6 Best Painters Near Pitman, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Pitman, NJ and the surrounding South Jersey area have access to several highly-rated painting contractors with strong track records across Google, Facebook, and Yelp. These companies range from family operations with decades of experience to newer businesses built by skilled tradespeople returning to their roots. What stands out across the reviews is how often customers mention specific crew members by name, a sign that these contractors rely on consistent, in-house teams rather than rotating subcontractors.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Original Design Painting had over 320 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 88.3%. Owner Recep Ozbas and his son Beytu run a family operation with over 20 skilled painters and more than 22 years in business. They also maintain 100% recommended on Facebook with over 30 recommendations. If you have an older home with challenging surfaces like cedar siding, this company has handled projects on homes over 100 years old.

• Customers regularly mention Recep visiting job sites to check on crews and ask how things are going
• Quick turnaround is common, with some exterior jobs completed in just two days
• The team handles wood repairs and siding replacement alongside painting

"They completed everything in only two days and were very patient with me and all my color changes. They were also by far the most reasonably priced!" - Briana Pachelli, Google Review

With nearly six decades serving Burlington, Camden, and Gloucester Counties, Cherry Hill Painting is now a second-generation family business with Doug Andersen at the helm since 1983. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 130 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company also holds 5.0 stars on Yelp with over 20 reviews and is 100% recommended on Facebook. If you need a contractor who handles both residential homes and commercial buildings, this team works across both settings.

• The Mac and Muhammet crew appears across dozens of reviews as a recognizable, consistent team
• Dana handles scheduling and billing while Brandon conducts estimates
• Historic building work includes The Haddon Fortnightly building in Haddonfield

"Their painters Mac & Muhammet took extraordinary care in making the exterior of our home look lovely. They arrived on time, carefully did all the prep work, and then applied two coats of paint to our trim & siding." - D. R. Bennett, Google Review

For homeowners who value quick response times, Sanders Painting LLC has built a reputation around owner Lamarr Sanders' exceptional communication. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 90 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. With over 10 years in business serving New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Maryland, the company is a father-and-son operation. One customer reported Lamarr came out within two hours of the initial call.

• Projects often finish ahead of schedule, with one whole-house interior completed in under four days
• Lamarr offers color suggestions and helps customers narrow down options
• Repeat customers dating back to 2016 confirm long-term consistency

"When I spoke to Lamarr, he came out within 2 hrs of me contacting him. He is reasonably priced, friendly & professional. Lamarr & his father did a beautiful job on our kitchen." - Janet Truxton, Google Review

A husband-and-wife team of twin brothers, Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC was started in 2021 by Justin and Christian after returning to their Cherry Hill hometown from years working with their father's painting company in Nashville. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.9% with over 130 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. If you need more than just painting, they handle minor renovations, vanity replacements, and home improvement projects.

• The owners respond to virtually every review with personalized replies addressing specific project details
• Multi-room jobs are often completed in days rather than weeks
• Power washing services are included with some exterior projects

"The owners are very hands on, professional and do amazing work. We renovated an entire house and Painting Plus made the final touches a breeze. They don't stop until everything is perfect!" - Mark Fillari, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Pitman, NJ, Wallpro Painting handles everything from accent walls to 4,000 square foot interiors. They earned a Chooz Score of 83.4% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. The company is also 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Mark Lynch personally handles estimates and oversees projects, with in-house crew members Joe, Kaleb, Joey, and Michael appearing across multiple reviews.

• Cabinet refinishing and kitchen painting are particular strengths
• Historic home work includes removing stuck wallpaper and restoring original character
• Drywall repair and trim replacement are handled alongside painting

"Mark and his team came to my historic house. Not only did they make it modern but they brought the old time feel back into it. I was able to leave them in my house alone all day and never had any worries at all." - Justin Betsch, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and attention to detail emerge as the dominant themes across hundreds of reviews for painting contractors serving Pitman, NJ. Customers frequently describe finished work that exceeds their expectations, with many noting that their homes look better than when they were new. The consistency of these comments across different companies suggests the area has access to skilled professionals who take pride in their craft.

Original Design Painting receives particular praise for workmanship on challenging exteriors. One customer with a 115-year-old Victorian covered in extremely dry cedar siding called the finished result beautiful. Cherry Hill Painting customers highlight the two-coat application process and careful attention to trim and siding. Wallpro Painting earned comments like "a better finish on the ceiling and walls than when everything was new" from William G. on Google. Meanwhile, Sanders Painting LLC has customers describing work that "transcended my home from looking outdated to being one of the best on the block" according to Brendan Klein's Google review. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC owner Justin and his crew receive praise for projects where "they don't stop until everything is perfect."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication stands out as a strength across the top-rated painting contractors serving Pitman, NJ. Customers describe owners who respond quickly to inquiries, explain their process clearly, and keep homeowners updated throughout projects. Several reviews mention same-day or next-day responses to initial quote requests.

Sanders Painting LLC owner Lamarr Sanders has built his reputation around responsiveness, with one customer noting he "responds to calls and texts" and "arrives when he promises to" according to Dan McBride's Google review. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC twins Justin and Christian maintain direct communication throughout every project, with nearly all reviews receiving detailed owner responses. Original Design Painting owner Recep earned praise for coming out for estimates within 24 hours of online requests. Cherry Hill Painting has a structured approach with Dana handling scheduling, Brandon conducting estimates, and crews like Mac and Muhammet executing the work. Wallpro Painting owner Mark Lynch personally handles estimates and "explained the process and timeline clearly" according to Danielle Metzger on Google.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality appears consistently across reviews for painting contractors serving Pitman, NJ. Customers describe crews arriving when promised, often early, and maintaining reliable schedules throughout multi-day projects. Several reviews specifically mention that delays only occurred due to weather, with contractors reaching out to communicate any changes.

Sanders Painting LLC customers consistently describe the team as always on time, with Anyah Reed noting on Google that "Lamar and his team arrived on time to the site each day until the project was complete. Even finished the project a day ahead of schedule." Wallpro Painting earned comments about showing up "exactly on time everyday" according to Jackie Kelley's Google review. Cherry Hill Painting crew member Mack and his team "showed up everyday on time" per Douglas Coleman. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC crews were described as "always on time, so polite" by Madeline Farquharson. Original Design Painting completed one exterior job within a tight insurance deadline, starting and finishing well within the customer's timeline.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Pitman, NJ. Customers describe competitive quotes, reasonable estimates, and work that feels worth the investment. Several reviews mention getting multiple bids and finding these contractors offered strong value compared to competitors.

Original Design Painting was described as "by far the most reasonably priced" by Briana Pachelli after comparing options. Sanders Painting LLC owner Lamarr provided what customers called "a very competitive and more than reasonable estimate" per Chris Smith on Google. Cherry Hill Painting earned comments about "fair pricing" from Nancy Morton and Dan McDevitt noted they were "surprisingly affordable compared to the competition." Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC received praise for being "reasonably priced" from multiple reviewers including Jill Grubb and Carolyn Barrett. Wallpro Painting customers like Cosmo Giovinazzi described the "price was very fair" with a quick turnaround.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and site organization appear prominently in reviews for painting contractors serving Pitman, NJ. Customers describe crews who protect flooring and furniture, clean up daily, and leave homes looking as if no work had been done. This attention to keeping job sites tidy seems to be standard practice across the top-rated companies.

Cherry Hill Painting customers noted the crew "cleaned up after themselves daily and you couldn't even tell they were here" according to S R on Google. Wallpro Painting earned praise for keeping work areas "clean and neat" with Julio Martinez noting "Honestly you wouldn't even know they were there!" Original Design Painting crews laid protective tarps on flooring and furniture, with Sandra Rambo praising their respect for other areas of her home. Sanders Painting LLC customers describe thoughtful preparation including covering floors, cabinets, and counters before any painting begins. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC crews "cleaned up great before leaving" and were described as maintaining clean sites throughout projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customer loyalty runs deep among the top painting contractors serving Pitman, NJ. Multiple reviewers describe returning for second, third, and even tenth projects over spans of years or decades. This pattern of repeat business suggests these companies deliver consistent results that keep homeowners coming back.

Cherry Hill Painting has customers who have used them for decades, with one reviewer noting they returned for a tenth project. Original Design Painting has customers like Sandra Rambo who noted this was her second project with the company, while Kelsey Ferguson wrote "We've used them a couple times now and will be using them again!" Sanders Painting LLC has Christine Burnette, who has used their services since 2016 and referred many family and friends. Chris Smith returned after having a deck done years earlier. Painting Plus Home Improvement LLC has Sharon Ryan praising them for a second time, and multiple reviewers mention planning future projects. Wallpro Painting customers like Julio Martinez stated "We will be calling them back in the near future for another project!"

~Review Snippet Sources: Google