Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Romeo Painting Plus LLC
Matt Romeo founded Romeo Painting Plus LLC from the family's Hewitt workshop, building the business over 25 years into a respected North Jersey painting and renovation company. Matt handles estimates and color consultations while Caryl manages scheduling and client communication from the office. Bill, the semi-retired original boss, still conducts estimates and oversees quality. Crew leader Javier runs job sites with painter Manuel handling power washing and prep work.
The veteran and family-owned company specializes in interior and exterior painting, with particular expertise in deck staining, cabinet refinishing, power washing, and smoke damage restoration. Projects range from single-room refreshes to complete home transformations, including work on historic properties requiring preservation techniques. They also handle kitchen and bathroom remodeling, custom millwork, and wallpaper installation.
The fully licensed, insured, and bonded team holds New Jersey Home Improvement License No. 13VH13109000 and is EPA RRP lead-safe certified for work on older homes. Romeo Painting Plus serves West Milford, Montclair, Ridgewood, Mahwah, and surrounding North Jersey communities within approximately 30 miles of Hewitt.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Multiple customers highlight reliability as a defining trait. Adam Lederman describes how "the team showed up promptly at 7am the next day" after his closing, while mohannad zindaki notes Matt "fit us into schedule last minute." Raymond McNamee adds that even when weather created challenges, they made efforts to complete his power washing, "even working in the rain at times." Scheduling coordination through Caryl keeps projects on track.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Adam Lederman's experience demonstrates their coordination abilities. He explains that "Matt coordinated with floor guys, plumber, electrician" to ensure everything stayed on schedule during his move-in timeline. Matt was present "the afternoon of closing" to assess needs, and the painting team integrated seamlessly with other trades. This single point of contact approach prevents scheduling conflicts and communication breakdowns.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Reviews consistently mention thorough preparation before painting begins. Dorothy Osusky praises their "excellent job with prep, paint job, and clean up." Joe Lambert describes how they handled his challenging knotty pine panels with "two coats of special BIN primer to cover knots" before painting. Kelli Whritenour notes they proactively "found rotted wood by window, replaced it rather than paint over it" instead of ignoring the issue.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Color consultation stands out as a strength. Adam Lederman credits "Matt's extensive knowledge of paint and colors" as incredibly helpful during his project planning. Robert diaz explains they "worked together to select color" for his cedar siding, with the team paying additional attention to areas where age affected absorption. Customers appreciate the guidance rather than being left to figure out selections alone.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cleanliness receives frequent praise across reviews. Joe Lambert notes they "cleaned up very well afterwards" on his interior project. Customers mention the crew keeps work areas tidy throughout the day, not just at project completion. Jeff Piecuch, whose property had cigarette smoke damage, describes the transformation where "everything looked clean and fresh" after their work preparing the home for sale.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers consistently describe pricing as fair and competitive. Karim El Moslemany summarizes his experience as "reasonably priced, quality work, very professional." Mohannad zindaki mentions Matt "gave us great price" while fitting them into a tight timeline. Multiple reviews note the value received relative to cost, with no complaints about unexpected charges or inflated estimates across the review history.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Speed without sacrificing quality appears throughout reviews. Daniel Hankinson notes they "completed job in just two days" and emphasizes it "wasn't a small task." Craig Rowles praises the team for being "super fast" while demonstrating they "know the products inside and out." The combination of experienced crews and efficient processes allows them to accommodate urgent timelines when needed.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The single negative review pattern involves one customer (Mitchell Kass) frustrated by weather delays on exterior work. The owner responded professionally, acknowledging the experience was "less than ideal" while explaining exterior painting is "100% weather dependent." Records show ongoing communication through emails and texts throughout the season. With 80 five-star reviews against this isolated complaint, the pattern suggests an unusual circumstance rather than systemic issues.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Updated: 04-07-2026