3 Best Painters Near Eatontown, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Eatontown, NJ have earned strong reputations through consistent quality and personal attention to every project. Local homeowners praise these companies for reliable communication, skilled crews, and results that exceed expectations.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Richard K. Moore Professional Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 91.9% and has been serving the Eatontown, NJ area for over 40 years since 1985. Owner Rich and office manager Diane handle every project personally, from the first estimate to the final walkthrough. If you want a painter who will remember your name and treat your home like their own, Richard K. Moore is a strong choice.

What stands out in the reviews is how many customers return for second, third, and even fourth projects over spans of 10 to 20 years. Crew members like Marty, Tom, John, and Brian are requested by name, and customers frequently describe how Rich personally checks in during work and makes sure everything meets their standards before leaving.

• Customers mention Rich uses a color scanner to match existing finishes perfectly
• Drywall repair and ceiling work praised as seamless, with damaged areas looking brand new
• Over 80 reviews on Angi with a 5.0-star rating
• Multiple customers describe receiving M&Ms with their estimate as a memorable personal touch

"Rich and Marty came on time and finished the job even faster than expected. Excellent work. Will be happy to have them back for additional work in the future." - Robert Hecht, Google Review

Owner Liz Whitaker personally handles every consultation for T. Whitaker Painting, and customers consistently praise her detailed explanations and thorough preparation. They've earned a Chooz Score of 89.6% with over 160 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. With over 35 years in business since 1987, they've become a fixture in the Jersey Shore painting community. If you're particular about communication and want to know exactly what to expect before work begins, T. Whitaker delivers.

Looking through the reviews, customers receive a comprehensive folder with insurance information, work ethics, and project scope before any work starts. This level of transparency shows up repeatedly in reviews, with homeowners describing how they felt informed and comfortable throughout the entire process. Cabinet painting and wallpaper installation are particular strengths, with customers describing kitchen cabinets that look brand new.

• Named crew members Dave, Shane, Nick, and Tim receive specific praise for careful work
• Popcorn ceiling removal completed cleanly with results customers describe as flawless
• 2-year workmanship warranty and 100% satisfaction guarantee clearly stated upfront

"From start to meeting Liz with her excellent eye to detail to the two men who were focused detailed and kind just getting the job done. My house looks beautiful." - Cyd Williams, Google Review

Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting rounds out the top contractors with a Chooz Score of 85.5%. With over 65 Google reviews and strong presence across multiple platforms, they've built a reputation for handling complex projects that go beyond just painting. If you need a contractor who can tackle renovation work alongside your painting project, Jaime's team offers that versatility.

Customers describe Jaime as someone who personally oversees every job and responds quickly to any concerns. The reviews show a pattern of homeowners who started with a small painting project and then hired Jaime's team for larger renovations including bathroom remodels, flooring, and carpentry work. Several reviewers mention this is their second or third time using the company.

• Cabinet painting projects completed with careful taping and protection of surrounding areas
• Crews described as arriving on time daily and cleaning up thoroughly each evening
• Renovation services including sheetrock, flooring, and carpentry alongside painting
• Quick turnaround praised, with some whole-house projects completed in under a week

"Jamie and his crew are highly professional, dependable and overall amazing. They do quality work and are able to tackle so many different home projects." - Stacy Liss, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Painting contractors in Eatontown, NJ consistently receive praise for delivering high-quality results. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers highlight careful attention to every surface, with one homeowner noting "They covered everything so that no paint or dust would get on anything in my home. They were thorough and the job was done to our full satisfaction." Another customer shared that "The team of Marty and Rich were professional, neat and courteous. I love the work they did!"

T. Whitaker Painting earns recognition for their craftsmanship on specialty projects. Customers describe cabinet painting results as "a brand new kitchen for way less money" and wallpaper installations that turn murals into "a true work of art." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting receives similar feedback, with one reviewer noting "The craftsmanship is outstanding, everything looks clean, modern, and beautifully finished." Across all three companies, reviewers emphasize that the finished work holds up over time and exceeds initial expectations.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Communication is a consistent strength among painting contractors serving Eatontown, NJ. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers praise owner Diane for her responsiveness, with one noting "Diane was so kind and accommodating" while another shared that "They were very accommodating during the construction process and always available to ask questions." The company responds personally to every Google review, referencing specific project details rather than generic thank-you messages.

T. Whitaker Painting takes communication a step further by providing customers with detailed documentation before work begins. One homeowner described how "Everybody at T. Whitaker Painting was friendly and took time to explain each step of the house painting process." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting earns similar praise, with a customer noting Jaime's "excellent communication and amount of patience he had with my many questions." All three companies make themselves available throughout the project to address concerns immediately.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and reliability are hallmarks of painting contractors in Eatontown, NJ. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers consistently mention crews arriving exactly when promised, with one reviewer noting "They showed up exactly when they said they would and did an exceptional job." Another customer shared that the crew "arrived and finished the work on time as per their commitment."

T. Whitaker Painting earns similar recognition for reliability. One homeowner described how "The painters said they would arrive at 8:00 A.M. each morning and they were at my house and started work on the dot at 8:00 A.M." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting customers praise the team for staying on schedule, with one noting "They were always on time every day till the job got done." Several reviewers across all companies mention projects finishing ahead of schedule without sacrificing quality.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Thorough preparation and clean job sites are priorities for painting contractors in Eatontown, NJ. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers describe careful protection of furniture and flooring, with one noting "They leave the place cleaner than when they arrived." Another reviewer shared that "All furniture was covered and put back in place" after the work was complete.

T. Whitaker Painting customers praise the team's prep work before any painting begins. One homeowner described how "They made sure to prep the walls and get rid of imperfections before the paint was applied. They were clean and fast." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting earns similar feedback, with a customer noting "Workers showed up on time, placed tarps throughout the walkway, and when they left, my bathroom was perfectly clean like no one had done any work." All three companies emphasize daily cleanup so homeowners can use their spaces during multi-day projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google