9 Best Painters Near Mahwah, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Mahwah, NJ have access to several highly rated painting contractors with strong track records across multiple review platforms. These companies consistently earn praise for quality workmanship, responsive communication, and crews that treat homes with care. Here are the top-rated painting contractors serving the Mahwah area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Spectrum Painting had over 650 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 92.9%. With over 35 years in business since 1989, they've built deep roots in Northern New Jersey. Reviews also span over 300 reviews on Angi at 4.9 stars and 5.0 stars on Houzz, plus an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. What stands out in the reviews is how often customers mention specific crew members by name, with Gregor, Hector, and Marcin appearing repeatedly for their attention to detail and friendly demeanor. If you're looking for a company with proven consistency over decades, Spectrum is a strong choice.

• Repeat customers describe using them for multiple projects over the years, coming back for everything from interior painting to power washing
• Reviewers frequently mention that crews explain the daily process and stay available for questions throughout the project
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified and Penntek Certified for concrete coatings

"This is the third home that I have used Spectrum Painting and they continue to exceed my expectations. The Crew Leader kept on top of the job always keeping me apprised of progress." - Eric Parnes, Google Review

For homeowners considering a cabinet refinishing project or looking to update their kitchen without a full renovation, Hudson Paint Contracting & Refinishing by Hudson has developed a specialty. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7% with over 95 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Simone Moussa stays directly involved, with customers describing how he personally evaluates projects and explains the process from start to finish. The company has earned four consecutive Houzz Service Awards from 2021 through 2024. If you want an owner who shows up and stays engaged, Hudson delivers that experience.

• Project coordinator Ricky appears consistently in reviews for keeping homeowners informed throughout multi-day projects
• Multiple customers describe cabinet work that made kitchens look brand new without the cost of replacement
• Crews seal off work areas and clean up at the end of each day

"They did EVERYTHING they said they were going to do. Simone and his crew were professional, neat, and highly skilled and walked me through all of the steps." - Teresa Fiorina, Google Review

With over 45 years in business since 1980, Touch Of The Brush Painting is a father-and-son operation led by Jack Sciueche and his son Victor. This company earned a Chooz Score of 89.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 220 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus over 230 reviews on Angi at 5.0 stars and over 65 reviews on Yelp at 4.9 stars. They also hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Reviewers mention that Jack is on site for the duration of projects and provides recommendations on what to paint based on the home's needs. If you want a family-run company with deep local experience, Touch Of The Brush fits that description.

• Several reviews describe extensive wallpaper removal and wall repair work completed to perfection before painting
• Commercial clients praise their ability to handle large-scale projects with the same care as residential work
• Customers note competitive pricing compared to heavily advertised competitors

"Jack and his crew did a great job preparing and painting our 4 bed 3 bath house. They paid incredibly close attention to detail in everything they did." - Dennis Tung, Google Review

A veteran and family-owned operation, Romeo Painting Plus LLC has spent over 25 years serving North Jersey. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.4% with over 70 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 88% recommended on Facebook. Owner Matt Romeo is mentioned by name across reviews for his hands-on involvement, from providing color consultations to coordinating with other contractors on tight timelines. The company is EPA RRP lead-safe certified and holds NJ License No. 13VH13109000. If you need a contractor who can work around your schedule and coordinate with other trades, Romeo Painting accommodates those needs.

• Reviewers describe finding rotted wood during projects that the crew repaired rather than simply painting over
• Customers with time-sensitive move-in deadlines praise the team for meeting compressed schedules
• Office manager Caryl handles scheduling while the crew maintains consistent communication throughout projects

"You couldn't ask for a more professional and friendly group. They arrived on time and finished on time and the cleanup was amazing." - Christine OKeefe, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for That 1 Painter North Jersey. This Fair Lawn-based company earned a Chooz Score of 86.1% with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. Project manager Paulo appears in dozens of reviews as the on-site leader, with Keith, Todd, and Juan Carlos also mentioned by name. They're EPA Lead-Safe Certified and back their work with a three-year transferable warranty covering peeling, bubbling, cracking, or splitting. If you're looking for a company with clear warranty terms and consistent crew leadership, That 1 Painter delivers both.

• Commercial clients describe projects over 2,000 square feet completed professionally with high ceilings and fair pricing
• Multiple reviewers mention painters taking their shoes off while working inside homes
• Customers note the team uses quality paints from Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore

"They sent in 5 men and they spackled and painted the entire house in shorter than two days. They were punctual, polite, and worked fast and efficiently." - Dr. Maryam Alikhani, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Mahwah, NJ, Five Star Painting of Bergen County is led by owner Christian Cruz, who maintains direct involvement from first contact through project completion. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 220 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and 4.6 stars on Yelp with over 30 reviews. As part of the Neighborly franchise network, they offer a two-year workmanship warranty plus the Neighborly Done Right Promise. Reviews describe Christian rearranging his schedule to accommodate urgent painting needs and returning for touch-ups without hesitation.

• Customers describe popcorn ceiling removal and detailed prep work like moving appliances to paint behind them
• Multiple reviewers note same-day estimates and projects starting within days of the quote
• The company states they never use subcontractors, only their own professional crew

"Christian and his team are amazing. They are fast, reasonably priced and great to work with. Christian even rearranged his schedule at least twice to accommodate our urgent painting needs." - Vanessa Purwar, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi, Houzz

Quality and workmanship are the most frequently mentioned themes in reviews for painting contractors serving Mahwah, NJ. Customers consistently describe careful preparation, attention to detail, and finished results that exceed expectations.

Spectrum Painting receives praise for their prep work, with one customer noting the crew achieved results on a chimney project that was both visually impressive and structurally sound. "The concrete work was done with precision and attention to detail. Our chimney now looks fantastic and is structurally sound," wrote Rob Papa in a Google Review. Touch Of The Brush Painting earns similar recognition, with Victor and his team described as handling extensive spackling and wall repair so thoroughly that walls and ceilings look new. "Everything came out absolutely amazing down to the fine details. The spackling and prep work alone was done so well that the walls and ceilings look like new," shared Frank Olivieri on Google. Hudson Paint Contracting customers describe cabinet refinishing that makes kitchens feel brand new, with one reviewer noting the team restored severely damaged walls to perfection after wallpaper removal. "Not only did they restore my walls to perfection, but they also managed to seamlessly blend in the two additional rooms we added to the project last minute," explained Kristen K. in her Google Review. Romeo Painting Plus LLC receives recognition for addressing underlying issues rather than covering them up, with customers noting the team replaced rotted wood rather than simply painting over problem areas.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Communication and professionalism are highly valued by homeowners in Mahwah, NJ, and the top-rated painting contractors in the area consistently deliver on both fronts. Customers describe responsive estimators, clear explanations of the work process, and regular updates throughout projects.

Hudson Paint Contracting stands out for their communication structure, with project coordinator Ricky mentioned by name across reviews for keeping homeowners informed about progress. "Simone was so easy to work with and so responsive! His team was on time every day and were so professional," shared Kara Schnaidt on Google. That 1 Painter North Jersey earns praise for George, who handles estimates and provides detailed proposals, while Paulo manages on-site communication. "From the free estimate to the finished work, it was first rate and top notch throughout the process," wrote Joe Sireno in his Google Review. Spectrum Painting customers describe crew leaders who explain daily processes and remain available for questions. "From day one Brian from Spectrum was on point. The prices were fair, communication was great, questions or concerns were responded to right away," noted D X on Yelp. Five Star Painting of Bergen County receives recognition for owner Christian Cruz responding to calls quickly and providing same-day estimates. Touch Of The Brush Painting and Romeo Painting Plus LLC both earn praise for owners who are accessible throughout projects and responsive to customer concerns.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Timeliness and scheduling reliability matter to homeowners, and painting contractors serving Mahwah, NJ receive consistent praise for meeting deadlines and arriving when promised. Customers describe crews that show up on time each day and complete projects within quoted timeframes.

That 1 Painter North Jersey impresses customers with efficiency, with one reviewer noting their entire apartment was painted, including a dark brown ceiling, ahead of schedule. "They did this not only well, but early, which is not something you can say about most companies!" shared Jeane Gutierrez on Google. Hudson Paint Contracting earns praise for working within tight timelines, with one customer describing how they completed multiple rooms before a move-in date. "They were able to work with us on a very short timeline to get it done before we moved in," wrote Jamie Bartolacci. Five Star Painting of Bergen County customers note fast turnaround times, with one describing how the entire house was power washed one week and painted the next in just two days. "Later that week, the house was power washed and the next week, they painted the entire house in 2 days!" shared Sylvia Zozulia on Google. Spectrum Painting receives recognition for timeline accuracy, with reviewers noting quoted schedules were approximately 95% accurate. Touch Of The Brush Painting completed a 4-bedroom house in under two weeks, and Romeo Painting Plus LLC customers with time-sensitive projects praise the team for meeting compressed deadlines.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Cleanup and preparation are essential parts of any painting project, and contractors serving Mahwah, NJ consistently receive praise for protecting homes during work and leaving spaces spotless when finished.

Spectrum Painting crews clean up daily and conduct final walkthroughs to ensure everything is in order. "The painters were immaculate and left each day after a full cleanup. There was follow up after completion and a walk through at the end," shared Cynthia Gilbert Pattison on Facebook. That 1 Painter North Jersey takes care to protect furniture and belongings, with one customer noting they carefully moved all furniture and covered anything that couldn't be moved. "They prepped the place and cleaned up the mess after. I was happy with the work and how fast it was done," wrote Pedro Guzman on Google. Five Star Painting of Bergen County goes the extra mile, with customers describing how crews removed the fridge and bathroom mirrors to paint behind them. "They were very detailed oriented and did a fantastic job cleaning up after themselves," noted Megan on Google. Touch Of The Brush Painting receives recognition for thorough preparation, including extensive spackling and sanding. Romeo Painting Plus LLC customers praise the crew for covering all walls and floors and completing excellent prep work before painting begins. Hudson Paint Contracting seals off work areas with plastic during projects and cleans up at the end of each day.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Mahwah, NJ. Customers describe competitive estimates, transparent quoting, and results that justify the investment.

Touch Of The Brush Painting stands out for competitive pricing, with one customer noting they came in at about half the price of heavily advertised companies while delivering better results. "Vic came in at about half the price of some of the heavily advertised companies, but did an even better job," shared Andrew S. on Google. That 1 Painter North Jersey earns praise for transparent pricing with no surprises. "Their pricing was fair and complete, and they charged me exactly what was on the original quote," wrote Tony Lando in his Google Review. Five Star Painting of Bergen County customers describe fair quotes and reasonable pricing for both interior and exterior work. "His prices were more than fair. I'm going to call him for my next painting project," noted Patty S. on Yelp. Spectrum Painting receives recognition for fair pricing paired with quality results, with customers noting the combination of competitive rates and excellent communication. Romeo Painting Plus LLC earns praise for excellent work at fair prices, with one reviewer describing them as affordable, responsive, and helpful. Hudson Paint Contracting customers describe fair, detailed quotes delivered promptly after initial consultations.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp