Top-Rated Painters Manalapan, NJ (Chooz Score Ranked)

Showing 5 painters servicing Manalapan, NJ

Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting gallery imageJaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting gallery imageJaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting gallery imageJaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting gallery image

About Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting

When Kaela DiBella needed her home painted with minimal disruption, Jaime's Renovation LLC completed the job so seamlessly she called the process "incredible" and immediately began recommending them to family and friends. This balance of speed without compromising quality defines how Jaime Villanueva operates his painting and renovation business from a modest shop on Norwood Avenue, understanding that behind every project timeline is a family eager to reclaim their space or a business losing revenue during renovations.

The numbers tell one story: over 150 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars, projects ranging from $500 touch-ups to complete commercial transformations like their featured work on FOX's Kitchen Nightmares at Max's Bar. But the reviews reveal something different. A contractor who protects furniture without being asked, who stays late Friday to ensure families have their kitchens for the weekend, who sends morning confirmation texts so customers never wonder where their crew is. These aren't services advertised on their simple website; they're simply how Jaime's team of fully insured professionals has operated for over twenty years.

What's notably absent speaks volumes: no BBB accreditation, minimal web presence beyond Google, no Angi listing despite being in business since the early 2000s. Yet Jeffrey Spitzer recommends them "1000%," and multiple customers describe experiences that exceeded expectations with work that made neglected rooms look "virtually brand new." From their unassuming Long Branch location, Jaime has built something that operates more on trust than marketing, where EPA RRP-certified crews handle everything from delicate cabinet refinishing to complete bathroom transformations, creating relationships where customers like Deb Reilly still call after ten years because, as she notes, he was her "first customer" and the trust never wavered.

Other Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.9
(171 reviews)
Facebook

100% Recommended (3 Reviews)

Yelp
2.3
(3 reviews)

* Reviews Last Checked: 09-29-2025

Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?

Get StartedFREE SERVICE
T. Whitaker Painting gallery imageT. Whitaker Painting gallery imageT. Whitaker Painting gallery imageT. Whitaker Painting gallery image

About T. Whitaker Painting

With over 8,000 homes transformed since 1987, T. Whitaker Painting brings 38 years of family-operated expertise to Ocean, Monmouth, Burlington, and Atlantic counties in Southern New Jersey. This fully licensed and insured contractor has earned well over 150 five-star Google reviews through consistent delivery of exceptional residential and commercial painting services.

The company excels in both standard painting projects and specialized services including cabinet refinishing, wallpaper installation, popcorn ceiling removal, and power washing. Led by owners Tim and Liz Whitaker, the team follows a meticulous five-step process—from initial consultation through final cleanup—ensuring every project meets their exacting standards. Liz's renowned color consultation service helps homeowners navigate selections with confidence, while Tim's master painter skills tackle the most challenging technical requirements.

What distinguishes T. Whitaker from competitors is their comprehensive approach to customer service. Each project includes a 2-year warranty, 100% satisfaction guarantee, and EPA RRP-certified professionals who treat homes with exceptional care. Customers consistently praise their punctuality, with painters arriving exactly at scheduled times, protecting every surface, and leaving properties "cleaner than when they started." Their HomeAdvisor Top Rated Professional status and 0% financing options make quality painting accessible without compromising on craftsmanship or reliability.

Other Reviews & Ratings

Google
5.0
(164 reviews)
Facebook

82% Recommended (27 Reviews)

Yelp
5.0
(6 reviews)

* Reviews Last Checked: 09-29-2025

Richard K. Moore Professional Painting gallery imageRichard K. Moore Professional Painting gallery imageRichard K. Moore Professional Painting gallery imageRichard K. Moore Professional Painting gallery image

About Richard K. Moore Professional Painting

When Nancy Remini needed her Long Beach Island house painted after two decades of using the same contractor, she didn't expect Rich Moore to make the trip. But he did, tackling extensive prep work on a weathered shore property that would make most contractors decline the job. Twenty years of trust earned through consistent performance. That timeline reveals something most painting companies never achieve: customers who call back not just for touch-ups, but for entirely new properties, second homes, family members' projects.

The numbers tell a surface story. Over 145 Google reviews averaging 5.0 stars. Forty years operating from a Freehold Township base since 1985. Licensed with NJ Division of Consumer Affairs (13VH04229900), EPA Lead-Safe certified. But the Google reviews expose patterns that paint catalogs can't capture. A contractor who texts morning confirmations unprompted. Painters who rehang artwork without being asked. Crews that arrive with M&Ms at estimates, not just to sweeten deals but because Rich and Diane Moore genuinely enjoy the human side of home improvement. When a customer notices one missed spot and calls, Rich doesn't schedule a callback. He's in his truck immediately.

What's missing is equally revealing. No BBB accreditation despite a verified license. Facebook page with 148 followers but virtually no reviews. One lonely Yelp review. This is not a company built on digital marketing sophistication. Instead, customers like Leonard Gray write unprompted essays about painters who need no masking tape for cutting, who clean obsessively, who complete complex cathedral ceiling beam work with flawless lines. His son hired them for a million-dollar Millstone home first, setting expectations sky-high. Rich and his team (Marty, John, Tommy, Brian) met them anyway, project after project, customer after customer, year after year.

Other Reviews & Ratings

Google
5.0
(145 reviews)
Yelp
5.0
(1 reviews)
Angi
5.0
(83 reviews)

* Reviews Last Checked: 09-30-2025

VAN GO PAINTING gallery imageVAN GO PAINTING gallery imageVAN GO PAINTING gallery imageVAN GO PAINTING gallery image

About Van Go Painting

When Jennifer Ricci needed her new home painted after moving in 1998, John from Van Go Painting delivered such exceptional work that 25 years later, she still won't call anyone else. This loyalty, echoed across well over 50 Google reviews spanning decades, reveals something unusual about this Freehold painting contractor. Customers don't just hire Van Go once; they keep John's number permanently saved, calling him back for every project, recommending him to elderly parents, referring him to neighbors.

The statistics suggest a typical painting business: 5.0 stars across over 50 reviews, established 1994, New Jersey contractor license #13VH09208100. But dive into the reviews and a different pattern emerges. Reviewers struggle to articulate what makes John different, repeatedly defaulting to the same words (professional, punctual, clean) while their actions tell the real story. Mary Anne Geskie imagined painting her entire home would be a "nightmare" but found John so quiet and considerate she "forgot he was here." PJ Whalen discovered nail holes "on almost every square inch of drywall" in their newly purchased home. John fixed every single one.

What customers actually pay for but rarely name: John's ability to make an inherently disruptive process feel manageable. He texts morning arrival confirmations. He rehangs pictures in their exact spots once paint dries. When a bedroom color doesn't match expectations, he repaints the wall without charge or complaint. These aren't advertised services. They're simply how John operates after 30 years of understanding that people don't just need painted walls. They need their daily routines preserved, their belongings respected, their anxiety about having a stranger in their home acknowledged.

Other Reviews & Ratings

Google
5.0
(99 reviews)
Facebook

100% Recommended (3 Reviews)

Yelp
5.0
(1 reviews)

* Reviews Last Checked: 10-02-2025

Carfagno Professional Painting LLC gallery imageCarfagno Professional Painting LLC gallery imageCarfagno Professional Painting LLC gallery imageCarfagno Professional Painting LLC gallery image

About Carfagno Professional Painting LLC

With over 100 five-star Google reviews and a consistent track record of exceeding expectations, Carfagno Professional Painting LLC has become the go-to painting contractor for homeowners throughout Ocean and Monmouth Counties. This family-owned operation, established in 2010, brings together seasoned professionals who treat each project with the same care they'd give their own homes.

The company excels in transformative projects that breathe new life into properties. From cabinet refinishing that saves homeowners thousands compared to replacement, to the careful removal of dated popcorn ceilings, their crew handles complex renovations with precision. Customers consistently praise their ability to tackle everything from single-room refreshes to complete home transformations, with particular expertise in detailed trim work where they paint perfect lines by hand without relying on tape.

What distinguishes Carfagno Professional Painting is their reliability and communication. Owner Joe Carfagno personally handles estimates and color consultations, while his crews led by professionals like Justin, Mark, and Skylar arrive promptly at 7:30 AM and maintain spotless work areas throughout each project. Their competitive pricing reflects honest value rather than corner-cutting, and they back every job with a satisfaction guarantee that has earned them an A+ Better Business Bureau rating and loyal customers who refuse to work with anyone else.

Other Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.9
(126 reviews)
Facebook

100% Recommended (4 Reviews)

Yelp
2.3
(4 reviews)
Angi
5.0
(10 reviews)

* Reviews Last Checked: 09-30-2025