Oak City Coatings
Updated: 11-08-2025
About Oak City Coatings
Founded in 2021 by Nick O'Keefe after spending 11 years with Sherwin-Williams in both management and sales, Oak City Coatings brings manufacturer-level expertise directly to Raleigh-area properties. With well over 50 five-star Google reviews, this family-owned operation specializes in residential and commercial painting where thorough prep work and color consultation distinguish every project.
The company handles everything from wallpaper removal and wood rot repair to commercial studio transformations and historic home limewashing. Reviews consistently highlight Nick's detailed estimates that outline each step, morning arrival confirmations, and crews who shield vehicles without being asked. Customers mention projects finishing ahead of schedule, with one Pure Barre studio owner noting the space looked "fresh, clean, and brighter than ever" after interior work.
What separates Oak City Coatings is the two-hour color consultation process complete with 8x10 swatches delivered to your home, allowing you to live with color choices before committing. Using exclusively Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore products, they serve Holly Springs, Fuquay-Varina, Apex, Cary, Raleigh, Morrisville, and Garner. BBB Accredited since 2021, they've built their reputation on transparent communication and finding rotted trim other contractors overlook.
Updated: 11-08-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Oak City Coatings
Q: Do Oak City Coatings' estimates really stand out from competitors?
Multiple customers who compared quotes emphasize the difference. "Nick's estimate was by far the most thorough and easier to really see what they would be doing and what value I would be getting" according to one homeowner. Another appreciated the estimate "outlining exactly each step his team will take." This detail-oriented approach continues through project completion with transparent communication at every phase.
Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Thumbtack
Q: How does Oak City Coatings' color consultation process work?
The service includes a two-hour specialist visit to review options and steer customers away from choices that wouldn't work in practice. Then they "send us 8x10 swatches of the colors we chose, so we could live with them for a few days" before finalizing. One customer valued how the consultant "gave us tools to use to really consider colors on our home" rather than just picking from a color wheel.
Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: What makes Oak City Coatings' prep work different?
Customers consistently notice exceptional surface preparation. "They were meticulous about prep work and their clean-up was flawless" wrote one reviewer with an older home full of wallpaper. Another praised crews "taking great care to ensure that every surface was properly prepped, primed, and caulked." Nick frequently identifies hidden issues, with one homeowner noting he "found many more" rotted pieces than other contractors spotted.
Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: Can Oak City Coatings handle projects of different sizes and complexity?
The company manages both quick turnarounds and complex renovations effectively. Some jobs finish remarkably fast, like interior painting "completed in 1 day" or a garage done "in half a day." Yet they also handle week-long exterior projects and specialized work like brick limewashing. A commercial client noted they "went above and beyond to ensure everything was completed to a high standard" on their studio renovation.
Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Thumbtack
Q: How does Oak City Coatings communicate throughout the project?
Communication receives consistent praise. The team provides "morning confirmation texts" before arriving, "stayed in regular contact giving me updates" during weather delays, and discusses "progress of the job and any concerns" daily. Multiple reviewers mention knowing exactly what to expect each day, with one emphasizing "communication and transparency on every level" from estimate through final walkthrough.
Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Oak City Coatings work on commercial properties or just homes?
They handle both residential and commercial projects across multiple industries. A Pure Barre studio owner praised their "quality commercial painting with a personal touch" during interior work. The company serves property management firms, HOAs, healthcare facilities, office buildings, retail spaces, and religious institutions. Their approach treats commercial clients as "business partners" rather than just another contractor on the schedule.
Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Website