4 Best Painters Near Highlands, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Highlands, NJ looking for painting contractors have access to several highly-rated options, each with distinct strengths. What stands out across reviews is the emphasis on trust, with customers regularly mentioning they felt comfortable leaving painters alone in their homes while they ran errands or went to work.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, T. Whitaker Painting had over 165 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 90.6%. With over 35 years in business, Tim and Liz Whitaker have built a company where the same painters show up year after year. The company also holds a 4.9-star rating on Angi with over 30 reviews. If you want a contractor that backs their work with a two-year warranty and handles everything from cabinet refinishing to popcorn ceiling removal, T. Whitaker is a solid choice.

Reviewers frequently note that T. Whitaker crews arrive in uniform and cover furniture with care before starting any work. Several customers describe receiving a comprehensive folder during the estimate covering licensing, insurance, and the painting process.

• Multiple customers mention being nervous at first but ended up trusting workers in their home while away
• The team painted over 8,000 homes across Southern New Jersey according to company records
• Cabinet refinishing and kitchen makeovers are a specialty, with several reviewers describing results as "like having a new kitchen"

"I am beyond thrilled with the painting of my kitchen cabinets. I have a new kitchen for 1/5th of the cost of new cabinets. Unbelievable!" - Maria Colon, Google Review

Repeat customers and word-of-mouth referrals define Richard K. Moore Professional Painting, which earned a Chooz Score of 90.4%. With over 150 Google reviews maintaining a perfect 5.0-star rating and over 80 reviews on Angi at 5.0 stars, the numbers reflect nearly 30 years of consistent service. Rich and his wife Diane run a family operation where the same crew members appear across reviews spanning years. If you value a personal relationship with your painter and want someone who will remember your home, Richard K. Moore fits that profile.

What sets this company apart is the brush technique. Multiple reviewers mention the painters do not use masking tape because their cutting skills are precise enough to produce perfect lines freehand.

• Rich personally starts each project to set quality standards before the crew takes over
• Customers describe calling back for additional rooms after seeing the initial results
• Diane handles scheduling and is described as "so nice to deal with" in multiple reviews

"Diane was so kind and accommodating. Brian's painting came out beautiful, he was professional, neat and a very hard worker." - Judy Kenny, Google Review

For homeowners who want help choosing the right colors before any painting begins, Color Impact Painting Co. offers that consultative approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 100 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Wander Rodrigues personally guides clients through color selection, helping visualize results before the first brushstroke. If you are unsure about colors or textures and want guidance from someone experienced, Color Impact is worth considering.

The company handles both residential and commercial work, including restaurants that require flexible scheduling and odd-hour painting to avoid disrupting business operations.

• Wander responds to over 95% of reviews, showing active engagement with customers
• Wallpaper installation is available alongside painting services
• Several reviewers describe older homes being brightened up significantly

"Wander and his crew just transformed my 100 year old dingy house into something bright and beautiful." - Serina Cata, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi, Facebook

Customers in Highlands, NJ consistently praise the attention to detail they see from local painters. Across reviews for top-rated contractors, the word "professional" appears frequently, often paired with descriptions of precise brush work and flawless finishes.

Richard K. Moore Professional Painting stands out for brush technique that eliminates the need for masking tape. "They did not use masking tape and their cutting was excellent and flawless," notes one reviewer who had owned seven homes over 50 years of marriage. T. Whitaker Painting earns similar praise, with one customer describing how crews noticed an area that could look better and applied an extra coat at no additional charge. "Very professional. After applying two coats of paint advised may need a third coat. Came back in the afternoon to inspect," explains John Arizzi in his Google review. Color Impact Painting Co. receives compliments for crisp, clean lines, with owner Wander described as detail-oriented by multiple reviewers.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Professionalism shows up in small details according to Highlands, NJ customers. Reviewers frequently mention painters arriving in uniform, showing up exactly when promised, and keeping homeowners informed throughout projects.

T. Whitaker Painting receives praise for their communication process, with Liz providing a detailed folder during estimates that covers licensing, insurance, and what to expect. "Liz kept me informed and was very helpful in picking color," reports Maria Colon in her review. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting operates as a family business where Diane handles scheduling and customer communication. "Diane was an absolute pleasure to deal with," notes Ed Nyland after his project. For Color Impact Painting Co., owner Wander is described as responsive and easy to contact. "If you're looking for a professional painting job, with top tier communication, contact Color Impact Painting Co!" writes Alexander Lopez.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value comes up repeatedly in reviews from Highlands, NJ customers, with many noting that quality work justified the cost. Several reviewers mention getting multiple estimates and finding these contractors competitive.

T. Whitaker Painting earns comments about delivering results that feel like major renovations at a fraction of the cost. One customer described getting a new-looking kitchen for 1/5th the price of actually replacing cabinets. "Pricing was very reasonable compared to other estimates I had obtained," confirms Phyllis Barbella. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting is described as fair and willing to work within budgets. "Pricing was fair and they were able to work within our budget," explains Sergio Calo. Color Impact Painting Co. is characterized as reasonably priced for high-end quality work. "His price was very reasonable," notes Dan Leff after having multiple rooms painted.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and schedule reliability are common themes in reviews from Highlands, NJ homeowners. Multiple customers mention painters arriving exactly when promised and completing work ahead of schedule.

T. Whitaker Painting customers describe crews showing up on time daily throughout multi-day projects. "Showed up when she said they would, kept things very neat in the house," reports Colleen Sullivan. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting earns similar praise for respecting schedules. "He scheduled this job quickly and showed up on time, completed job as expected," notes Jean Stelicos after having exam rooms painted. Color Impact Painting Co. finished one project ahead of schedule according to Joseph DeSilvio, who wrote "He came in worked diligently and got the job done ahead of schedule."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google