5 Best Painters in Toms River, NJ - Chooz Score Ranked

Why Customers Choose Carfagno Professional Painting LLC

Hundreds of Happy Customers

Over 135 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating is impressive for any painting company, but especially for one that's only been in business since 2020. This company earned a Chooz Score of 90.1%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, reviews spanned multiple platforms with consistent praise:

• A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau with zero complaints on file
• 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews
• NJ Home Improvement Contractor License No. 13VH11150000 verified active

"I can't say enough about Joe, Mike, and everyone on the Carfagno team. By far the most reasonably priced and the work is EXCEPTIONAL! Hire with maximum confidence." - Marc A., Google Review

Pride in the Finished Product

Cabinet refinishing is where Carfagno's attention to detail really shows. Customers consistently describe 30-year-old cabinets looking "brand new" and kitchens being transformed without the cost of full replacement. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators show detailed project descriptions across dozens of reviews:

• Specific projects mentioned include cabinet refinishing, popcorn ceiling removal, EFIS/stucco painting, deck staining, and drywall repair
• Crew members Justin, Chris, Mark, and Skyler are praised by name for their craftsmanship
• Many reviews include customer-uploaded photos showing before and after transformations

"Joe Carfagno and his team of painters exceed all my expectations. His prices were fair and he kept every promise he made. Joe's team of painters took extra care with our home. They were clean, courteous and walked us through everything." - Donna C., Google Review

The Boss Shows Up

Owner Joe Carfagno is personally involved from estimate through completion. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Joe is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, handles estimates in person, and responds to virtually every customer review. This hands-on approach extends to follow-through when things need attention:

• Joe personally visits homes for estimates rather than quoting over the phone
• The office team, including Lucy, is praised for responsive communication
• Owner responses to reviews reference specific projects and thank customers by name

"From beginning to end Joe and his crew were amazing to work with. The crew did an excellent job, skilled painters, professional, polite and after day one I knew I picked the right company." - Susan K., Google Review

Why Customers Choose T. Whitaker Painting

Clear Communication from Start to Finish

Owner Liz Whitaker responds to virtually every review with personalized messages, not copy-paste thank-yous. The Chooz Score's review response quality component reflects how the owner handles feedback: each response mentions the customer by name and references specific project details:

• Liz personally handles estimates and consultations, explaining every aspect of the job in detail
• Customers receive a comprehensive folder with insurance information, work ethics, and project scope before work begins

"When Liz arrived to assess what we wanted done, she went above and beyond. We felt comfortable in their ability for what we needed." - Claudia R., Google Review

Craftsmanship You Can See

What sets them apart is the attention to detail customers consistently praise. From wallpaper installation to cabinet painting to popcorn ceiling removal, the Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators show reviewers mentioning specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines:

• Tim's wallpaper skills are praised as "second to none," turning a 16-foot mural into "a true work of art"
• Cabinet painting projects completed in as few as 3 days with results customers describe as "brand new kitchen"
• Named crew members like Dave, Shane, and Chris are specifically praised for meticulous work

"Let me just say amazing! The craftsmanship and communication second to none. Painted our kitchen cabinets and all moldings. They look fantastic!" - George V., Google Review

Years of Consistent Results

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, T. Whitaker Painting had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 83.4%. With 38 years in business since 1987, they've been a fixture in the Jersey Shore community:

• EPA Lead RRP Certification NAT-55147-2 verified
• 2-year workmanship warranty and 100% satisfaction guarantee clearly stated
• The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, reviews spanned multiple platforms including 5.0 stars on Yelp and 82% recommended on Facebook

"If I could give them 6 stars I would. The house looks better than it has in 20 years!" - John F., Google Review

Why Customers Choose ProEdge Painting

The Reviews Speak for Themselves

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, ProEdge Painting had over 165 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%. Reviews also span additional platforms with strong ratings:

• 100% recommended on Facebook with 9 recommendations
• 5.0 stars on Yelp
• Valid NJ Home Improvement Contractor License No. 13VH09970800 verified active

"Chris and his team were excellent. They completed the job in two days. They were very easy to work with, always on time and did a very thorough cleanup once the job was finished." - Robert M., Google Review

Craftsmanship You Can See

Customers consistently mention the same thing: meticulous prep work and attention to detail. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong, with reviewers mentioning specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines:

• Multiple reviews highlight popcorn ceiling removal, cabinet painting, and flooring installation completed to high standards
• "Better than expected" and "looks like new construction" appear repeatedly across reviews

"This is the best paint job I ever had done. He goes above and beyond. My family room came out amazing. It looks like brand new construction." - Ann E., Google Review

Fast Turnarounds, No Shortcuts

Projects consistently finish ahead of schedule without sacrificing quality. What would take most homeowners days gets completed in a fraction of the time:

• Whole-house interior projects completed in 2-3 days
• Same-day or next-day project starts after estimate approval
• "Originally a 2 day job was completed in just one full day" is a common theme

"I explained that I wanted my new 2250sf home with 10' ceilings painted in three days. Chris said no problem. I am happy to report that he and his professional staff not only completed the job in three days, but the workmanship was outstanding." - William Z., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Richard's Painting of Barnegat

Customers Keep Coming Back

High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers mention returning for second, third, or even fourth projects. This family-run business has built serious loyalty over more than two decades serving the Barnegat and LBI area:

• Robert Meyers hired them twice in one month for different properties
• Michael Milling notes they handle "all my painting interior and exterior"
• Jillian Cerbone recommends them to "all friends, family, and clients"

"I hired Richard's Painting of Barnegat for a second time. Your crew is very professional, hard working, respectful and take pride in their work. My mother-in-law was so happy." - Robert M., Google Review

Owner on the Job

Mike runs this family operation alongside his sons, and that hands-on approach shows in every project. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Mike is personally mentioned in the majority of reviews and responds to nearly every piece of feedback:

• Mike handles estimates personally and works alongside the crew
• Father-and-sons team means you know exactly who is in your home
• Owner responds to 95%+ of reviews with personalized messages

"Mike set up an appointment for an estimate, showed up on time and followed up with written estimate. He works with his sons so there was no concerns with who would be handling the job." - Katy O., Google Review

Years of Consistent Results

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Richard's Painting had over 170 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%. With over 25 years in business since 1999, they've established deep roots serving Barnegat, LBI, Beach Haven, and surrounding communities:

• NJ Home Improvement Contractor License No. 13VH10831000 on file
• Active presence on Instagram with over 780 followers showcasing completed work

"Mike and his sons did an excellent job painting the exterior of my house. The quality of the paint job was better than I expected." - Joyce J., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting

Fast Turnarounds, No Shortcuts

Customers consistently mention the same thing: Jaime's team works incredibly fast without cutting corners. Multiple reviewers express surprise at how quickly projects were completed while maintaining high quality:

• A full apartment paint job completed in less than a day
• A five-room bathroom renovation finished in just one week as promised
• An entire first floor shiplap installation done in under two weeks

"I couldn't believe the short amount of time everything was completed by and how clean and efficient his team works! They are such an amazing group of hardworking, friendly and the happiest guys I've ever seen working." - Tiffany K., Google Review

They Treat Your Home Like Their Own

The attention to cleanliness and respect for customer property comes up repeatedly in reviews. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators show consistent mentions of protection measures and thorough cleanup:

• Tarps placed throughout walkways and work areas
• Furniture covered and floors protected during every project
• Final cleanup so thorough that customers are "surprised by the lack of remaining dust"

"Workers showed up on time, placed tarps throughout the walkway, installed the shower doors and when they left, my bathroom was perfectly clean like no one had done any construction." - Gerardo R., Google Review

More Than Just Painters

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Jaime's Renovation had over 140 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 85.5%. What stands out is the range of services beyond painting:

• Kitchen and bathroom remodels, including cabinet refinishing and tile work
• Custom carpentry, from built-in entertainment units to mudroom cabinets
• Deck building, floor installation, and electrical work

"His team painted all of the rooms, closets, trim, cabinets, changed out the door hinges and handles, electrical work etc - his team does it all!!" - Tiffany K., Google Review

Questions to Ask Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting

Getting alignment on project scope and pricing

One anonymous Yelp reviewer reported that pricing changed after work began, with the contractor citing the job being harder than expected. Jaime did not respond to this review. To avoid surprises, ask directly: "How do you handle situations where the work ends up being more complex than the initial quote? Will you discuss any changes with me before proceeding?"

"All was fine up until he actually had to do the work at which point he stated the work was harder then he thought and wanted to charge me more money." - Anonymous, Yelp Review (no owner reply)