5 Best Painters Near Barrington, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Barrington, NJ have access to several highly-rated painting contractors with strong track records across multiple review platforms. These companies have earned customer loyalty through consistent quality, clear communication, and a willingness to go beyond basic expectations. Whether you need interior refreshes, exterior repaints, or specialty cabinet work, the top-rated painters in this area offer a range of expertise to match different project needs.

Original Design Painting leads the pack with a Chooz Score of 88.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 320 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and were 100% recommended on Facebook with over 30 recommendations. With over 22 years in business, owner Recep Ozbas and his son Beto run a family operation that reviewers describe as accommodating and detail-focused. If you have an older home with tricky surfaces or need someone who can handle last-minute scheduling changes, this company stands out for flexibility.

• Customers with cedar shake siding and century-old homes consistently praise the finished results
• Several reviewers mention the crew completing exterior jobs within just two days despite complex prep requirements
• The team works around tight insurance deadlines and holiday timelines without sacrificing quality

"Working with Original Design Painting was one of the best contractor experiences ever. They came to look at the scope of the work and got me a quote that evening. The price was fair and the workmanship was excellent." - David R., Google Review

For homeowners seeking a contractor with deep local roots, Cherry Hill Painting brings nearly six decades of experience to every project. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 130 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp with over 20 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. Now a second-generation family business with Doug Andersen at the helm since 1983, they maintain consistent crews that customers recognize by name. If you value seeing the same familiar faces return for future projects, Cherry Hill Painting delivers that stability.

• The Mac and Muhammad crew appears across dozens of reviews, with customers specifically requesting them for repeat jobs
• Commercial projects like the Haddon Fortnightly building showcase their capacity for larger-scale work
• Customers report receiving status photos at the end of each work day

"Mac and his team were fantastic. They showed up everyday on time, they were respectful of my house and didn't cut any corners. Interior of my house looks amazing." - Douglas C., Google Review

When owner involvement matters most, Chambers Color Coating stands apart. Owner Angelo Chambers personally handles estimates, checks on every job site, and maintains direct communication throughout each project. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.8% with over 80 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Real estate agents and contractors who hire painters regularly have added this company to their referral lists, which speaks to the professional-grade consistency.

• Cabinet refinishing emerges as a specialty, with several customers updating kitchens without the cost of full replacement
• Reviews from other contractors note reliability that sets Chambers apart from typical subcontractor experiences
• Customers describe work areas left cleaner than when the crew arrived

"Angelo not only gives you the serious elbow grease but he hires good people and expects solid results from them. The owner of the company was involved in every phase of the job." - Jim G., Google Review

Twin brothers Justin and Christian launched Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC in 2021 after years working with their father's painting company in Nashville, and they've quickly built a reputation for fast turnarounds. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.9% with over 130 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating. Their NJ contractor license ranks in the top 27% on BuildZoom, and they maintain an active social media presence showcasing completed projects. If you need a multi-room interior completed before the holidays or a quick turnaround for a real estate closing, this team delivers.

• One customer's bedroom project finished in a single day versus their four-to-five day estimate
• Investment property owners and real estate agents use them repeatedly across multiple properties
• Nearly all reviews receive detailed owner responses addressing specific project elements

"Justin and his team just painted my house and I couldn't be happier. Everything looks great and they were so easy to work with. Justin kept me updated every step of the way and finished right on schedule despite some additional work I requested." - Lee C., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Barrington, NJ, Rainer Painting Company brings over 38 years in business and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. They earned a Chooz Score of 82.0% with over 90 Google reviews at a 4.6-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook with over 15 recommendations and 4.7 stars on Angi with nearly 50 reviews. Owner Joe Rainer offers personalized color consultations, visiting homes to assess lighting and existing fixtures before recommending paint selections. If you feel stuck on color choices, this hands-on guidance can make the difference.

• Customers who used them 13 years ago return and find the same quality standards intact
• Church and commercial clients appear alongside residential homeowners
• Joe's color recommendations receive specific praise from customers with difficult-to-match tile or countertops

"Rainer painted our home 13 years ago and did a fantastic job then. We wanted to re-paint the porch for upcoming celebrations and Rainer gave its same quality work and made sure the job was done in time, despite me asking at the last minute!" - Ashling E., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi, BBB

Quality and workmanship emerge as defining factors in reviews for Barrington, NJ painting contractors. Customers consistently describe finished results that exceed expectations, with particular attention to prep work, clean lines, and durable finishes. Several reviewers note that walls with significant damage or holes looked brand new after completion, and exterior projects on older homes with challenging surfaces receive praise for the final appearance.

Original Design Painting customers frequently highlight how prep work contributes to lasting results. One reviewer with an older home full of large wall holes described the finished rooms as looking brand new. Cherry Hill Painting earns similar praise, with customers noting that crews don't cut corners even on details that might go unnoticed. "The quality of the work exceeded our expectations!" - Dan D., Google Review. Chambers Color Coating receives recognition for cabinet refinishing that makes outdated kitchens look new without the cost of replacement. "His work is impeccable, he made my outdated kitchen look brand new!" - Katie R., Google Review. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC customers describe transformations of entire homes, with one reviewer noting that walls and ceilings looked like new after completion. Rainer Painting Company handles challenging spaces like pantry cabinets and powder rooms with attention to every nook and cranny. "The transformation of these spaces is incredible, thanks to the exceptional work done by Joe Rainer and his team." - Dominick S., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication and professionalism appear throughout reviews for Barrington, NJ painting contractors. Customers value responsiveness during the estimate phase, clear updates throughout projects, and crews who treat homes with respect. Several companies stand out for owner involvement and follow-through on commitments.

Original Design Painting customers describe a responsive estimate process, with one reviewer receiving a quote the same evening after a walkthrough. Cherry Hill Painting takes communication further by sending status photos at the end of each work day, keeping homeowners informed even when they're not present. "They were very communicative throughout the process, sending status pictures at the end of each day." - Dan D., Google Review. Chambers Color Coating owner Angelo Chambers earns specific praise for keeping customers in the loop from start to finish. "He was a great communicator and ensured we stayed in the loop with his progress." - Breanna H., Google Review. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC twin owners Justin and Christian respond to nearly every review with detailed, project-specific comments rather than generic thank-yous. Customers describe them as always available for questions. Rainer Painting Company owner Joe Rainer promptly answers inquiries and accommodates schedules for consultations, with one reviewer noting his attention to concerns and willingness to listen throughout the process.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value and fair pricing surface regularly in reviews for Barrington, NJ painting contractors. Customers compare quotes from multiple companies and frequently note that the winning bid combined competitive pricing with quality workmanship. Several reviewers specifically mention receiving reasonable estimates that proved accurate once work completed.

Original Design Painting customers describe fair pricing paired with excellent workmanship. One reviewer who compared multiple exterior quotes found them the most reasonably priced while still delivering top results. "They completed everything in only two days and were by far the most reasonably priced!" - Briana P., Google Review. Cherry Hill Painting provides professionally presented, broken-down estimates that customers appreciate for transparency. Chambers Color Coating appeals to homeowners who sought quotes from larger companies, with one reviewer finding Chambers completed work in half the time at a competitive price. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC customers consistently describe pricing as fair and reasonable, with the added benefit of fast completion times that reduce disruption. "His crew got the entire job completed in just two days!" - one customer noted about their competitive quote. Rainer Painting Company maintains fair pricing that keeps customers returning over decades, with reasonable quotes backed by quality that justifies the investment.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness and scheduling reliability stand out in reviews for Barrington, NJ painting contractors. Customers describe crews arriving on time each day, projects completing ahead of schedule, and companies that accommodate tight deadlines without sacrificing quality. Several reviewers needed work completed for specific events or insurance requirements and found contractors who delivered.

Original Design Painting accommodates last-minute scheduling needs, with one reviewer describing a quick turnaround for an insurance-related exterior paint job that started and finished within their timeline. Cherry Hill Painting crews show up on time daily and often complete work quicker than expected. "Showed up on time. Went above and beyond in the prep work. Finished job looked great." - Dennis I., Google Review. Chambers Color Coating customers describe punctual service with work completed in less time than anticipated, even when weather issues required adjustments. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC regularly finishes projects early, with customers reporting multi-room jobs completed in days rather than weeks. One 3,400 square foot interior was completed before the holidays on short notice. "The job was completed early!" - Sabrina A., Google Review. Rainer Painting Company honors start and end dates reliably, with one customer noting their porch repaint finished in time for upcoming celebrations despite a last-minute request.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and site maintenance appear frequently in reviews for Barrington, NJ painting contractors. Customers describe work areas left spotless, crews who tidy up daily, and homes that show no trace of a painting project once complete. Several reviewers with concerns about specific areas like French drains or cathedral ceilings found crews who took extra precautions.

Original Design Painting customers describe clean job sites with no mess left behind after exterior and interior projects. Cherry Hill Painting crews clean up daily, with reviewers noting you couldn't tell anyone had been working in the home. "They cleaned up after themselves daily and you couldn't even tell they were here." - S R., Google Review. Chambers Color Coating leaves work areas cleaner than when they arrived, according to multiple reviewers. One customer with a 13-foot cathedral ceiling praised how carefully surfaces were protected throughout the project. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC crews clean up thoroughly before leaving each day. "They were very considerate and cleaned up great before leaving." - Garry, Google Review. Rainer Painting Company maintains tidy work areas throughout projects, with one customer who had concerns about their French drain system noting the painter kept debris away from the area and genuinely cared about their concerns.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook