9 Best Painters Near Oyster Bay, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Oyster Bay, NY have access to a strong field of painting contractors serving Nassau and Suffolk County, with several companies consistently earning five-star reviews across multiple platforms. The top-rated companies on Chooz Painters stand out for thorough prep work, consistent crew quality, and results that hold up over time. Whether you need interior refreshes, exterior repaints, or specialty decorative finishes, here is a breakdown of the highest-scoring contractors in the area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. The company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Based in Massapequa Park and licensed under Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692, Teall Painting has spent over 12 years in business building a repeat clientele across Long Island. Owner Charlie Cascio handles estimates personally, delivers itemized quotes that eliminate pricing surprises, and stays in contact throughout each project. Beyond standard interior and exterior painting, the team regularly takes on specialty challenges including vinyl siding restoration, cedar home restoration, cabinet refinishing, and commercial studio renovations - all backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty. If you want an owner who personally manages communication and a crew that handles specialty work beyond basic walls, Teall Painting is worth calling.

• Charlie provides detailed, itemized estimates before work begins, with no pricing surprises after the job starts
• The team handles specialty exterior challenges including stucco, vinyl siding restoration, and cedar shingle restoration
• Multiple reviewers describe commercial projects alongside residential work, including gyms, studios, and business spaces
• Scheduling flexibility is a consistent pattern, with Charlie working around tight timelines when customers are in a jam

"Teall Painting is absolutely the best! They recently completed work at my business, and I couldn't be more impressed. Their professionalism, organization, and customer service are second to none." - Joe Reale, Google Review

For homeowners seeking specialty decorative finishes like limewash, Roman clay, or Venetian plaster, Interior Finishing NYC is a standout option in the area. Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, brings an artist's background to every project. The company had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. With over 22 years in business, Dorian and his crew - including Jose, Amir, and Marvin - cover everything from wallpaper installation to ceiling gilding and color-matched plaster repairs on water-damaged walls. Several customers describe bringing Dorian in after other contractors declined their projects. All work is backed by a 3-year workmanship warranty. If your project requires specialty finishes or skilled decorative work, Interior Finishing NYC is a good fit.

• Dorian explains the differences between finish types and paint products before work begins, helping customers make more informed choices
• Color matching on existing specialty finishes is a standout skill, including exact matches on water-damaged faux-painted and strie walls
• Commercial and corporate clients appear regularly, with retail spaces and office turnovers completed on tight deadlines

"Dorian and his team did an incredible job doing lime-wash finish at our business on short notice. They prepped the wall, patched some rough spots, and painted everything as we requested. The lime-wash finish came out much better than we expected." - Lenny Blake, Google Review

The breadth of services sets Big Expert Painting LLC apart from a typical painting contractor. Owner Denis Erazo and his crew take on sheetrock installation, crown molding, marble flooring, cabinet resurfacing, power washing, and bathroom renovations alongside interior and exterior painting. The company had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, holding Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 and an EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes. Multiple reviewers describe starting with one job and immediately booking additional work because of early results. Denis answers calls quickly, often the same day. If you want one crew to handle multiple project types in a single visit, Big Expert Painting is a good choice.

• Denis and his crew handle projects well beyond painting, including sheetrock repairs, crown molding, marble flooring, and kitchen cabinet resurfacing
• Multiple reviewers describe calling for one specific job and adding more rooms or services mid-project because of satisfaction with early results
• Same-day response is a consistent pattern, including one reviewer who had a wall patched, painted, and a TV mounted all on the day of the initial call

"BigExpert Painting exceeded all my expectations! They were incredibly punctual, arriving right on time every day, which made the entire process seamless. Their reliability was unmatched - they stayed true to their word and delivered exactly what they promised, if not more." - Melva M. Miller, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for JRT Pro Painters LLC. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, with crew members Milton, Antonio, and Alex appearing consistently across projects. The company had over 65 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook, and earned a Chooz Score of 84.3%. Holding Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-66725, the crew takes on wallpaper removal, crown molding installation, deck staining, and drywall repair alongside standard painting. Brayan includes color consultation as part of the process, with several reviewers noting his direct input made the final selection easier. If you appreciate a painter who can also handle connected home improvement tasks, JRT Pro Painters is worth a call.

• Brayan includes color consultation in the estimate process, offering direct recommendations rather than just deferring to the customer
• Crew members Milton, Antonio, and Alex appear consistently across reviews, reflecting a stable team rather than rotating subcontractors
• The company handles wallpaper removal, crown molding, deck staining, and drywall repair alongside standard painting work

"Brayan and his colleague, Antonio, were professional, respectful and kind. They exhibited exceptional discipline and care in their painting. They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished. Their work was excellent." - Janette Payne, Google Review

Also serving the Oyster Bay, NY area, Long Island Painting and Restoration has earned a reputation for completing large-scale projects efficiently without cutting corners. Owner Andres Gallego handles walkthroughs personally, offers color recommendations, and scales crew size to meet deadlines. The company had over 55 Google reviews, every one a five-star rating, and earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%. With over 6 years in business, the team has grown almost entirely through word-of-mouth. Several new homebuyers describe Andres as their first call after closing, relying on him for complete pre-move-in refreshes. If you are on a tight timeline and need a crew that can scale up to deliver, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a solid fit.

• Large jobs get scaled-up crews: one reviewer had six painters arrive and complete a full whole-home project in a single day
• Multiple new homebuyers describe Andres as their first call after closing, handling complete pre-move-in refreshes on a quick turnaround
• Andres offers color recommendations and honest expert guidance as part of the consultation process

"Andres was very honest with color picking and gave us his opinion on what will look the best. We had our WHOLE home painted. Walls had to be stripped, spackled and painted - along with the moldings and doors. His workers worked fast and it looks absolutely beautiful!!" - Elizabete Barros, Google Review

With over 20 years in business, CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY has built multi-decade client relationships across Long Island. Owner John Paulik handles estimates personally and uses digital color enhancement tools to help customers visualize exact color choices before work begins. The company had over 150 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, plus 88% recommended on Facebook and BBB accreditation since 2018. The company earned a Chooz Score of 83.9%. Multiple reviewers describe working with John for a decade or more across different properties, and the company has handled everything from waterfront homes to century-old historic structures. A senior citizen discount is available for qualifying customers. If you want a company with a long track record and the range to handle complex or historic properties, CertaPro of Huntington is a strong choice.

• John uses digital color enhancement tools to help customers visualize exact colors before committing - an extra step most contractors skip
• Multiple reviewers describe 10-plus-year relationships with John and his crew, using them across different properties and project types
• The company handles historic properties with care, including century-old homes and the restoration work on a 150-year-old church sanctuary
• A senior citizen discount is available for qualifying customers on exterior painting projects

"We are completely satisfied with the work done by John at CertaPro of Huntington. They did a complete house repaint for us and it looks beautiful. The price was fair and the work was done efficiently and thoroughly. We highly recommend John." - Elane, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of the finished product is the most consistently praised element across reviews for painting contractors in the Oyster Bay, NY area. Teall Painting customers frequently describe results that exceeded their original expectations, with reviewers noting that proper surface prep - from crack repair to careful priming - produced finishes that held up differently than work done by prior contractors. Interior Finishing NYC earns a different kind of quality praise: owner Dorian Golemi's specialty decorative finishes, including Venetian plaster, limewash, and Roman clay, are described by multiple reviewers as looking like works of art rather than a standard paint job. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY draws consistent praise for the quality of detail work around trim, moldings, and edges, with several customers specifically noting that no touch-ups were needed after the crew left.

Big Expert Painting LLC customers frequently describe crews correcting problems left by prior contractors - from sheetrock patches blended so cleanly they are invisible to siding repairs that match the original - before delivering a lasting finish. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns quality praise across both interior and exterior work, including old-home restoration where Andres and his crew scraped, sanded, and brought deteriorated surfaces back to like-new condition. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp has built a loyal base of customers who return year after year specifically because the quality holds up, with repeat clients describing multiple projects over more than a decade without any drop in results.

"The finished job made my apartment look amazing. I told Charlie, in all honesty, that he exceeded my expectations. I would recommend Charlie and his team for any painting job." - Audrey Bolger, Google Review (Teall Painting)"His work is exacting, thorough, and artful, and he operates with integrity and kindness. My apartment had decades' worth of paint applied to the woodwork, and Dorian explained the differences in approach and cleaned it up beautifully." - Claire Trempe, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)"The painters assigned to paint my condo were professionals in every way. They arrived on time and cleaned up at the end of each day. They did a great job - no touch-ups were needed." - Barbara Downing, Google Review (CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY) ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Responsive communication from start to finish is a consistent theme across reviews for the top-rated painting contractors serving Oyster Bay, NY. Teall Painting's owner Charlie Cascio is praised across dozens of reviews for staying reachable throughout each project, with customers describing regular check-ins during multi-day jobs and immediate responses to questions or concerns. Long Island Painting and Restoration's Andres Gallego responds quickly to quote requests and returns personally to walk customers through scope and color choices before crews arrive. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's owner John Paulik is regularly described as easy to reach from the estimate through to the final walkthrough, visiting job sites during projects rather than just showing up at the start and end.

For JRT Pro Painters LLC, owner Brayan Rivas Ticas gets consistent credit for being quick to respond to messages and easy to work with through every stage of a project. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis Erazo answers calls directly and frequently responds to estimate requests the same day, including on weekends. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi regularly provides quotes over the phone or via video call, saving customers time before any in-person visit. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp's Manny takes time before each job to discuss scope, colors, and finishes in detail, with reviewers noting that questions were answered promptly well after project completion as well.

"Charlie and his team were professional from start to finish. From the thorough inspection and estimate to the finished product, the entire process was seamless." - Michelle Scaduto, Google Review (Teall Painting)"John was always easy to get in touch with and made sure the job was moving along well. Very happy with the results. Definitely worth the money." - Susan Holden, Google Review (CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY)"Brayan is very responsive and prices are incredibly fair. The painters were knowledgeable and did a wonderful job. Highly recommended." - Sita Pirozzi, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC) ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Protection of customers' homes and thorough cleanup after each day's work is a recurring theme across reviews for painting contractors in the Oyster Bay, NY area. Teall Painting crews routinely cover floors and furniture with drop cloths, plastic sheathing, and builder's paper before any paint is applied, and multiple reviewers specifically note the space being left cleaner than when the crew arrived. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp's Manny and his team are described as arriving like a well-oiled machine - photographing and removing wall decor, covering every surface, and completing extensive prep work before picking up a brush. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns repeated praise for cleaning up fully at the end of each work day, with reviewers noting the crew arrived to a fresh, organized workspace each morning.

CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY crews protect floors and furniture during multi-day interior projects and clean up at the end of every day, with several customers specifically noting no touch-ups were needed after the job finished. Long Island Painting and Restoration and Big Expert Painting LLC each draw reviews praising spotless post-job cleanup, with customers describing returning to find the space in better shape than before the painters arrived. For homes with new flooring, recent renovations, or fragile surfaces, all of the top-rated companies in the area show consistent records of treating customers' spaces with genuine care.

"They protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless. They were on time each day, and were patient with our decisions. They are a small company with the personal service of a larger one." - Cindy Rantal, Google Review (Teall Painting)"They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down, cover everything and go to work. Lots of time spent on preparation before painting." - Tom Wedell, Google Review (Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp)"Brayan and his colleague, Antonio, exhibited exceptional discipline and care in their painting. They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished." - Janette Payne, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC) ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Transparent, competitive pricing is a common theme across reviews for painting contractors serving Oyster Bay, NY. Teall Painting customers frequently describe detailed, itemized estimates that eliminate surprises, with multiple reviewers noting that the final price matched the original quote even on complex, multi-day projects. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns praise for upfront pricing that customers describe as fair relative to the scope of work, with one long-term client noting the value held up across several projects over multiple years. Big Expert Painting LLC and Long Island Painting and Restoration are each frequently described as providing the most competitive quotes among multiple bids, while still delivering quality that matched or exceeded what other contractors promised at higher prices.

CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's detailed estimate process - which includes written scope, color samples, and a clear cost breakdown - makes the price feel transparent and easy to evaluate. The company also extends a senior citizen discount on exterior painting projects for qualifying customers. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is described by long-term customers as consistently fair over nearly three decades of work, with repeat clients noting that pricing stays reasonable even as project scope increases. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi is regularly praised for coming in under competing quotes while delivering specialty finish work that other contractors charge a premium for.

"Very reasonable price for the amount of work he did for us. He values his job and knows what he's doing." - Shai Bojsa, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Excellent quality work for a fair price. Courteous workers and clean job site. Responsive owner and any unanticipated problems are handled properly and with customers best interest in mind." - Mark Rosenbloom, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)"He worked with our budget, timeframe and color preference and we love the final result. We definitely recommend this business." - Sandra B., Google Review (CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY) ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and on-schedule completion are strong and consistent patterns for the highest-rated painting contractors near Oyster Bay, NY. Teall Painting customers consistently describe crews arriving when scheduled and completing work within the promised timeframe, with Charlie staying in regular contact during multi-day projects so customers always know what to expect each day. Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out for finishing ahead of schedule on a number of projects, with one reviewer describing a four-bedroom, two-bathroom home completed in under 48 hours and another noting their full apartment was wrapped up hours earlier than expected. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns repeated praise for arriving exactly on time each day and putting in full shifts, with reviewers noting the crew cleaned up at the end of every day and started fresh each morning.

CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's crews arrive when they say they will and complete work according to the schedule John Paulik outlines during the estimate - customers on large interior projects describe multi-day timelines that held without delays. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis Erazo is praised for accurate timeline estimates, with multiple reviewers noting the crew even finished early on some jobs. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp responds to initial quote requests quickly and often schedules work within days, with several reviewers noting their projects began the same week as the estimate visit.

"From day 1 we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and completed and what to expect that day. We are beyond thrilled with the finished result!!" - John Calvacca, Google Review (Teall Painting)"From initial consultation to the final product, we had a 10/10 Experience with Andres and his team. His team did an efficient, professional, clean job and even got the job completed quicker than expected." - Patrick Healy, Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)"Brayan and his team were excellent. They arrived on time, immaculate and professional at a reasonable price. I would definitely recommend and use them again!" - Dale Gradel, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC) ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

The painting contractors serving Oyster Bay, NY offer a wider range of specialty services than most homeowners expect when searching for a standard paint job. Interior Finishing NYC is the clearest specialty option in the area: owner Dorian Golemi's fine arts background and over 22 years in business make his team one of the few in the region offering limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic finishes, ceiling gilding, and expert wallpaper installation on challenging surfaces. Several customers describe bringing Dorian in after other contractors declined their projects. Teall Painting handles specialty exterior work that many painters avoid, including mahogany door refinishing, western red cedar restoration, stucco surfaces, and kitchen cabinet refinishing that prior contractors couldn't complete to the customer's satisfaction.

JRT Pro Painters LLC extends beyond standard painting into kitchen cabinet refinishing, deck staining, and crown molding installation - a useful combination for homeowners managing multiple connected projects. Big Expert Painting LLC takes on the broadest range of services alongside painting, including sheetrock installation, marble flooring, full bathroom renovations, and power washing. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY brings over 20 years in business handling historic structures, including century-old homes requiring careful attention to original woodwork and specialty exterior applications such as cedar shake restoration. Long Island Painting and Restoration handles popcorn ceiling removal, wallpaper stripping and repainting, and large-scale restoration work on older homes with deteriorated exterior surfaces.

"I needed someone to do wallpaper hanging, some drywall repair and gilding in my home. It was hard to find a contractor that does all of the services we needed, especially a gilding contractor in NYC. Luckily we found Dorian." - Kha Asia, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)"I have a mahogany front door that faces south and gets abused by the sunlight. I have tried to have it refinished in the past and it did not come out good. The guys at Teall got the door sanded and refinished in a day and it looks like it is brand new!" - Steve Mazziotti, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Bryan and his team just finished painting my kitchen cabinets and I can't believe how good they look. Absolute kitchen makeover for so much less than replacing cabinets in very good condition." - Michael S M, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC) ~Review Snippet Sources: Google