Five Star Painting of Mandeville
About Five Star Painting of Mandeville
Barry Blumenthal's review captures what defines Five Star Painting of Mandeville: "A large part of life is showing up." His crew received text messages every morning with arrival times. Two painters worked his exterior independently but coordinated when steadying ladders. The work finished on time with no mess left behind. This operational consistency, rather than bold marketing claims, built their 4.9 star average across more than 80 Google reviews.
Owner Brian Ammerman acquired the Mandeville and New Orleans territories in 2020 after running successful Five Star franchises in Illinois. Project managers Axel and Jose handle daily site oversight. Larry provides on-site estimates that Brandon Sita described as "significantly better than other quotes received," sometimes thousands below competitors. Color consultant Nicole helps customers navigate paint selections, noted by Julie Knesel as "an absolute pleasure" who "knows her stuff." From their 153 Lochmere Drive location, the team covers Mandeville, Covington, Hammond, Slidell, and surrounding St. Tammany Parish communities with projects ranging from single door repaints to complete 2,394 square foot interior transformations.
The reviews consistently reveal positive insights: Elise Taylor hired them twice. Pattie Stoddard appears in two separate reviews spanning different years. Raymond Kaufmann's cabinets looked "factory finished." Marie Leefe's project manager answered texts quickly and checked daily despite weather delays on her exterior job. The operation runs primarily through word of mouth, backed by a 2-year workmanship warranty and the kind of punctual, communicative service that transforms one-time customers into repeat clients.
Updated: 10-31-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Five Star Painting of Mandeville
Q: Does Five Star Painting of Mandeville actually show up on time?
Punctuality appears as a defining characteristic throughout customer feedback. Multiple reviewers emphasize crews arriving when promised, with Barry Blumenthal noting they "texted their approximate arrival times every day." The team maintains consistent schedules throughout multi day projects, and Brandon Sita specifically praised how "everyone showed up when they said they would" during his exterior painting project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What about their pricing compared to other contractors?
Competitive pricing emerges as a consistent theme. Jessica Connolly reported they were "several $1000 cheaper than another reputable painting company" for her exterior work. Brandon Sita described their quote as "significantly better than other quotes received" and noted their "prices were among the best that we received." Chris Olivier called the pricing "fantastic."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Five Star Painting of Mandeville handle project management and communication?
Project oversight receives particular attention in reviews. Axel, frequently mentioned as project manager, "checked the work numerous times and kept us advised throughout the process" according to Charles Skillern. Marie Leefe noted her project manager "came by daily and always answered my texts quickly." Brandon Sita described Axel as "incredibly engaged the entire process," checking in every morning and conducting final walkthroughs.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What's the quality like on cabinet refinishing specifically?
Cabinet work generates strong reactions. Raymond Kaufmann stated their "cabinets looks factory finished, brand new" after painting three bathrooms, kitchen, laundry, and mudroom. Harold Drivon couldn't "ask for a better job" on kitchen cabinets and a small island. However, Raquel T.'s detailed two star review documents incomplete cabinet work, including unpainted drawer undersides and color matching issues between doors and bases, with follow up communication breaking down.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do they handle both small touch ups and large whole house projects?
Project range spans considerably. Pattie Stoddard had a "2 day paint job completed in one" for family room and kitchen combo work. Brian Wallace's crew completed "entire interior, 2394 sf of walls, ceilings, trim and doors with 2 coats each in 7 days." Curtis Monson hired them for just "exterior doors and columns." The operation scales from targeted refreshes to complete residential transformations.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What about their cleanup and respect for the property?
Protection and cleanliness receive consistent praise. Carla Benelli appreciated how they "treated my home with respect." Michael Boutwell noted they "pressure washed the home and prepped really well." Marie Leefe observed "their work was excellent and their attitudes were even better." Multiple reviewers specifically mention daily cleanup, with Hattie Laverne stating they "cleaned everything each day."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 10-31-2025