About Realtor's Choice Services
Owner Kyle Mitchell launched Realtors Choice Services to handle residential painting, staining, and exterior cleaning across the Greater Cincinnati metro. When homeowners reach out by phone, text, or the website contact form, Kyle handles the initial contact and schedules an on-site visit himself. Reviewers call him the "most responsive, genuine small business owner we've encountered in almost 30 years." He walks the project in person, discusses scope and color choices, then follows up with a written quote.
The company handles interior and exterior painting, cabinet work, drywall repair, and trim and soffit repair. The crew also stains decks, fences, wood siding, and log homes, and provides house washing, roof soft washing, gutter cleaning, and window cleaning. Reviewer Marla Kouche notes the team "didn't try to oversell" while Tara P points to Kyle's range across "my house, soffits, fascia, and window sills."
Realtors Choice Services is a BBB Accredited business and an Angi Approved contractor recognized with the 2025 Super Service Award. The team serves Batavia, Cincinnati, Loveland, Mason, Mount Orab, Amelia, Felicity, and surrounding communities.
Updated: 05-14-2026
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
How quickly does owner Kyle Mitchell respond when someone reaches out to Realtors Choice Services for an estimate?
Multiple customers describe Kyle as the first point of contact and praise his speed. Julie Williams writes that "Kyle was quick to respond to my inquiry which was awesome," and Lewis Egner calls him "the most responsive, genuine small business owner we've encountered in almost 30 years of owning our home." Tara P adds that her crew "came out the next day to get started" after she requested a fast turnaround.
What does the estimate and scheduling process look like with Realtors Choice Services from initial contact through project start?
Reviewers describe a straightforward path from inquiry to start date. Brad Morrissey notes that "the quotes were fast and the work was high quality," with "the projects completed faster than I was hoping." Meagan L on Angi thanks the team "for getting us on your schedule quickly." Bailey Drexler adds that the crew "completed my deck and fence repair project in the time promised and had great communication."
How do customers describe pricing and the quoting approach at Realtors Choice Services?
Customers consistently mention fair, transparent pricing. Marla Kouche writes that the crew "didn't try to oversell" and "did quality work at a reasonable price." Anthony Smith on Google notes "great quality with a better price," and Jeongwon J on Angi sums it up with "the price was reasonable. Kyle is professional, thoughtful, skillful, kind and dependable." Several reviewers mention getting fair quotes without pressure to add extra services.
Beyond painting, what other services do Realtors Choice Services customers mention having done?
Reviews span a wide range of exterior and repair work. Glenn Kuhlman writes that his "deck repair and house trim boards [were] replaced," and Tara P points to "my house, soffits, fascia, and window sills." Vince Cantrella had the team "repair some drywall issues, repair cabinets and paint," while Marko3d praises the crew for "a great job pressure washing the house" during exterior cleaning work.
How do Realtors Choice Services crews handle homeowners' spaces while a project is in progress?
Customers highlight care for the home as a recurring strength. Sue Ellen B on BBB notes that after a single-day living room project the team "left the room spotless," adding that they "wrangled the heavy stuff out and back in which I appreciated." Talya on Google describes that the crew "worked with so much care, treating my home with real respect." Joe Stokes echoes their "top-notch workmanship... conscientious of their safety and cleanliness."
Do Realtors Choice Services projects come in on time, even during difficult weather conditions?
Punctuality comes up often in reviews. Barbara B on Angi writes that the team "was reliable, and completed the job on time and on budget, during a brutal heat wave," and Barbara Boyne on Google describes work completed "over three days in brutal heat." Sherri Blatt sums up a common experience as "showed up on time. Got everything done. Looks great." Multiple reviewers describe consistent, on-time arrivals throughout the project.
What do Realtors Choice Services customers say about working with the company again on future projects?
Repeat-business intent appears across platforms. Jeongwon Joe on Google writes "I'll definitely hire Realtor's Choice again," and Tina Stewart adds "will call again with any future needs or repairs." Brad Morrissey notes "I would definitely use these guys again" on Google, while Jeonguon J on Angi reinforces the sentiment with "I'll definitely hire again Realtors Choice Services." The pattern shows up across roughly half the reviews.
Is Realtors Choice Services a verified business entity, and does Ohio require a state painting contractor license?
Realtors Choice Services LLC is registered with the Ohio Secretary of State as a Domestic Limited Liability Company, Entity No. 4621340, with original filing date 2-15-2021 and Active status. Ohio does not require a state-level painting contractor license per the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board, which licenses only electrical, plumbing, HVAC, hydronics, and refrigeration trades. The company holds BBB A+ Accredited status with accreditation dated 10-5-2025.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State, BBB, Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board