When Kyle Mitchell launched Realtor's Choice Services in 2020, he built the company around a straightforward idea homeowners shouldn't have to chase a contractor for updates or wonder when the crew will show up. Kyle answers inquiries himself, schedules estimates personally, and stays reachable by call, text, or email throughout every project. Customers reach him directly from first contact through final walkthrough.
The BBB-accredited company handles interior and exterior residential painting, deck and fence staining, wood siding and log home staining, and a full range of exterior cleaning services including soft washing, roof washing, concrete cleaning, gutter cleaning, and window washing. For home sales preparation, the team paints interiors and exteriors of listing properties, handles drywall repair, and can coordinate specialty trades through their established partner network. The fully insured crew also takes on commercial painting for offices, retail spaces, and places of worship throughout the region.
Based in Batavia, Ohio, Realtor's Choice Services serves the Greater Cincinnati area across Clermont, Hamilton, and surrounding counties.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Communication is one of the most praised aspects of working with Realtor's Choice Services. Customers describe being kept in the loop from the first inquiry through project completion. One reviewer noted Kyle "always kept me informed of any development and/or issues, and was readily available for further discussions," while another said "we knew when he was coming and next steps." Multiple customers across Google and Angi highlight that updates flow consistently throughout each job rather than only at the start and finish.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Surface preparation stands out repeatedly in reviews of Realtor's Choice Services. Amanda Collins noted the "quality of the prep work thoroughly impressed me," and James Palmarini highlighted that Kyle personally walked the property with his crew leader to review wood repair and power washing before any paint was applied. The team scrapes loose paint, addresses wood damage, and washes surfaces before coating. Palmarini also noted Kyle "washed my deck a second time when the first washing didn't quite do the job" — returning to get the prep right before proceeding.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Deck and fence work is a core strength at Realtor's Choice Services. Multiple customers hired the company specifically for deck restoration combining board replacement, cleaning, and staining in a single project. Patrick Fagan noted the team "replaced boards, stained, and did a variety of other work on our deck," and Barbara Boyne praised the crew for completing a full deck revision "over three days in brutal heat." The company also stains fences, wood siding, and log homes, making it a full-service option for exterior wood surfaces beyond standard painting.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Pricing comes up positively across reviews of Realtor's Choice Services, with customers noting fair quotes and no unexpected charges. Marla Kouche pointed out the team "didn't try to oversell" and delivered "quality work at a reasonable price," while Kelly DeNu described the price as "fair and the work detail was top notch." Several customers mention getting what they paid for without upsells or surprises. One Angi reviewer paid $5,432 for an exterior project and described the pricing as reasonable for the scope delivered.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Follow-through after project completion appears throughout the Realtor's Choice Services review record. James Palmarini noted Kyle "returned after the job was done to do some minor paint touchup" without needing to be asked, and Justin Spalding described finding minor chipping spots after completion, noting Kyle committed to fixing them right away. One Angi reviewer mentioned a deck board came up a month later and Kyle "brought the team back out to put back down at no cost." The pattern reflects a consistent willingness to return and make things right.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
The company name reflects a real service niche — helping homeowners and real estate agents prepare properties for sale. Realtor Meagan Ioannou used the team to paint an upcoming listing and praised how quickly they got on the schedule, while Vince Cantrella hired them to handle drywall repair, cabinet repair, and painting while preparing his home for sale. The company handles the kind of fast-turnaround, multi-task preparation work that listing agents need before a home hits the market.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Kyle Mitchell works on-site rather than managing from a distance. Patricia Smith described him as "always friendly, showed me exactly what needed to be done and very patient with my questions," and Lewis Egner called him "the most responsive, genuine small business owner we've encountered in almost 30 years of owning our home." Multiple reviews note Kyle himself handling power washing, walking properties with crew leaders, and returning personally for touchups. He is described throughout the review record as accessible, hands-on, and personally invested in each project's outcome.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Ohio does not require a state-level painting contractor license — the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board covers only electrical, plumbing, HVAC, and similar trades, and painters are not included. Realtor's Choice Services is registered as a Domestic Limited Liability Company with the Ohio Secretary of State under the legal name REALTORS CHOICE SERVICES LLC, Entity No. 4621340, with an original filing date of 02/15/2021 and an Active status. The company is also BBB Accredited as of October 6, 2025. Kyle Mitchell is listed as Owner. Primary business address is 135 Douglas Drive, Batavia, OH 45103.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State, BBB
Updated: 04-07-2026