Homeowners in Bayville, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong track records across multiple review platforms. Whether you need a full exterior repaint for a coastal home, decorative plaster finishes, or a quick interior refresh, the top-rated companies in this area consistently earn praise for reliable communication, clean job sites, and skilled crews that customers call back again and again.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Owner Charlie Cascio built the company name from his five children's initials - Tyler, Ella, Ava, Lucas, and Lia - and that family-first approach carries into how his crews treat customers' homes. Multiple reviewers describe how Charlie provides virtual estimates for convenience, then follows up with constant communication throughout the project. If you want a licensed Long Island contractor with a 2-year warranty who handles everything from cabinet refinishing to vinyl siding, Teall Painting is a solid choice.
What stands out in the reviews is how many customers mention specific crew members by name and then hire them again for follow-up projects. Reviewers also frequently note that Charlie personally checks in during and after each job, and several describe being referred by friends or returning for second and third projects.
- Customers highlight that estimates are detailed and transparent, with no surprise costs at the end of the project
- Several reviews mention specialty work including mahogany door refinishing, deck staining, and western red cedar restoration
- Commercial clients, including a fitness studio and a salon, praise the crew's ability to handle business renovations on tight timelines
"My kitchen looks brand new! Excellent work. The crew was fantastic, arrived early, stayed late, cleaned up daily. I would recommend Teall painting without hesitation." - Rita Linchitz, Google Review
When it comes to specialty decorative finishes that most painting contractors won't attempt, Interior Finishing NYC stands out with a Chooz Score of 87.3% and over 120 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper installation. With over 22 years in business and a 3-year workmanship warranty, this company is a great fit if you're looking for artistic finishes or have a project that other contractors have turned down.
Dorian is personally on site for most projects, and reviewers consistently describe him as responsive, honest about pricing, and willing to work around complicated schedules. Several customers note that Dorian provided quotes over the phone or video call to save time, and his crew members Jose, Amir, and Marvin show up repeatedly across different reviews as a consistent, reliable unit.
- Multiple reviewers hired Dorian after other contractors refused their projects, particularly for color-matching faux finishes and restoring pre-war apartment surfaces
- Commercial clients, from corporate offices to retail spaces, praise the team's ability to deliver on short deadlines
"I cannot recommend Dorian and his team highly enough. His work is exacting, thorough, and artful, and he operates with integrity and kindness." - Claire Trempe, Google Review
For homeowners who value a hands-on owner and competitive pricing, Big Expert Painting LLC has earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis answers calls directly, often responds to quote requests the same day, and holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License plus EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes. If you need a contractor who handles everything from power washing to cabinet refinishing to sheetrock repair, Big Expert Painting LLC covers a wide range of services at prices customers repeatedly call fair.
What comes through clearly in the reviews is how many customers hire Denis for one project and immediately book the next. Several describe starting with a single room and then expanding to full interiors, cabinets, and exteriors once they saw the quality of the initial work.
- Customers describe Denis checking in after projects are completed, sometimes calling a month later to make sure everything still looks good
- The crew handles bilingual projects comfortably, with Spanish-speaking customers also leaving enthusiastic reviews
- Power washing, deck restoration, and flooring installation appear alongside standard painting projects
"Beyond satisfied with the work! Used Big Expert Painting to remove wallpaper in our bedroom and to paint two other rooms. The job was completed in the time estimated and totally exceeded my expectations." - Karen Chilicki, Google Review
With over 18 years in business, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge has built a deep presence across Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook, and hold BBB accreditation since 2015. If you're tackling a large-scale project like a whole-home repaint or complex staining job, this company has the crew depth and project management structure to handle it efficiently.
Reviewers frequently mention territory manager David Maloney and project supervisors Jason Eng and Brendan by name, which reflects a company that assigns dedicated points of contact rather than passing customers between departments. One reviewer, a contractor himself, described the experience as the standard every home improvement company should aspire to.
- Multiple customers describe receiving three or more estimates and choosing Precision Painting for the best combination of price and professionalism
- Cabinet painting, garage floor epoxy, and exterior staining projects appear alongside standard interior work
"After doing my due diligence and based upon their amazing reviews, I reached out to Precision Painting Plus for the interior painting of my new home. I knew this was going to be a tremendous project but they handled it with professionalism from start to finish." - Shelley Oliva, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for JRT Pro Painters LLC, which earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 65 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, and customers describe him as honest, responsive, and helpful with color selection. If you need wallpaper removal, skim coating, or drywall repair alongside your paint job, JRT Pro Painters LLC is a good choice for bundled interior work.
- Customers praise Brayan's willingness to help select colors and offer design guidance at no extra charge
- Several reviewers describe whole-house projects completed over multiple return visits as their needs expanded
- Door and molding replacement services are offered alongside painting, giving homeowners a single contractor for full room updates
"I never had such a pleasant experience with people working at my house like I did with JRT Pro Painters crew. They are absolute the best! From the care that they had with our home to the result of the job, everything was perfect." - Janice Simonetti, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Bayville, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego is known for spending extended time on initial walkthroughs, and reviewers describe him offering free color consultations and detailed written estimates. With over 6 years in business, this company is a strong fit if speed matters to you, as multiple customers describe entire homes being completed in one to two days with large crews.
- A six-person crew completed a large whole-home project in a single day, and customers regularly express surprise at the turnaround time
- Both residential and commercial clients leave positive reviews, including a medical office and a consulting firm
"After doing endless research we finally decided to go with Long Island Painting and Restoration. We were renovating our kitchen so we decided to have the whole house painted. Andres came by and went room by room giving us his opinion and pricing." - Verenise Gerardini, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
