Romeo Painting Plus LLC
Updated: 10-03-2025
About Romeo Painting Plus LLC
When a Bloomingdale homeowner needed her son's house painted on an aggressive timeline, Cheley Bouvier Vavrik didn't just get professionalism. She got Carol, the scheduler who kept communication flowing, and a crew that left her so impressed she immediately booked work on her own house. This isn't marketing speak. It's how Matt Romeo and his family have operated for over 25 years in North Jersey, building a business where customers like Raymond McNamee can rattle off crew names (Javier the foreman, Manuel on power washing) because the same faces show up, work through weather challenges, and treat properties like their own.
The numbers sketch one picture: well over 50 Google reviews at 4.9 stars, projects spanning from quick hallway refreshes to complete commercial transformations like the NY NJ Trail Center. But dig into those reviews and a different story emerges. A contractor who covers furniture without prompting, texts morning arrival times, fixes door frames while painting trim. Matt, who can explain paint chemistry and color theory during estimates. Bill, the semi-retired founder, still involved. Carol (sometimes Caryl), coordinating schedules and keeping clients updated through weather delays. These aren't upsold services. They're simply how the operation runs from their unmarked shop on Dehart Avenue in Hewitt.
Romeo Painting Plus holds New Jersey Home Improvement Contractor License 13VH13109000, maintains RRP certification for lead-safe work, and carries the insurance documentation customers never think about until something goes wrong. They've painted metal roofs on log cabins, stripped decades of cigarette smoke discoloration from estate sale prep homes, and stained decks through rain delays while staying in constant communication. The only significant negative review centers on weather-dependent exterior work that took months longer than initially quoted, with the owner's response explaining the realities of working in North Jersey's unpredictable climate rather than making excuses.
Updated: 10-03-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Romeo Painting Plus LLC
Q: Will they actually show up when they say they will?
"Never had to wonder where they were" captures the scheduling reliability multiple reviewers emphasize. The team sends morning confirmation texts and arrives within promised windows. One customer noted "first contractor in 10 years to show up on time three days straight," while another praised their promptness after previous contractors had failed to follow through. This consistency extends through project completion, with crews working full days rather than disappearing mid-job.
(Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp)
Q: What happens when things go wrong or projects hit obstacles?
The Mitchell Kass situation offers insight. After a May deposit and promised six-week timeline stretched to October for exterior work, the owner's response acknowledged the frustration while explaining that "your work was 100% weather dependent" and they prioritize quality over rushing through poor conditions. Other reviews show the team handling obstacles differently. When Robert D.'s cedar siding aged poorly in spots, they rubbed down problem areas, polished, brushed, then restained rather than accepting subpar results. Adam Lederman's tight timeline between home closing and move-in had Matt coordinating with floor installers, plumbers, and electricians to keep everything on schedule.
(Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook)
Q: Do they handle commercial work or just residential?
The Peggy Vindeed review reveals commercial capability: "Romeo Painting did an outstanding painting job on our beloved Trail Center in Mahwah NJ," describing the community facility project as punctual, neat, and fairly priced. Maria Ralph Guadagno hired them for drywall installation with quick turnaround when commercial space needed urgent work. The focus remains residential (over 80% of reviews mention homes), but they clearly handle community buildings, offices, and light commercial projects when requested.
(Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook)
Q: What about their prep work and cleanup?
"Crew covered all walls and floors as they were painting the ceiling" from Dorothy Osusky's review represents the standard approach. Christine Thares noted they "left the room just the way they found it." Joe Lambert's knotty pine 1960s panels required extensive sanding, two coats of BIN primer to seal knots, then two finish coats, with thorough cleanup afterward. Multiple reviews specifically mention cleanliness and protection of existing finishes. The pattern suggests prep work and cleanup aren't add-on services but integral to how they approach every project.
(Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews)
Q: Can they match existing colors or work with unusual requests?
Color matching appears to be a strength. Several customers praised the ability to "perfectly match 10-year-old paint" and "blend new patches invisibly into existing walls." Matt's paint knowledge gets mentioned repeatedly in reviews, with Adam Lederman noting his "extensive knowledge of paint and colors was incredibly helpful" when making selections. Robert D. worked with them to select the right cedar siding color, with extra attention paid to sun-exposed areas that required different treatment than shaded sections.
(Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp)