9 Best Painters Near Valley Stream, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The top-rated painting contractors serving Valley Stream, NY have earned some of the strongest ratings on Long Island, with most holding perfect scores across hundreds of combined reviews. Whether you need cabinet refinishing, a full interior repaint, or specialty decorative work, the companies below consistently deliver quality results and reliable service.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, NYCA Contractors, LLC had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 88.9%, the highest in this group. Their specialty is off-site cabinet refinishing: doors and drawers are carefully numbered, transported to their shop for professional spray application, then returned and reinstalled with a finish that consistently reads as factory-applied rather than hand-painted. Guests who see the completed kitchens frequently assume the cabinets were replaced, not refinished. They also maintain 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews and are 100% recommended on Facebook. If you're looking to update your kitchen without the cost of full replacement, NYCA Contractors is a strong choice.

Owner Al (Albano) stands out for a no-pressure approach that comes through clearly across the reviews. He sends quotes quickly by text or phone, accommodates building management requirements and weekend schedules without complaint, and customers preparing to sell their homes specifically book NYCA to get their kitchen camera-ready before listings go live. Romino handles on-site installation with the same care from start to finish.

• Cabinet doors are carefully numbered before removal so each piece returns to its exact original location after off-site painting
• Customers maintain kitchen access throughout the project - doors go to the shop while base cabinets and counters stay in use
• Multiple reviewers with 20-30 year old cabinets report being complimented months later by guests who assumed they installed entirely new cabinetry

"When they brought back the cabinets, I didn't even recognize them. After years of our kids running into them with various objects, they now shine like new. We're putting our place up for sale in a week and this will certainly make a positive impression." - Tim R., Google Review

While NYCA specializes in cabinet work, Teall Painting handles the full range of interior and exterior painting from their Massapequa Park base, with over 12 years in business on Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. The company carries Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692, with all workmanship backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. For customers who want a reliable contractor they can return to for projects over many years, Teall Painting is a good fit.

Owner Charlie Teall stays genuinely involved on every project - checking in daily, providing detailed itemized estimates, and personally walking through scope before work starts. Crew members Victor, Rene, and Gavin appear by name across reviews from entirely different customers, often specifically requested for return visits. Projects that would challenge other painters - cedar siding restoration, mahogany door refinishing, stucco exteriors, wainscoting installation - appear alongside standard interior work with no apparent drop in quality.

• Victor is mentioned across multiple reviews as particularly skilled at detail work and willing to stay late to keep projects on schedule
• Teall estimates are itemized in writing, which customers consistently credit for there being no unexpected costs at project completion
• The crew protected newly installed hardwood floors with paper and drop cloths before starting work - without being asked

"Thomas and crew did a fantastic job! Super nice as well as professional! Cleaned up everyday like they weren't there!!!" - Rosemarie O., Google Review

For homeowners looking to add decorative finishes - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, wallpaper, or ceiling gilding - Interior Finishing NYC brings specialized training most painting contractors simply don't have. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi founded the company in 2003, giving them over 22 years in business, and backs all work with a 3-year workmanship warranty. If you have a specialty finish project other contractors have declined, Interior Finishing NYC is worth calling first.

A pattern comes through clearly from the reviews: customers told by other painters that their project was too unusual or too complex hired Dorian and got exactly what they wanted. He is described as physically working on-site alongside his crew, not managing from a distance, and he provides quotes by phone or video call to save customers time on initial consultations.

• Multiple customers hired Interior Finishing NYC for one room, then immediately booked additional spaces after seeing the finished results
• Dorian accommodates last-minute additions and scope changes once work is underway without the friction customers expect from most contractors
• Reviewers with bold color choices - deep hues, full color drenching, specialty plaster textures - consistently report results that matched their inspiration photos

"His work is exacting, thorough, and artful, and he operates with integrity and kindness." - Claire T., Google Review

Repeat customers and long-term referrals drive nearly every review for CRD Painting Inc. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, with over 90 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo holds Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-59404, verified active through 2027, and has built this company over more than 8 years serving Long Island.

The depth of loyalty in these reviews stands out. One reviewer has hired Camilo across over five different homes and an office. A 60-year-old family drywall business on Long Island refers all their builders and customers to CRD. Prep work is a consistent thread across reviews: floors and furniture covered before a single can opens, careful protection of switches and receptacles, and daily cleanup that leaves homes orderly every evening.

• Camilo redid an entire freshly painted room without complaint after a customer changed their mind about a color once the first coat was on
• Trade and contractor referrals appear frequently, confirming professional-level trust in the quality of the work
• Camilo offers a specific multi-coat technique for bathroom ceilings that multiple reviewers credit with preventing moisture buildup long after the job is done

"I have used C.R.D. Painting Inc. for many jobs in my home. Each and every one has come out amazing. No job is too big or too small. Camillo and his team are professional, reliable and very neat." - Jenna P., Google Review

Also serving the Valley Stream, NY area, Big Expert Painting LLC tied CRD with a Chooz Score of 87.0% and leads this group with over 130 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis Erazo holds Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388, verified active through 2027, and carries EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work in pre-1978 homes - worth asking about if your house predates that year. If you're looking for a contractor who can handle painting and light renovation work under one roof, Big Expert Painting is a good fit.

Denis's range of services is one of the broadest in this group, covering interior and exterior painting, power washing, sheetrock repair, crown molding, pool painting, epoxy floors, and cabinet refinishing. Customers who hire him for one project frequently come back for several more, and his direct phone availability on weekends is mentioned often as a differentiator.

• Denis proactively rescheduled an exterior job two days early after checking the weather forecast, completing before rain without any loss in quality
• Multiple customers note he patched sheetrock and repaired damaged surfaces as part of painting projects, without treating these as separate charges
• One reviewer had a very high chimney other painters refused to bid on - Denis's crew completed it on schedule and to specification

"BigExpert Painting exceeded all my expectations! They were incredibly punctual, arriving right on time every day, which made the entire process seamless. Their reliability was unmatched - they stayed true to their word and delivered exactly what they promised, if not more." - Melva M., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Valley Stream, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earned a Chooz Score of 84.8%, with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. They have been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and are 100% recommended on Facebook. With over 18 years in business and Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-73176 verified active through January 2028, they are a strong choice for larger multi-room or whole-home projects that benefit from a structured project management approach.

Territory manager David Maloney appears more than any other name in the reviews, with customers describing thorough walkthrough estimates, daily on-site supervision, and consistent follow-through. Unlike the owner-operator companies in this group, Precision runs a layered management structure with office support through Trish Gates and dedicated field supervisors Jason Eng and Brendan, which translates to reliable communication across longer projects. One homeowner trusted the crew with a key to his 2,300-square-foot home for a full multi-day renovation, unsupervised from start to finish.

• David Maloney is noted for daily updates by text, call, or email - customers on 6-8 day projects say they always knew exactly where the crew was in the process
• The written contract specifies scope and timeline in detail, which customers credit for eliminating surprises at project completion
• Over 16 new reviews in the last 3 months confirm this company is actively scheduling work right now

"Their work was always done with much care, with attention paid to even the smallest details! The Job Managers, David and Carlos, were very professional and thorough when meeting for an estimate." - Doreen C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Quality comes up in nearly every review for the top-rated painters serving Valley Stream, NY, but the specifics vary in interesting ways. At NYCA Contractors, LLC, craftsmanship centers on finish quality - their off-site spray process produces results customers describe as indistinguishable from factory-applied coatings, with color matching so precise that reviewers who supplied Benjamin Moore samples report a perfect result. For Teall Painting, quality shows up in the precision of detail work: crisp paint lines, clean edges on trim, and specialty surfaces handled correctly the first time - cedar siding, mahogany doors, cathedral ceiling repairs using specialty products other contractors wouldn't attempt. At Interior Finishing NYC, quality takes on a different meaning entirely. Owner Dorian Golemi brings formal fine arts training to decorative applications like limewash, Venetian plaster, and Roman clay, and reviewers who brought inspiration photos consistently report results that matched or exceeded what they envisioned.

CRD Painting Inc earns quality marks through surface preparation that goes well beyond what most crews do. Camilo's team caulks, spacklles, sands, and addresses wall and ceiling imperfections before any paint opens - customers describe surfaces that look completely replaced after the work is done. Big Expert Painting LLC and Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge each draw quality praise for even coverage, crisp trim lines, and thorough wall repair before painting begins. Multiple reviewers at both companies describe being asked to walk through and inspect each room before the crew departed, with any concerns addressed before they left for the day.

"They refinished my kitchen cabinets and they look brand new. Last time they refinished our bedroom wall unit and after 4 years they still look brand new. I can't recommend them highly enough." - Leslie R., Google Review (NYCA Contractors)"The painting work they complete is flawless due to the amount of surface preparation that isn't skimped on. The resulting finish is smooth and professionally done, so the attention to detail is what we have come to expect." - W.P., Google Review (CRD Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities across reviews for the top-rated painters serving Valley Stream, NY, and each company handles it a little differently. NYCA Contractors, LLC owner Al is noted for same-day quote responses by text or phone, a no-pressure approach, and easy accommodation of schedule changes - one reviewer described reaching out after the holidays and picking up right where they left off without any friction. Teall Painting owner Charlie Teall checks in with customers daily throughout each project, provides detailed written estimates that leave no room for surprises, and is described as responsive by call or text throughout. Multiple reviewers note that Charlie confirmed scope details with them in writing before work started. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi provides quotes by phone or video call to save time, and reviewers describe him as easy to reach throughout each project with concerns addressed the day they were raised.

For longer, multi-room projects, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge's project management structure draws consistent praise. Territory manager David Maloney sends daily updates by text, call, or email, and customers on 6-8 day projects note they always knew exactly where the crew was in the process. Office manager Trish Gates handles scheduling communication, adding another layer of professional touchpoints. CRD Painting Inc and Big Expert Painting LLC earn professionalism marks through owner accessibility - both Camilo and Denis answer calls and texts directly, respond quickly to estimates, and are described as present for walkthroughs at the start of every job. Both companies draw reviews from customers who felt comfortable leaving the crew in their homes unsupervised.

"Charlie immediately responded to any questions that we sent his way, whether by call or text... Charlie also checked in with us on a daily basis to evaluate the progress of the job, make sure there weren't any problems, and see if we had any additional needs." - Michael D., Google Review (Teall Painting)"David told me in the beginning the job should take 4 to 5 days, and sure enough his crew was done on time. Carlos did a fantastic job with the painting of the interior of the house. My wife and I are pleased with the work Precision Painting did." - Jean A., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness is a recurring theme in reviews for the top-rated painters serving Valley Stream, NY, with several companies earning specific praise for finishing ahead of schedule. Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out for speed on residential work - one reviewer described a 4-bed, 2-bath home completed in under 48 hours, and another noted an exterior job finished several days ahead of the original estimate. Owner Andres Gallego scales crew size to project scope to keep timelines tight. NYCA Contractors, LLC customers describe going from initial quote to completed cabinet refinishing in as little as 1.5 weeks, which is notably fast given the off-site spray process involved. The turnaround is consistent enough that multiple reviewers mention it as a specific selling point after getting slower timelines from competitors.

Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis checks the weather before exterior work and proactively rescheduled one project two days early to beat incoming rain, completing on time without any loss in quality. Teall Painting's Victor is described across multiple reviews as willing to stay late to keep projects on schedule, and customers on whole-home repaints consistently note Teall hit the completion dates they were given. CRD Painting Inc's Camilo is noted for honest upfront timeline estimates - one reviewer described a 3-day commitment met exactly as promised, with the crew working a little longer on the final day to deliver on schedule. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge builds timeline estimates into their written contracts, with multiple reviewers noting the crew finished on or before the stated date even on complex multi-day projects.

"Gave me an estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B., Google Review (Big Expert Painting)"They not only had the best pricing but the workmanship was amazing and they finished before the estimated time!" - Greg S., Google Review (Teall Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup separate professional painters from those who are simply fast, and it shows up consistently in reviews for the top-rated contractors serving Valley Stream, NY. NYCA Contractors, LLC's process begins with carefully numbering each cabinet door before removal so every piece returns to its exact original location - a level of organizational detail customers frequently call out specifically. Their vacuum-sanding approach at the shop means no dust spreads through the home during prep work, which matters for customers staying in their homes throughout the project. CRD Painting Inc's Camilo is described across multiple reviews as covering all flooring and furniture before anything opens, with careful protection of switches, receptacles, and surfaces not being painted. One reviewer detailed Camilo's technique of applying multiple coats of differing paints to bathroom ceilings specifically to prevent moisture problems long after the job is done.

Teall Painting's crew puts down plastic sheathing, builder's paper, and drop cloths before work starts, and customers with recently installed hardwood floors specifically note the crew protected them without being asked. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge leaves homes in a "useable condition" at the end of each workday, with furniture moved, covered, and returned to its original place before the crew departs each evening. Big Expert Painting LLC customers note the team consistently cleaned up after themselves daily, with several reviewers mentioning the crew took initiative moving and covering personal items without direction. At Interior Finishing NYC, Dorian's team keeps specialty finish work contained and organized even on multi-day decorative plaster or wallpaper projects in occupied homes.

"They take the time necessary to protect the space from paint drips, they are careful to not paint receptacles, switches or anything else that is not supposed to get painted." - Reyes H., Google Review (CRD Painting)"When our job was complete you never knew they were even there. We are very happy with the work and the quality." - Melinda S., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair pricing comes up across nearly every review for the top-rated painters serving Valley Stream, NY, with several companies specifically noted as the most competitive option after multiple estimates. NYCA Contractors, LLC customers consistently describe cabinet refinishing as a fraction of the cost of full cabinet replacement - one reviewer noted they had wanted to renovate for five years and the NYCA price finally made it realistic. Owner Al's quotes are described as fair and accurate, with no pressure to decide quickly and no added charges at the end. Teall Painting's Charlie was selected over several other painters by one reviewer specifically on price, with the reviewer noting the workmanship turned out to also be the best. Teall's itemized estimates are credited with eliminating any cost surprises at project completion.

CRD Painting Inc's Camilo draws consistent value reviews on multi-room and whole-home projects, with customers describing quotes that were accurate to the final invoice. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis is described as easy to reach for estimates, often responding the same day with competitive pricing - and several reviewers who collected multiple quotes came back to Denis because his price was the best without sacrificing quality. Interior Finishing NYC earns value marks specifically for specialty work, with customers noting Dorian's prices for limewash, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper came in below other specialists they contacted. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge positions slightly higher in the market given their project management structure, but customers consistently describe the pricing as reasonable for the scope of what they deliver - and one repeat customer noted the quote came in lower than competitors despite the company's larger operational setup.

"Nyca's prices are fair and in line with the time and effort that was invested in the job. My 30 year old cabinets look like new!!" - Yossi P., Google Review (NYCA Contractors)"I hired Precision Painting after getting 3 estimates. They are by far the most reasonably priced." - Helen G., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Several of the top-rated painting contractors serving Valley Stream, NY offer specialty work that goes well beyond standard painting. NYCA Contractors, LLC is the most focused specialist in this group - their entire operation is built around off-site cabinet refinishing using an industrial spray process with high-quality Italian-brand paints. Cabinet doors are documented, removed, transported to their Norwalk shop, spray-applied in a controlled environment, and reinstalled at home. The finish is described by reviewers as factory-quality, and the company has handled 20-30 year old oak, veneer, and lacquered cabinets that other contractors declined. If kitchen cabinet refinishing is your primary need, NYCA is the most specialized option in this area. For homeowners interested in decorative wall finishes, Interior Finishing NYC stands alone in this group. Owner Dorian Golemi trained at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, wallpaper installation, and ceiling gilding.

Teall Painting and Big Expert Painting LLC both offer cabinet refinishing alongside their standard painting work, and each has earned strong reviews for that specific service. Big Expert's Denis also installs crown molding, handles sheetrock repair, and takes on bathroom renovations - making him a good choice for homeowners who want painting and light renovation handled by a single contractor rather than coordinating multiple trades. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge offers cabinet painting as part of their broader interior work, and their crews have received strong reviews for kitchen cabinet projects alongside whole-home painting contracts.

"They painted my old outdated kitchen cabinets and made them look like they came direct from the showroom! They also installed a new backsplash! The entire job was done amazingly professional and with great attention to detail!" - Ronnie M., Google Review (Big Expert Painting)"Dorian and his crew from Interior Finishing NYC did an amazing job with the Roman Clay application to the interior of our project. Not only were they professional, but also attentive to detail which rendered absolutely beautiful results." - Brittaney E., Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google