Rodgers Painting
Updated: 11-17-2025
About Rodgers Painting
Recognized as one of Paducah's highest-rated painting contractors with over 50 five-star Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, Rodgers Painting has built exceptional standing across western Kentucky. The third-generation family business, founded in 1964 by James "Buster" Rodgers and now led by son Billy and grandson Bryce, brings sixty years of trade knowledge to both residential and commercial projects throughout Paducah and Lexington.
The company handles everything from single-room refreshes to complex historic restorations. When a 125-year-old Victorian home needed paint and carpentry repairs, crews completed intricate column work and 30-foot-high patches that other contractors avoided. Reviews consistently mention cabinet refinishing that transforms dated kitchens, exterior painting that makes neighborhoods take notice, and water damage repairs customers didn't know were possible. Crews arrive as early as 7:00 AM and work full days, taking brief lunches on-site to maintain momentum.
What distinguishes Rodgers Painting is straightforward pricing that reflects actual value. When one homeowner received $3,000 quotes from two competitors for trim touch-up work, Rodgers priced the same job at $1,200. Owner Bryce Rodgers personally handles estimates and color consultations while painters like Kyle, Austin, Christian, and Jeff execute the detailed work. The A+ BBB rating and consistent five-star feedback reflect a contractor who prioritizes honest assessments over inflated proposals, turning first-time customers into long-term clients who return for multiple projects.
Updated: 11-17-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Rodgers Painting
Q: Does Rodgers Painting actually arrive early and work full days like reviews claim?
Multiple customers mention crews arriving between 7:00 and 7:30 AM and working until 5:00 or 6:00 PM. Isabel notes workers had "a brief lunch on the premises" and describes their schedule as "arriving at 7-7:30 am and not leaving until 5 or 6 pm." Gene mentions they "took exactly the one hour lunch break they planned." This work ethic appears consistent across projects rather than occasional.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Rodgers Painting's pricing compare to other Paducah contractors?
Stone Johnson specifically compared quotes and found significant differences. He received estimates of "almost $3k" from two other painting companies for trim touch-up and filling nail holes, while Rodgers priced the identical work at "$1200." He describes this as "very fair and reasonable" and notes the quality matched the lower price. Multiple reviews mention fair or reasonable pricing without surprise charges.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What makes Rodgers Painting's cabinet refinishing different from replacement?
Reviews show dramatic transformations that convince homeowners they've avoided expensive replacements. S.L. Martin describes door refinishing results, while Teresa mentions cabinet painting alongside interior work. The company uses specialized techniques that refresh existing cabinets rather than pushing costly renovations. Customer feedback suggests the finished appearance rivals new installations at a fraction of replacement cost.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Can Rodgers Painting handle complex historic restoration projects?
William Coscarelli's 125-year-old Victorian home required both painting and carpentry repairs on ten original columns and 30-foot-high patches. He describes the work as challenging, noting "The house is not easy to work on," yet praises how crews handled the complexity. The company corrected "sloppy work left by the carpenters who did the door installation" according to another customer, showing capability beyond basic painting.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Why do customers mention specific crew members like Kyle, Austin, and Christian by name?
Customers identify painters by name when individual performance stands out. Teresa specifically praises "Austin, Christian and Jeff" as "outstanding," noting she had "no qualms of leaving them here if I had to run errands." Mary Beth Schroeder mentions Kyle's professionalism, stating "Kyle cleaned everything so I did not have any cleanup work." Rita Giles describes Kyle as "pleasant, sweet" with "excellent" painting quality. This name recognition suggests consistent crew assignments rather than rotating workers.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Rodgers Painting communicate during projects?
Isabel describes "immediate" communication with supervisors and crew members. Teresa mentions they "called to let us know what time they would be here." Jessica highlights "top notch" communication as evidence they "care about customer satisfaction." The company appears to provide schedule updates, arrival notifications, and address concerns as they arise rather than leaving customers guessing about progress or timing.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Rodgers Painting handle negative feedback professionally?
Richard Hendley's review noting "several spots missed and a couple sloppy drywall repairs" received a professional response acknowledging the issues. The company apologized, stated it didn't meet their standards, offered to "make it right," and committed to scheduling a return visit at no charge. This direct accountability without defensiveness demonstrates their approach to service recovery when work falls short of expectations.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What's behind the consistent mentions of Rodgers Painting leaving properties cleaner than they found them?
Beverly notes crews "made sure that everything was just the way we wanted it to be" while fixing water damage that existed for years. Gene describes "They cleaned up at the end of each day." Multiple reviews reference thorough cleanup, protected surfaces, and attention to not leaving a mess. This pattern suggests daily cleanup protocols rather than end-of-project scrambling, maintaining livable conditions throughout multi-day jobs.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews