The Picky Painters
About The Picky Painters
A Strongsville-based painting company since 2016, The Picky Painters has built a loyal following across Greater Cleveland through word-of-mouth referrals and repeat customers. Owner Joe Strbik brings over 25 years of painting experience to every project, personally handling estimates and color consultations while his trained crew executes the work.
The company specializes in kitchen cabinet refinishing using KCMA certified coatings that create a factory-quality finish, backed by a five-year warranty. Interior and exterior painting services include full surface preparation, primers, and two coats of high-quality paint, with exterior work carrying a two-year warranty. Additional services include wallpaper removal, deck staining, and drywall repairs.
The fully insured team uses employees rather than subcontractors, with every worker passing background checks. The Picky Painters serves Strongsville, Brunswick, North Royalton, Westlake, Lakewood, Bay Village, and surrounding communities within Greater Cleveland. The company is BBB Accredited and a member of the Strongsville Chamber of Commerce.
Updated: 02-17-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About The Picky Painters
Q: Does The Picky Painters actually show up when scheduled and keep customers informed?
Multiple reviews emphasize punctuality and communication as standout qualities. Ben Walburn notes the crew was "on time with a full crew every day" while Jamie Blakely praises "constant updates on job status." Veronica Bedell adds that communication was "on point from start to finish." Owner Joe personally manages scheduling and provides timeline expectations during the estimate process.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does The Picky Painters handle cleanup during and after painting projects?
Customers consistently describe job sites left cleaner than expected. Heather norris mentions the team was "very neat and clean, cleaning up every day." Ben Walburn observed "minimal disruption to daily routine" throughout a multi-service project. The company uses protective coverings on floors, walkways, and countertops, with daily cleanup as standard practice on every job.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What makes The Picky Painters cabinet refinishing different from other painters?
The company uses KCMA certified coatings applied with specialized equipment including a HEPA 1000 Air Scrubber for dust and fume control. Gary Ryan describes the finished cabinets as "thousands cheaper than buying new, and they look better than new." Colleen Linhart notes her cabinets came out "beautiful" after the refinishing process. Projects include a five-year warranty on workmanship.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How did The Picky Painters handle challenging exterior projects with weather or repair issues?
Chuck Genaro's exterior project faced both rainy weather and unexpected wood rot discovery. He reports Joe "worked with me on price for the wood repairs" and the crew "worked around the weather as much as possible." The team completed repairs and painting despite the challenges. Wes Baka updated his review after one year confirming "the paint job is still holding up great."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do customers come back to The Picky Painters for multiple projects over time?
Frank Shewalter has hired them for "four different projects" including interior painting and cabinet work in two different homes, calling them his "go to painters." Wes Baka returned after using them previously, stating they were his "first choice" based on past experience. Gary Ryan had Joe return for additional work after the initial cabinet project was complete.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: What do reviews say about The Picky Painters deck and fence staining work?
Customers praise both the preparation and finished results. Kathleen Hauck describes the deck work as "exceptional" with thorough pressure washing before staining. Arjo Sengupta notes the team "did a great job" on deck staining with clear communication throughout. Gery Riva hired them for fence staining and reports being "very pleased" with the outcome and professionalism.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does The Picky Painters respond to the negative review from a former employee?
The single negative review came from former employee Blake Neuhauser. Owner Joe responded professionally without arguing, acknowledging the feedback and stating the company has "enhanced training programs" while wishing the former employee well. This measured response demonstrates accountability rather than defensiveness when facing criticism publicly.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does The Picky Painters handle drywall repairs as part of painting projects?
Several reviews confirm drywall work is included when needed. Eric Jacobs notes the team handled "some drywall repair before painting" his kitchen. Kathleen McFadden had similar experience with drywall work completed prior to interior painting. The company website lists drywall surface repairs as a standard service, integrated into the painting process rather than requiring a separate contractor.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 02-17-2026