Recognized with Angie's List Super Service Awards across 2009 through 2018 and PDCA member recognition, Best Buy Painting handles residential and commercial painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, and wallpaper removal for Northeast Ohio homeowners and businesses. The family-owned crew operates from East 286th Street in Euclid and includes foreman Sean, crew chief Austin, estimator Matt Rosati, office liaison Laura, and painters Dana, Tyler, Brandon, Casey, Justin, and Edgar.
The team works with premium products from Benjamin Moore on exterior projects and Sherwin-Williams and Behr on interior work, with custom finish capabilities that include faux wallpaper, faux stucco, glazing, color washes, and stenciling. Drywall repair, plaster restoration, water damage repair, wood rot repair, cedar shingle replacement, and pressure washing round out the prep offerings. Best Buy Painting serves Cleveland, Shaker Heights, Solon, Pepper Pike, Aurora, Beachwood, Chagrin Falls, Gates Mills, Highland Heights, Hudson, Bainbridge, Twinsburg, Akron, and Canton. The crew is fully insured, and projects are backed by a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee with most jobs starting within two weeks of the estimate.
Updated: 05-13-2026
Multiple reviewers describe results that exceeded expectations. Damian Henri called Best Buy Painting "easily the best painting company that I have ever hired," highlighting prep that included "proper scraping, old caulk removal, and priming of the substrates." On Facebook, Robert Schaefer wrote that the team "overpromises and then delivers MORE than promised," a startling and welcome experience compared to other contractors he had used.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Austin and Sean receive frequent praise across reviews. Valerie wrote "Austin matched the texture flawlessly" after a ceiling repair and called him "an asset to the Best Buy Painting team." Ann-Marie Cosmo described Austin and Justin as "outstanding people" who helped her move furniture and dispose of items. Lina Mehta gave a shout-out to "Austin, the crew chief, and to Sean, who went above and beyond."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Communication runs through estimator Matt Rosati and office liaison Laura. Bitty Cook noted Matt "was readily available to answer questions via text and a phone call" and that everyone in the office was "pleasant and helpful." Damian Henri said the crew "were highly communicative about progress" and asked questions before proceeding with uncertain scope. Daily updates and end-of-day walkthroughs are mentioned across many reviews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Reviews show frequent work on century homes and older properties. Samantha Nedlik wrote the crew "repaired cracks in the plaster of our 105 year old home." Lesa Kest trusted them with "solid wood garage doors" on her "almost a century home" because she wanted to "keep as original as possible." Jane Grebenc described work on her "140 year old house" with results that "caused very little disruption."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cleanliness comes up repeatedly. Deborah Corn said "the house was spotless after the job was completed." David Alpert noted the crew used "HEPA-grade vacuum cleaners" and "left the areas they worked on dust-free, clean, and with all tools and materials removed." On Facebook, Cardinal Plumbing & Drain wrote the team was "very professional, clean, responsive and made the whole process easy from start to finish."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Repeat customers appear across reviews. Bob and lynda Stuart said they had "used them for over a decade." Kelly Ann Worthington wrote she had "been using them for projects in our house since 2017." Barbara Higgins returned after first hiring Best Buy Painting in 2006. Yelp reviewer Jennifer S. wrote that Best Buy Painting is "the only painting company my family will use in the future" after they painted her mother's home.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Owner Brad Pietrafese checks in on projects in person. Tim Moyer wrote that "not only did the Project Manager do an extensive walk thru, before final sign off, the owner also stopped by to check on the crew." Matt Delguyd noted "Sean and Brad kept an eye on the job to make sure it was being done to their standard." Dwight Perry called the "Owner followup a nice touch" on his second project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Ohio does not require a state painting contractor license, so Best Buy Painting operates without a state license number. The business is registered with the Ohio Secretary of State as Best Buy Painting, Inc. (Entity No. 1454886), a Corporation for Profit in active status since its original filing on April 7, 2004. The statutory agent on file is Brent M. Pietrafese at 1405 East 6th Street, Cleveland OH 44114.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State Business Search, Project License Lookup File
Updated: 05-13-2026