Oak City Coatings
Chooz Score Insights
Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Oak City Coatings
About Oak City Coatings
When Margaret Kellner needed her two-story front hall painted, Oak City Coatings' color specialist spent two hours reviewing options and steering her from choices that "just wouldn't have worked in practice." Then came 8x10 swatches delivered home, letting her live with colors before committing. The crew arrived "friendly, courteous, professional" and completed the work quickly. This consultation-first approach defines how Nick O'Keefe operates, recognizing behind every project is someone reimagining their space.
Owner Nick O'Keefe founded the company in 2021 after 11 years with Sherwin-Williams in management and sales. The operation handles residential and commercial painting from wallpaper removal to brick limewashing. Nick personally conducts estimates, often finding rotted trim competitors miss. His detailed proposals outline each step, and crews text confirmation before arrivals.
The family-owned company is BBB Accredited since 2021. Using Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore products exclusively, they serve Holly Springs, Fuquay-Varina, Apex, Cary, Raleigh, Morrisville, and Garner within the greater Raleigh area.
Updated: 01-06-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Oak City Coatings
Q: How do Oak City Coatings' estimates compare to other painting companies?
Multiple customers who obtained proposals from several companies emphasize the difference. One homeowner stated "Nick's estimate was by far the most thorough and easier to really see what they would be doing and what value I would be getting for my money" after comparing highly-rated contractors. Another appreciated the estimate "outlining exactly each step his team will take to do the job," showing professionalism before any work began.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Thumbtack
Q: How fast does Oak City Coatings complete projects without sacrificing quality?
Completion times vary by scope but efficiency patterns emerge consistently. Interior painting jobs finish "completed in 1 day" while a garage wrapped up "in half a day." Even larger exterior projects often conclude ahead of schedule. A commercial studio owner noted the team was "professional, efficient, and incredibly detail-oriented" while transforming their space quickly without compromising the finished results customers describe.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Thumbtack
Q: Why does Oak City Coatings find structural issues other contractors overlook?
Nick personally walks properties during estimates and identifies problems competitors miss. One customer noted he "found many more" rotted pieces than expected, despite other companies already providing quotes. Another mentioned Oak City "won't take short cuts saying a piece of trim or siding is fine when really it needs replaced." This thoroughness protects the customer's investment through honest assessment rather than securing easy sales.
-Review Snippet Sources: Facebook, Google Reviews
Q: Does Oak City Coatings handle commercial properties differently than residential work?
The company treats commercial clients as business partners rather than quick turnover jobs. A Pure Barre studio owner praised their "quality commercial painting with a personal touch" during interior work, noting they "went above and beyond to ensure everything was completed to a high standard." Oak City serves property management firms, HOAs, healthcare facilities, office buildings, and retail spaces while maintaining the same detailed approach defining their residential projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Website
Q: What makes Oak City Coatings' color consultation process worth the time investment?
The service extends far beyond selecting shades from fan decks. Customers receive a "2hr visit to go over colors" with a specialist who steers them from problematic choices, then Oak City sends "8x10 swatches of the colors we chose, so we could live with them for a few days" before finalizing. One homeowner valued receiving "tools to use to really consider colors on our home" rather than quick recommendations that might fail long-term.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: How does Oak City Coatings maintain communication once projects begin?
Communication continues daily after work starts. Crews provide "morning confirmation texts" before arriving, Nick "stayed in regular contact giving me updates" when weather caused delays, and the team discusses "progress of the job and any concerns" each day according to reviewers. One customer emphasized experiencing "communication and transparency on every level" from initial estimate through final walkthrough, standing out in an industry known for poor follow-through.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Thumbtack
Updated: 01-06-2026