Best Painters Near Old Tappan, NJ - Chooz Score Ranked

Why Customers Choose Romeo Painting Plus LLC

Hands-On Leadership

Matt Romeo doesn't just run the business, he's on the job. This veteran and family-owned company has spent over 25 years serving North Jersey, and customers consistently mention Matt by name for his personal involvement from estimate to completion. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Matt personally handles color consultations, coordinates with other contractors, and maintains oversight throughout every project:

• Matt was present "the afternoon of closing" for one customer, coordinating with floor installers, plumbers, and electricians to keep a tight move-in timeline on track
• Office manager Caryl handles scheduling while Bill, the semi-retired original boss, still conducts estimates and quality checks

"Matt's extensive knowledge of paint and colors was incredibly helpful, and he provided valuable guidance throughout the project." - Adam L., Google Review

Craftsmanship You Can See

Customers consistently praise the crew's preparation work before any paint is applied. The team doesn't cut corners, and it shows in the finished results. Reviews highlight attention to problem areas that other contractors might overlook:

• Dorothy O. noted the crew "covered all walls and floors" and did an "excellent job with prep, paint job, and clean up"
• Joe L. described how they applied "two coats of special BIN primer to cover knots" on his challenging knotty pine panels
• Kelli W. appreciated that they "found rotted wood by window, replaced it rather than paint over it"

"The painting completed by Romeo was outstanding! The crew was courteous and cleaned up after each day." - H-man, Google Review

Years of Consistent Results

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Romeo Painting Plus LLC had over 70 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 88.4%. With 5.0 stars on Yelp and 88% recommended on Facebook, they've built cross-platform consistency that reflects genuine customer satisfaction:

• NJ Home Improvement Contractor License No. 13VH13109000 verified active
• EPA RRP lead-safe certified for work on older homes
• Repeat customers like Raymond M. have "used them for a couple of projects in the past" and keep coming back

"Reasonably priced, quality work, very professional. I'll use again and I highly recommend." - Karim E., Google Review