Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County
About Precision Painting Plus of Long Island
Jonathan Richards and Michael Zilberman have built a painting company with over 150 five-star Google reviews through consistent practices and professional execution since 2007. Project managers like Matt Zicherman and Dave Malone providing detailed estimates within 24 hours, crews showing up on scheduled days ready to work, and painters like Jose and Eric taking pride in thorough prep work before any brushes touch walls. Reviews mention crews "cleaning up exposed nail heads and cracks" before painting, installing drop cloths to protect floors and furniture, and completing final walk-through inspections to ensure customer satisfaction.
When Ruth needed cedar shakes replaced and painted on a tight timeline before the holidays, Precision Painting Plus not only squeezed the project into their schedule but had the crew cut raw shakes to size, install them, and paint the entire house front in a single day. They cleaned up the same day and "left everything looking perfect." That combination of skilled carpentry and painting execution demonstrates the company's expanded service capabilities beyond standard interior and exterior work.
Projects range from single-room refreshes to complete commercial transformations across Long Island, NYC, and expanding nationally to New Jersey, Connecticut, Florida, Texas, and California. The fully licensed team (Suffolk County License #H0459050000), A+ BBB accredited since 2015, operates as a Benjamin Moore preferred supplier and offers 18-month interest-free financing for larger projects. Customers repeatedly describe the experience as "professional from start to finish" with crews who work efficiently while maintaining daily communication through dedicated project managers.
Updated: 12-12-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Precision Painting Plus of Long Island
Q: Does Precision Painting Plus of Long Island really fix imperfections before painting?
Surface preparation stands out consistently in reviews. One repeat customer notes they "do a very thorough job of fixing all the small imperfections before they begin painting walls or moldings" and that "their attention to these small details are what sets them apart." Crews address nail pops, cracks, and settling damage before any paint is applied. This prep work often goes unnoticed until customers see how clean the finished surfaces look.
-Review Snippet Sources: Angi, Google Reviews
Q: How does Precision Painting Plus of Long Island handle project communication?
Project managers maintain direct contact throughout each job. One customer praised how their PM "kept me informed from the initial estimate through scheduling, implementation and completion." Eric and his team "always kept in touch, provided updates, made sure to ask before doing anything." Daily communication happens through dedicated project managers rather than leaving customers wondering about progress.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, HomeAdvisor
Q: What makes Precision Painting Plus of Long Island's cleanup practices notable?
Cleanup discipline appears frequently in feedback. Crews install drop cloths to protect floors and furniture before starting, and one customer described staff who "cleaned the home thoroughly, including mopping" at the end of each day. Another noted they were "very neat and tidy" while a third mentioned "no mess" after two coats were applied. Jobsite cleanliness is clearly a company standard, not an exception.
-Review Snippet Sources: Angi, HomeAdvisor, Google Reviews
Q: Does Precision Painting Plus of Long Island have repeat customers?
Multiple reviews mention returning for additional projects. One customer stated they've "hired them for more than a dozen projects, all of which I was very satisfied" and called themselves a "loyal customer who will only use Precision Painting for all our painting needs." Another reviewer immediately booked them to paint additional classrooms after the first job impressed them.
-Review Snippet Sources: Angi, Google Reviews
Q: How does Precision Painting Plus of Long Island handle tight deadlines?
The company demonstrates flexibility with scheduling. When one customer needed work done "right before holidays on a short timeline," Precision Painting Plus accommodated them and completed the project. Matt and other project managers "scheduled the job sooner than anyone else" according to another reviewer with urgent needs. The company appears willing to work around customer timelines when possible.
-Review Snippet Sources: Angi, HomeAdvisor
Q: Are there concerns about Precision Painting Plus of Long Island from negative reviews?
Some reviewers reported issues with cleanup quality and post-project responsiveness. One customer mentioned paint on window frames and doorknobs, while another noted warranty concerns went unaddressed after multiple contacts. The company responds professionally to Google reviews but BBB complaints show less consistent follow-through. Customers should document expectations in writing and maintain communication with project managers throughout.
-Review Snippet Sources: BBB, Angi, Yelp
Q: What services does Precision Painting Plus of Long Island offer beyond painting?
The company handles comprehensive home improvement including drywall installation and repair, power washing, wallpaper installation and removal, light carpentry, and flooring work. One reviewer noted their crew "replaced various areas of crown molding" and had "a carpenter come in who was excellent." They also cut and installed replacement cedar shakes for exterior work. This makes them a single-source option for multi-trade projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Website, Google Reviews, Angi
Q: Who are the crew members customers mention at Precision Painting Plus of Long Island?
Reviews consistently name specific team members. Project managers include Matt Zicherman, Dave Malone, John, and Eric. Painters mentioned by name include Jose, Nestor, Anthony, Joshua, Cristhian, and Fernando. Customers praise Cristhian for being "so talented" with "attention to every detail," while Anthony was described as "neat and detail oriented" who "takes pride in his work." Named crew accountability appears to be part of company operations.
-Review Snippet Sources: Angi, HomeAdvisor, Google Reviews
Updated: 12-12-2025