Homeowners in Nutley, NJ have access to several highly rated painting contractors with strong track records across multiple review platforms. From family-run operations with decades of experience to newer companies that have quickly built loyal customer bases, these contractors stand out for their craftsmanship, reliability, and customer service.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Touch Of The Brush Painting led the pack with a Chooz Score of 89.2%. This father-and-son operation has over 220 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus over 230 reviews on Angi at 5.0 stars and over 65 Yelp reviews at 4.9 stars. With over 45 years in business and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, owner Jack Sciueche and son Victor have built a company where customers describe the experience as seamless from estimate to completion. If you value a contractor who treats smaller jobs with the same care as major projects, Touch Of The Brush is a solid choice.
- Reviewers frequently note that Victor personally follows up after estimates, often answering questions outside normal business hours
- Commercial clients, including office buildings, praise the crew's ability to work around active business operations without disruption
- Multiple customers mention neighbors commenting on how polite and professional the crew appeared from the outside
"I hardly ever give any reviews. Jack and his team exceeded my expectations. Repainted my whole house in the projected time frame they gave me from day 1. Corrected all my problems and concerns I had. I'm very particular on how I want things done - Jack and his team performed!" - Michael Massaro, Google Review
Tied for the second-highest score in the area, Elite Painting & Powerwashing Inc. earned a Chooz Score of 88.7% with over 250 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Tony DiGrezia has been serving North Jersey for over 25 years, and what sets this company apart is the project management structure. Danny, the project manager, appears in dozens of reviews for his hands-on approach - texting homeowners before crew arrivals and stopping by multiple times during active projects. If you want consistent communication throughout your project, Elite delivers.
- The crew handles water damage repairs alongside painting, allowing homeowners to work with one contractor for both issues
- Several reviews mention crews returning to address touch-ups without being asked, catching imperfections on their own
- Customers with older homes note the team's experience with cedar siding prep work - power washing, sanding, and priming before paint
"The best painters in the world. Tony, the owner was super nice. His crew did a fantastic job painting the exterior of my house. I have a very old house with cedar siding. They came in, power washed, sanded, primed it, then painted. What I liked about Elite Painting is they have a Project Manager called Dan who made sure the project was on time and on budget." - Al Valentin, Google Review
Also earning a Chooz Score of 88.7%, Brush House Painting and Flooring Services of North Jersey has built an impressive review volume with over 600 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and over 14 Angi reviews at 5.0 stars. What makes this company unique is their dual expertise in painting and flooring - allowing homeowners to coordinate both services under one project manager. Their Lifetime Warranty on workmanship is backed by NJ License No. 13VH12404800.
- The same crew names - Santiago, Shawn, Sergio, and Tom - appear across reviews spanning years, showing low turnover
- Customers with century-old homes praise the team's ability to refinish original hardwood floors while simultaneously painting
- Cabinet painting is a specialty, with multiple reviews describing color-matched kitchen refreshes
"Shawn and team are the best in our area! They are very responsive, do excellent work, and most importantly show back up if something is wrong to fix. We have become lifelong clients." - Adam Menner, Google Review
For homeowners in Bergen County and the Fair Lawn area, That 1 Painter North Jersey earned a Chooz Score of 86.1% with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. The company holds EPA Lead-Safe Certification (NAT-F304774-1), making them a good fit for pre-1978 homes where lead paint concerns apply. Project manager Paulo and estimator George are mentioned by name across reviews for their detailed proposals and responsiveness. Their three-year transferable warranty covers peeling, bubbling, cracking, or splitting.
- Several commercial clients, including 2,000+ square foot offices with high ceilings, praise the competitive pricing for large-scale jobs
- The team is known for thorough walkthroughs before leaving, catching details homeowners might have missed
- Customers note painters removing shoes indoors and protecting floors with care
"That 1 Painter was great! Paolo and his team were fast, clean, easy to work with and of high finish quality. Pricing was very reasonable vs other painting contractors in the area. One week after our first project, I asked them to come back to patch, skim and paint other rooms." - Jeremy DeSane, Google Review
With nearly 40 years in business, Mark Tirondola Jr. Painting Contractor LLC has earned a Chooz Score of 85.4% based on over 130 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. This company specializes in exterior work on older Montclair-area homes, including carpentry repairs that go beyond typical painting prep. The four-level sanding technique - taking surfaces down to bare wood - contributes to finishes that customers report lasting a decade or longer. If your home needs structural repairs alongside paint, this team handles both.
- An architect who hired them noted being "super impressed with their attention to detail"
- Customers describe the team handling rotten soffits, eaves, porch railings, and window sills before painting
- Neighbor referrals account for many reviews, with homeowners mentioning they hired Mark after seeing work done nearby
"Mark and his team are awesome. They made my three-car garage look brand new. Considerable carpentry repairs, they made it weather tight, oil primer and two coats of oil-based finish coats. Mark was responsive, his team were clean, neat and experts with a hand brush - even painted my birdhouse to match the two-tone garage." - Scott Kennedy, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Nutley, NJ, N&C PAINTING earned a Chooz Score of 84.7% with over 85 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Manuel Castro stands out for his personal involvement from estimate to final walkthrough. With over 10 years in business, Manuel has built a reputation in the Morristown area for responsiveness - customers note he answers calls and texts even on weekends. If you need help selecting paint colors, Manuel provides guidance throughout the decision-making process.
- Customers with tight timelines mention the team completing a 2,500 square foot interior in four days
- Drywall repair quality is a consistent theme, with reviewers unable to tell where patches were made
- The crew vacuums after sanding and tidies work areas daily
"N&C is an amazing painting service. We needed a tight turnaround of less than a week from estimate to completion and N&C delivered. The owner is a true delight. Prompt, professional, excellent communicator for timing and invoices. The painting team was incredibly talented with seamless drywall repair." - Lex Minniti, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi
