Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Elite Painting Services Plus
Elite Painting Services Plus has built its reputation across Nassau County by applying a prep-first approach to every residential and commercial painting project. The Malverne-based team, led by founder Benny Montalbano, begins each job with a detailed surface inspection using laser measuring tools to identify water damage, stress cracks and uneven walls before any brush touches a surface.
Crew leaders like Dave, Tony and their painters follow a documented process that includes thorough floor and furniture protection, daily cleanup and a final walkthrough with the homeowner. Clients working with office manager Kelly receive hands-on color consultation support, with sample testing and recommendations tailored to each room's lighting and function.
As an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm and Malverne Chamber of Commerce member, the company brings both safety credentials and community roots to projects ranging from single-bedroom refreshes to full-home renovations across the Town of Hempstead, Oyster Bay and beyond. Featured on NBC's George to the Rescue, Elite has earned multiple Best of Long Island nominations while maintaining a 4.9-star Google rating across nearly 280 reviews.
Updated: 06-11-2026
Homeowners describe a crew that arrives with floor coverings, plastic sheeting for doorways and laser measuring tools for precise wall assessment. Raffaella Marciari noted her crew taped paper on the floor and plastic on the doorways before touching a brush, while Patricia Johnston explained that the team leader goes over the entire scope before starting. Clients repeatedly say the space looks cleaner when the painters leave than when they arrived.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Kelly serves as the dedicated color consultant for the company. Laura Wise described how Kelly came to her home and helped select colors for every room, and Karen Zang called the team meticulous perfectionists after Kelly guided her through choices. For clients who change their minds mid-project, the office works through multiple rounds of sampling without frustration, as The Tobins experienced when they switched schemes more than a zillion times.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The team adjusts crew size and scheduling to meet deadlines. Toniann T hired Elite to paint a new home before move-in on a very short timeline, and Benny accommodated a last-minute change without issue. For Steve's entire house, the team brought in an additional crew and worked a Saturday to finish on schedule. Zahra Rizvi's full gut renovation with second-story extension also ran smoothly with Tony's crew managing every surface.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The crew builds a final walkthrough into their process. Daniel Urick noted the painters returned a short while later to make a few touch-ups, and Ben Gorham's experience included Benny stopping by after the crew left to double-check quality. Christine Gangone praised Dave's crew for their patience with staircase work and their willingness to fix any concern, no matter how small.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The company handles both corporate retail and community-serving buildings. The website highlights work for Christian Dior's Manhasset store and a skin-care salon called Aesthetically Yours. Robert Walsh has hired them on numerous projects at the Franklin Square Library, and Pastor Humberto Chavez praised their work at The Bridge Church in Malverne. CCC, a general contractor, calls them their go-to painting subcontractor for client homes.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple reviewers make direct comparisons to past experiences. Andrea Dimieri called Elite by far the best of many past painting experiences, and Brian Brown wrote a detailed review explaining this is not your typical hit 5 stars and write nice words before laying out specific reasons for the rating. Lori Abramowitz interviewed multiple painters but knew after meeting Benny that she wanted to work with him. Eileen Ward noted she has worked with multiple painting companies and Elite does the best work.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The company holds an active Nassau County Home Improvement license under the category of Home Improvement with a Painting designation. The license remains valid through late 2027. Elite Painting Services Plus Inc. is registered as an active Domestic Business Corporation with the New York Department of State, filed in Nassau County.
-Verification Sources: Nassau County Consumer Affairs, NY Department of State Division of Corporations
Updated: 06-11-2026