Top-Rated Painters Bayville, NJ (Chooz Score Ranked)
Showing 3 painters servicing Bayville, NJ
About
With well over 150 five-star Google reviews and a flawless 5.0 rating across all platforms, ProEdge Painting has established itself as Ocean County's most consistently praised painting contractor since 2018. Owner Chris Fernandez leads a team that has transformed hundreds of Toms River, Brick, Manchester, and Jackson properties through their distinctive blend of speed, precision, and remarkable attention to detail.
The company specializes in comprehensive residential transformations, from intricate cabinet refinishing that breathes new life into dated kitchens to the challenging task of popcorn ceiling removal that modernizes entire homes. Their expertise extends to complete interior and exterior painting projects, deck and fence staining, and even light carpentry work including flooring installation. What distinguishes ProEdge is their ability to compress typical project timelines without sacrificing quality – multiple reviews describe entire houses painted in just three days, with crews of up to 16 painters mobilizing when deadlines demand it.
Beyond technical skill, ProEdge has built its reputation on reliability that customers find refreshingly rare in the contracting world. Crews arrive precisely when promised, send morning confirmation texts, and protect every surface before beginning work. The team's commitment to leaving properties "cleaner than when they arrived" appears repeatedly in reviews, alongside praise for their willingness to accommodate last-minute additions and picky furniture placement requests. Fully licensed (#13VH09970800), insured, and bonded, ProEdge serves the greater Ocean County area from their Toms River base, offering what customers consistently describe as exceptional value – professional craftsmanship at prices that frequently undercut competitors by significant margins.
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICET. Whitaker Painting
About T. Whitaker Painting
With over 8,000 homes transformed since 1987, T. Whitaker Painting brings 38 years of family-operated expertise to Ocean, Monmouth, Burlington, and Atlantic counties in Southern New Jersey. This fully licensed and insured contractor has earned well over 150 five-star Google reviews through consistent delivery of exceptional residential and commercial painting services.
The company excels in both standard painting projects and specialized services including cabinet refinishing, wallpaper installation, popcorn ceiling removal, and power washing. Led by owners Tim and Liz Whitaker, the team follows a meticulous five-step process—from initial consultation through final cleanup—ensuring every project meets their exacting standards. Liz's renowned color consultation service helps homeowners navigate selections with confidence, while Tim's master painter skills tackle the most challenging technical requirements.
What distinguishes T. Whitaker from competitors is their comprehensive approach to customer service. Each project includes a 2-year warranty, 100% satisfaction guarantee, and EPA RRP-certified professionals who treat homes with exceptional care. Customers consistently praise their punctuality, with painters arriving exactly at scheduled times, protecting every surface, and leaving properties "cleaner than when they started." Their HomeAdvisor Top Rated Professional status and 0% financing options make quality painting accessible without compromising on craftsmanship or reliability.
Carfagno Professional Painting LLC
About Carfagno Professional Painting LLC
With over 100 five-star Google reviews and a consistent track record of exceeding expectations, Carfagno Professional Painting LLC has become the go-to painting contractor for homeowners throughout Ocean and Monmouth Counties. This family-owned operation, established in 2010, brings together seasoned professionals who treat each project with the same care they'd give their own homes.
The company excels in transformative projects that breathe new life into properties. From cabinet refinishing that saves homeowners thousands compared to replacement, to the careful removal of dated popcorn ceilings, their crew handles complex renovations with precision. Customers consistently praise their ability to tackle everything from single-room refreshes to complete home transformations, with particular expertise in detailed trim work where they paint perfect lines by hand without relying on tape.
What distinguishes Carfagno Professional Painting is their reliability and communication. Owner Joe Carfagno personally handles estimates and color consultations, while his crews led by professionals like Justin, Mark, and Skylar arrive promptly at 7:30 AM and maintain spotless work areas throughout each project. Their competitive pricing reflects honest value rather than corner-cutting, and they back every job with a satisfaction guarantee that has earned them an A+ Better Business Bureau rating and loyal customers who refuse to work with anyone else.
