About That 1 Painter Cincinnati
That 1 Painter Cincinnati is a residential and commercial painting company serving the greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky area. The first conversation usually happens with owner John Brannen or his sales team, who handle estimates and walk homeowners through service options. Customers describe a responsive scheduling process, with one reviewer noting "they were the only painting company to respond in a timely manner and keep their scheduled estimation appointments." A free color consultation through the company's dedicated Color Studio is part of the planning process, and That 1 Painter Cincinnati is a member of the Anderson Area Chamber of Commerce.
The crew handles interior and exterior residential painting, cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, drywall repair, popcorn ceiling removal, pressure washing, and carpentry. Project managers like Andy Monnin, Eli Boyd, and Mary Riley coordinate between the estimate and final walkthrough. All work is backed by a 3-year transferable warranty covering labor and materials, and the company is fully insured with certificates available on request.
Updated: 05-22-2026
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
What can homeowners expect from the initial consultation with That 1 Painter Cincinnati?
Customer reviews consistently describe a smooth first contact. Greg Brokamp wrote "Mary and Justin were very responsive to our request for an estimate." Kevin Carr added "from our initial contact with John and his team through the completion of the project, we could not have been happier." A Scott noted "they were the only painting company to respond in a timely manner and keep their scheduled estimation appointments."
How does the crew handle preparation and cleanup on interior projects?
Multiple reviews highlight the prep-first approach and daily cleanup. Kelly Potter wrote "they patched holes and prepped, then painted ceilings, walls, interior doors and trim. They also cleaned up well." Robert Turner noted "the areas were cleaned up properly, furniture back in place." Jason Burkhardt described "the work area was kept clean and organized throughout the project, and everything was cleaned up perfectly at the end of each day."
What do customers say about the quality of finished work on whole-house and multi-room projects?
Reviews from larger projects praise the finished results. Jason Burkhardt wrote "every wall, ceiling, and detail was done with precision and care, and the final result looks flawless." Kellie Lynn said "the finished product looks amazing" after a two-bedroom repaint. Leslie Keller, a repeat client, noted "second time using That 1 Painter. They painted 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. Once again they did a great job."
How has That 1 Painter Cincinnati performed on commercial and school projects?
Several reviews document institutional and event-space work. Elizabeth Delaney wrote "our experience with That 1 Painter exceeded all of our expectations" for a sentimental event center project. J Sharp2626 said "they provide a real value with high quality work and competitive cost" for a school gym. Grant Brannen confirmed "professional, punctual, and delivered outstanding work" on school projects, and Markus Heinze received quick classroom service.
How do real estate professionals and investors evaluate That 1 Painter for pre-sale work?
Realtors and investors highlight speed and value. Realtor Lisa Phair wrote "I was thoroughly impressed with their speed, efficiency and communication throughout the whole process, far better than contractors we've used." Deal Stream Pros noted "they delivered exactly as promised" for a rental listing turnaround. Brittany Rodgers said "needed interior painting of 5 rooms done quickly to sell a house. They were able to accommodate my schedule."
What is the experience like working with individual team members at That 1 Painter Cincinnati?
Named team members appear throughout the review base with distinct praise. Sarah H wrote that Andy Monnin "knows his colors and combinations" and "stands behind his work." Debbie Boyd said Eli Boyd was "professional, kind and honest about the water damage we had experienced." Diane Gillespie praised Mary Riley, noting "she truly cared about my clients and their satisfaction." Dione named John, Andy, and Cass as "a great team with excellent customer service."
How did the company address a negative customer experience involving exterior work?
One review from Karen Bridges described property damage during an exterior project, including overspray and broken tiles. The owner responded, noting "we had a gutter company come in and replace any damaged gutters" and mentioned "monetarily reducing costs of the garden and several other paint related issues." The reviewer disputes that full resolution occurred. This is the only negative review among 78 total and raises questions about subcontractor oversight.
Is That 1 Painter Cincinnati a licensed and registered business entity in Ohio?
Ohio does not require a state-level painting contractor license. The Cincinnati location operates under Brannen Enterprises LLC, registered with the Ohio Secretary of State as Entity No. 5199080 (Fictitious Name filing, Active status, filed 3/14/2024). The company holds a BBB rating of A (not accredited) and is a member of the Anderson Area Chamber of Commerce.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State, BBB, Anderson Area Chamber of Commerce