Teall Painting
About Teall Painting
Serving the unique architectural styles of Long Island's South Shore communities, Teall Painting understands the specific challenges Nassau and Western Suffolk County properties face. Owner Charlie Cascio named the company after his five children (Tyler, Ella, Ava, Lucas, and Lia), reflecting the family values that drive this fully licensed and insured painting and restoration operation.
The company specializes in residential and commercial painting, with particular expertise in cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall repair, and light carpentry. Production manager Douglas handles complex drywall work while crew leaders Thomas, Anthony, and Omar oversee job sites. Senior painters including Victor, Rene, Oscar, Celcino, and Sebastian bring extensive experience to every project. Reviews consistently mention these team members by name.
Teall Painting offers a 2-year warranty and 100% satisfaction guarantee on all workmanship. The team uses premium Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore paints and provides virtual estimates for customer convenience. Based in Massapequa Park, they serve communities including Garden City, Huntington, Babylon, Farmingdale, and surrounding Long Island areas.
Updated: 01-12-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Teall Painting
Q: Does Teall Painting handle commercial projects like salons and fitness studios?
Recent commercial work demonstrates their business capabilities. Nicole Fonovich raved that her salon renovation results were "stunning" with a space that "feels brand new, elevated, and beautifully finished." F45 Training Carle Place called hiring them "one of the best decisions" for renovating two fitness studios. Joe Reale praised their "professionalism, organization, and customer service" for his business.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What makes Teall Painting's estimates different from other contractors?
Transparency defines their quoting process. Michael Deerr was "impressed by how detailed the estimate was" noting "everything was itemized and spelled out, so there weren't any surprises." Steve Golub emphasized "the quote is the quote" even when additional wood repairs were needed. Greg Schaeffer found them to have "the best pricing" among six estimates he received.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What happened with the negative Facebook review about Teall Painting?
One Facebook reviewer reported a missed appointment after a rescheduled consultation. This represents the only negative feedback among 83 total reviews across all platforms. The pattern across other reviews shows consistent punctuality, with customers noting crews "arrived on time" and "showed up early and got down to work promptly" according to multiple reviewers.
-Review Snippet Sources: Facebook, Google Reviews
Q: Why do so many Teall Painting reviews mention painter Victor by name?
Victor receives standout recognition from customers. Michael Deerr observed "it was obvious that Victor is a master of his craft" and felt "fortunate to have him painting our home." Priya Sridevi noted "Victor painted our kitchen cabinets and he did a fantastic job." Barbara Rosen described him as "right on time and a pleasure to work with."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Teall Painting handle cleanup during and after projects?
Cleanliness receives frequent praise from customers. Rosemarie obrien mentioned crews who "cleaned up everyday like they weren't there." Cindy Rantal described how they "protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless." The company uses drop cloths, plastic sheathing, and builder's paper as standard practice on every job.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Teall Painting accommodate customers with complicated schedules?
Flexibility emerges as a consistent theme in reviews. Lauren Morales appreciated them being "super flexible with my tight calendar." Frank Servidio explained how "they made accommodations around our schedule" spreading a 5-day project over 10 days. Michael Deerr noted Victor "worked late most nights (with our permission!) to finish the project as quickly as possible."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Teall Painting show up on time and stick to the project schedule?
Punctuality appears consistently across reviews. Susan M. noted the "crew showed up on time each day" and the "job was started and completed on time." Cindy Rantal confirmed "they were on time each day" while Craig Fryman praised how they "completed the job in a timely fashion." Charlie provides daily check-ins throughout projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Teall Painting do anything unexpected that surprises customers?
Small touches stand out beyond quality work. Dame Cascone mentioned receiving "a nice surprise" with a "cookie delivery" during their project. Multiple customers highlight Charlie's hands-on involvement, with Mitch noting Charlie repainted his gas fireplace cover himself rather than delegating it. The company emphasizes creating what they call the "Teall Experience."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 01-12-2026