Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Allan Painting
Recognized as one of North Andover's highest-rated painting contractors, Allan Painting operates with a consistency that comes from five decades of focused work in the same community. Owner Allan Marcus started the business in 1974 at age seventeen in West Peabody, relocating to North Andover in 1991 where the company built its reputation throughout the Merrimack Valley. With over 50 five-star Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, plus an A+ BBB rating maintained since 2010, the company established itself through repeat customer relationships rather than aggressive marketing.
The fully licensed and insured team specializes in both residential interior and exterior painting, with particular expertise in cabinet refinishing, popcorn ceiling removal, deck staining, and wallpaper services. Foreman Dan leads the crew alongside painters William, Jerry, and Pete. Customers consistently mention the thorough preparation work, noting how crews protect surfaces with multiple layers and leave properties "cleaner than when they started."
What distinguishes Allan Painting is the operational stability. The same core team has worked together for years, arriving punctually each morning and maintaining daily communication about progress. Allan personally handles color consultations and project oversight while his crew executes the detailed work. Reviews frequently mention that while they're "not the lowest cost painters on the block," the quality justifies the investment. The company serves eleven towns throughout the North Andover area within a 25-mile radius.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Multiple long-term customers mention consistency in crew members. Deena notes using Allan Painting "since 2010" with the same quality throughout. Charles reports working with Allan Painting "over 20 plus years" and loves that "in 12 years, only one person has changed in the crew." Dan, William, and Jerry appear repeatedly in reviews spanning multiple years, confirming the stable team composition Allan describes.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Allan personally guides color consultations rather than leaving decisions entirely to customers. Louise mentions Allan "patiently walked us through options while giving his own professional opinion." Deena describes how Allan picked colors for her exterior after she lived with a "hideous" color for ten years, stating she "absolutely LOVED IT" because "he knew the look I was going for." Jamie notes Allan "helped me to select colors and was very patient, allowing me to see several colors on the wall."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Preparation work receives consistent praise across reviews. Ken Davis mentions "prep work was thorough" and they kept "the job site immaculate." William Flanagan describes how the crew "took down and re-hang window treatment, light fixtures, speakers, switches" and "sanded all walls, took down wallpaper in the dining room." Multiple customers note the daily cleanup routine, with Jean stating crews "left the house clean" every day.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Allan demonstrates accountability through follow-up practices. Deena describes a situation where Allan returned to check the deck staining weeks later, felt it needed another coat, and had his crew return at no additional charge, stating "that's Allan." Amy notes Allan is "skilled at helping clients find the perfect color" and ensures satisfaction. The company maintains communication beyond project completion rather than disappearing after final payment.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The Yelp review from Cameron G. describes a cabinet project dispute involving hourly billing and an inexperienced employee. Allan's business model typically uses detailed estimates rather than purely hourly rates for established services. The single detailed negative review on Yelp contrasts with consistent five-star feedback across Google and Angi platforms, suggesting this represents an atypical experience rather than standard practice.
-Review Snippet Sources: Yelp
Multiple customers acknowledge Allan Painting costs more than budget options but emphasize value. One Angi reviewer states explicitly they're "not the lowest cost painters on the block" but adds they're "the best" and "that's why I keep bringing them back." Jack Foley notes "Allan's quote was the highest of the 3 I received" but chose them for quality, stating the work "delivered exactly that" and remains perfect years later.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
The company manages specialized work including historic home restoration. One customer describes painting a "200 year old house" with "wood trim, wainscoting, shelves, and a fireplace," praising Allan's team for their "understanding of an antique home." William Flanagan mentions they "replaced trim boards that were rotting" during exterior work. Services extend to cabinet refinishing, popcorn ceiling removal, wallpaper installation, and wood rot repair.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Customer retention appears exceptionally strong throughout reviews. Deena reports using Allan Painting "since 2010" for both interior and exterior work. Charles has worked with them "over 20 plus years." Alan Seale states "I've been working with Allan Painting since 2012" across two houses. Amanda and Luke have used them "since we moved to North Andover almost 10 years ago" for "multiple projects." The repeat business pattern validates the quality consistency claims.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 04-07-2026