and leaving spaces spotless.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Specific crew members receive repeated recognition by name. Emily H praised Joel and Jamie who "took such great care with the house, with my dog, and in their communications." Alison Thigpen highlighted Joel's work making "50-year old woodwork look like new." Julie Welsh appreciated how Joel and Jamie "rolled with the flow" when coordinating with other contractors. The pattern shows consistent crews building relationships with customers.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Value emerges as a consistent theme without sacrificing quality. Marilyn Pozgay chose them because they were "the most cost effective for our smaller home" after getting multiple estimates. Ben Fouch noted the company was "flexible on pricing to ensure we did not blow through our budget" during significant wallpaper removal. Jordan Shultz summarized that "their prices are tough to beat."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The company demonstrates expertise across specialty work. Catherine Emmel had her "dark, outdated cabinets" transformed by Chris and Tavon, calling the result a "bright new kitchen." Karen Fiechtner had paneling painted over so seamlessly "you could not tell there had been paneling." Alexis Torrance trusted them with her historic home's interior, praising Joel's "attention to detail."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Commercial experience spans diverse industries. McKenzie Harris hired them for her skilled nursing facility where the team proved "detail oriented and efficient" with daily compliments on their work. Cole Huth's fire department used them for training tower painting. The company also handles HOA projects, office complexes, and retail spaces throughout the South Bend region.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Repeat business and loyalty appear throughout reviews. Benjamin S. Stover returned after moving back from Florida, noting he "used them years ago" and chose them again. Nikhil Patankar "used them 7 years ago to paint my entire house...and again recently." Tamara dowd has been "using them for years to paint my rental homes" citing their dependability.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 04-07-2026