Brennan Home Painting & Restoration
About Brennan Home Painting & Restoration
When Bob and Judy needed their log home exterior stained, the project presented a challenge. Part was old work and the rest was new, unfinished wood. Jim Brennan provided the technical expertise to select a product that worked seamlessly across both surfaces. Bob described Jim as "a painter's painter" who "knows his craft to an unusual depth." This pattern of deep product knowledge solving complex problems appears throughout the company's reviews.
Owner Jim Brennan personally handles estimates, works on every job, and responds to virtually every customer review. A former special education teacher who spent two years in the Jesuit Volunteer Corps working with at-risk youth, Jim brings patience and clear communication to every consultation. Team members Tim, Harvey, and Cole assist on larger projects, with customers consistently mentioning the crew by name across reviews.
Brennan Home Painting serves the Finger Lakes region, including Canandaigua, Geneva, Naples, Penn Yan, and surrounding communities. Services include interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall repair, pressure washing, window glazing, and Victorian home restoration.
Updated: 01-12-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Brennan Home Painting & Restoration
Q: Why do customers consistently mention that Brennan Home Painting & Restoration owner Jim Brennan is personally on every job?
Jim operates as an owner-craftsman rather than a sales-focused contractor who hands jobs off to crews. Ted Aub's review captures this, noting Jim "doesn't mind working and getting dirty with his crew." Multiple customers describe Jim handling estimates through final walk-through personally. This hands-on approach means customers work directly with the decision-maker throughout their project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Brennan Home Painting & Restoration handle the historic Victorian homes common in the Finger Lakes area?
The company has extensive experience with Victorian properties, which present unique challenges including ornate trim, multiple paint layers, and weather-damaged wood. Marolyn Caldwell hired them for her 1880s Geneva Victorian that had "paint peeling on every board" and noted they were "thorough on trim, even painting in corners and under eves where needed coverage is often missed." Jim's window glazing expertise addresses the original windows these homes typically feature.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Website Testimonials
Q: What happens when customers need to make changes or additions during a Brennan Home Painting & Restoration project?
Reviews indicate flexibility with project modifications. Rodney D. noted that Jim "stuck with the job until it was completed even though we had a few add-ons while he was here." Deborah Schwarz mentioned that when her "job required an unexpected change of paint color," Jim "accommodated us with a smile." This adaptability appears consistently across customer feedback.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Website Testimonials
Q: Does Brennan Home Painting & Restoration show up when scheduled and complete work on time?
Punctuality emerges as one of the strongest patterns in reviews. Multiple customers specifically praise reliability, with Dr. Dale Kulick noting they "arrived early every day until the job was complete." Bob's review of his log home project confirmed Jim "got the job done on time, as he said he would." Ann Marie stated simply that Jim was "on time every day."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Q: How do Brennan Home Painting & Restoration prices compare to other painting contractors in the Canandaigua and Geneva areas?
Several customers mention getting multiple quotes before selecting Brennan. Rodney D. explained that "although he was not the lowest priced, I liked his approach the best." Michael Parsons noted the price was "very fair for all the work that was completed." Linda and Brad J. summarized their experience as "excellent quality for a great price." The pattern suggests mid-range pricing with quality justifying the investment.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Website Testimonials
Q: What specialized surfaces can Brennan Home Painting & Restoration handle that other contractors might avoid?
The company takes on challenging projects including log homes, aluminum siding, vinyl siding, and concrete staining. Bob praised Jim's ability to advise on products for his log home where "part was old work and the rest was new, unfinished wood." Derek's review mentions work on a pole barn. The company also handles unusual requests like painting metal ductwork and high two-story living rooms with difficult access.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi, Website
Q: How did Brennan Home Painting & Restoration respond to the negative reviews that appear in their feedback?
Two negative reviews exist, both involving situations where no painting work was actually performed. Norman's one-star review stemmed from a rental property development dispute. Lucille Lobue's review involved a pricing disagreement where Jim declined the job. In both cases, Jim responded professionally, explaining "I do not do that type of work" regarding rental properties. The negative reviews reflect business disagreements rather than workmanship complaints.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about cleanup and worksite conditions when Brennan Home Painting & Restoration completes a project?
Cleanup receives consistent praise across reviews. Jeff and Holly noted Jim "cleaned up like he was never there." Dr. Dale Kulick observed they were "cleaning up every trace of paint and work materials at the end of each day." Mark Glickman's commercial project review specifically mentioned that the crew "cleans up" as part of what makes them true professionals.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Website Testimonials
Updated: 01-12-2026