Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for J & S Painting Plus Inc
When first-time homebuyers close on a house and need interior painting done before the moving truck arrives, finding a contractor who can mobilize within days seems impossible. Matthew Conway experienced this scenario and found J & S Painting Plus delivered on a tight schedule, describing Jay as "great at helping us break the analysis paralysis we were having over paint colors while still making us feel empowered in our decisions."
Owner Jay Gisonni (Carl J. Gisonni) runs the Port Chester operation alongside office manager Kathy Gisonni, with crew leaders Sheki, Omar, and Mauricio handling job sites across two states. The company specializes in interior and exterior residential painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall repair, and wallpaper services. Incorporated in 2001, the team brings over two decades of experience to every project.
The BBB Accredited team is fully licensed and insured, holding both Westchester County and Connecticut Home Improvement Contractor licenses. They serve Westchester County, NY and Fairfield County, CT within a 30-mile radius of Port Chester.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Cabinet work generates strong praise across platforms. Youri Choi reported their kitchen cabinets were "done so well - our kitchen looks brand new." A rental property owner on Angi described how J & S "painted my old ugly oak cabinets" and transformed them so completely that "my neighbor came over and thought that I purchased new cabinets." Jay oversees cabinet color selection for these projects. -Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Reviews frequently name specific team members. Sheki (also spelled Shecki) leads many projects, with customers praising him as "professional, responsible, and a pleasure to work with." Omar works alongside Jay on interior projects. Jose handles carpentry and deck work. The consistency of names across reviews suggests stable, experienced crews rather than rotating subcontractors. -Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Multiple reviews highlight rapid response times. Eleanor Keiser closed on her house Tuesday, had Jay do a walkthrough the same day, and his team started "the next morning at 10am." Matthew Conway needed painting done "before the moving truck came" and Jay "got a team in to paint our house with a few days notice." The office staff, including Pam, handles scheduling efficiently. -Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The single 3-star review from Erin Biggins raised concerns about primer substitution and prep work. Owner Jay responded professionally, acknowledging the feedback without becoming defensive. The response pattern across platforms shows J & S addresses criticism directly. One customer whose initial concerns were addressed noted the work was ultimately "addressed and it looks excellent." -Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Cleanup receives consistent praise. One customer described the painter as "so clean and efficient that even in the middle of the job, when he left for the day the only indication that work was being done was the wall itself." An exterior project customer noted the crew "kept the perimeter clean" throughout the week-long job. Sheki's team "cleaned up every night." -Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Value comes up frequently in reviews. Matthew Conway found Jay's "rates were reasonable" while Eleanor Keiser noted "the price was very reasonable." One Angi reviewer who hired them for aluminum siding described the quote as "fair considering the high level of effort required, and in retrospect still feels right." Customers emphasize quality justifying cost. -Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Customers consistently mention strong communication patterns. One Angi reviewer noted Jay "was always available to answer any questions and dropped in to review the job from time to time" while finding "the office staff very prompt whenever I emailed them." Another described the experience as "very efficient and professional process" with the team being "very communicative." -Review Snippet Sources: Angi
Durability emerges as a theme in reviews. One Angi customer returned for deck re-staining after their exterior paint job, noting the "first was painting the house exterior and it's still holding up well 5 years later." Virginia Silinsky has used J & S for rental property maintenance across "4 apartments" over seven years, demonstrating long-term satisfaction with their work quality. -Review Snippet Sources: Angi, Google Reviews
J & S Painting Plus, Inc. is a Domestic Business Corporation registered with the New York State Department of State, DOS ID 2682713, with an Active status. The company was incorporated on September 24, 2001. They hold Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License No. WC-12397-H01 and Connecticut Home Improvement Contractor License No. 0574653. The registered address is 72 South Regent St, Port Chester, NY 10573, with Carl J. Gisonni listed as Chief Executive Officer. -Verification Sources: NY Department of State Division of Corporations, Westchester County Consumer Protection, Connecticut DCP eLicense
Updated: 04-07-2026