6 Best Painters Near Locust Valley, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Finding the right painting contractor on Long Island's North Shore means knowing who consistently delivers and who has the review record to back it up. The companies serving Locust Valley, NY cover a wide range - from specialty decorative finish artists to decades-long painting businesses with crews customers request by name year after year.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Elite Painting Services Plus had over 90 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp, earning a Chooz Score of 89.3%. Based in Malverne with over 14 years in business, this company holds a verified Nassau County Home Improvement License, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and two "Best of Long Island" wins in 2015 and 2016. Owner Benny handles estimates personally, and reviewers frequently cite their meeting with him as the reason they chose Elite over competing bids. Kelly coordinates scheduling and color consultations, and team leader Tony's interior work draws specific praise across many reviews for precision and efficiency. If you're looking for a crew that handles both large exterior projects and detailed interior painting with the same team from start to finish, Elite Painting Services Plus is worth considering.

• Customers describe the color selection process as collaborative - Benny and Kelly both invest time helping clients narrow paint choices before the crew ever arrives.
• Reviewers returning for third and fourth projects are common, with several noting they stopped seeking competing quotes before calling Elite.
• Crew members Dave (exterior) and Tony (interior) appear by name across years of reviews, pointing to long-term staffing stability.
• Multiple reviewers mention feeling comfortable leaving their homes entirely while the crew worked - a detail that reflects the trust this company has built.

"Our great experience with Elite Painting Services Plus started with the owner, Benny and continued with Kelly who helped us make difficult color choices for our entire house. It continued with team leader, Tony and his amazing and hardworking crew." - Steve, Google Review

For homeowners who want an owner personally involved from estimate through final walkthrough, Teall Painting has built exactly that reputation. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Operating for over 12 years with a verified Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License, Teall backs every project with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Specialty work - cedar siding restoration, mahogany door refinishing, stucco exteriors, and cabinet refinishing - appears regularly in the review record alongside standard interior and exterior painting. If you have a non-standard project that other painters have passed on, Teall Painting is a strong option to call first.

• Charlie Cascio checks in with clients throughout multi-day jobs and follows up after completion - reviewers describe this as consistent throughout the project, not just a sales-phase promise.
• Crew members Ricardo, Eli, Rene, Oscar, Victor, and Gavin are each called out by name in separate unrelated reviews, indicating consistent staffing across projects.
• Commercial clients - including gym studios, a salon renovation, and a church restoration project - appear alongside residential jobs, showing the crew's range of capabilities.

"Charlie and his team were professional from start to finish. From the thorough inspection/estimate to the finished product, the entire process was seamless. Jose and his team arrived on time both days and left our home spotless. We are so happy with the finished product." - Michelle Scaduto, Google Review

When it comes to decorative finishes like limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and gilded ceilings, Interior Finishing NYC stands in a category of its own. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and brings that artistic background to every project. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. Founded in 2003, the company has been in business for over 22 years and backs all projects with a 3-year workmanship warranty. Multiple reviewers note that other contractors declined their specialty projects before Dorian accepted and delivered. If you're seeking decorative finishes, expert wallpaper work, or high-end plaster restoration in the New York metro area, Interior Finishing NYC is a standout choice.

• Clients in design and contracting fields hire Dorian as a subcontractor for specialty work - a sign of trade-level respect for his technical skills.
• Dorian responds personally to virtually every Google review, referencing specific project details in his replies.
• Repeat commercial clients - including corporate offices and retail businesses - bring Dorian back for multiple projects over years of working together.

"I have been working with Dorian and his team for over 10 years. So far it has been an amazing experience. By far the best painting contractor I have worked with." - Jose Maganaaa, Google Review

With over 25 years in business serving Long Island, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has built the kind of multi-decade track record that draws whole-neighborhood referrals and five-time repeat customers. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.7%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 245 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score at that review volume. Their Yelp profile shows 4.8 stars across over 25 Yelp reviews, and they hold over 80 reviews on Angi at a perfect rating. Co-owners Dave Walker and Sal Sciame run an operation where the same crew members appear across years of independent reviews, with Sal visiting job sites daily during active projects. Homeowners who want a painting company to rely on for years - for both large projects and periodic touch-ups - will find Walker Painting fits that need well.

• Sal Sciame regularly provides same-day or next-day estimates and delivers written quotes within hours of his visit.
• Crew members Hugo, Alfredo, Luis, and Alfonso have been with the company for over 15 years per the company's own documentation, and they appear repeatedly by name across independent reviews.
• Walker handles carpentry alongside painting - molding installation, door work, and deck staining all appear in reviews - simplifying the need to coordinate separate contractors.

"My experience with Walker painting was nothing less than fantastic. Their estimator Sal is very professional and caring. He is very responsive, thorough and passionate about his trade. Hugo is a fantastic asset for the team and did an amazing job for my exterior barn doors!" - Laraine Fitterman, Google Review

A hands-on owner and a crew that completes projects faster than most clients expect - that's the pattern that shows up most in reviews for Long Island Painting and Restoration. Owner Andres Gallego earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, the company had over 55 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across every single review on file. Based in Bay Shore with over 6 years in business, this company has grown almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. Andres personally walks through homes room by room during estimates, includes color consultations at no extra charge, and has scaled crews large enough to complete a whole-home project in a single day. New homeowners who need the whole house done before moving in, or anyone working against a tight deadline, will find Long Island Painting and Restoration's turnaround speed particularly practical.

• Andres spends considerable time on initial walk-throughs, with reviewers noting he went room by room providing professional color recommendations before any agreement was signed.
• The company scales crew size to match project timelines - multiple reviewers express genuine surprise that their jobs finished ahead of schedule.
• Clients who first found Andres through a general contractor during renovations often return to book him directly for follow-on home projects.

"Andres and his crew have painted my house on numerous occasions from top to bottom. They are great in every way possible. They are all very skilled in what they do and very clean with no mess ever left behind." - Mike Silversmith, Google Review

Repeat customers and long-term relationships tell the story for CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY. Owner John Paulik has earned a Chooz Score of 83.9%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with an 88% recommended rate on Facebook. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2018 with a perfect customer rating, and with over 20 years in business, they've handled everything from Victorian historical homes to waterfront properties and commercial facades. John uses computer color enhancement to find exact color matches for clients who can't find what they want from standard samples. Homeowners with older homes or architecturally complex exteriors who want a contractor experienced with non-standard challenges will find CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY a reliable choice.

• John provides a detailed, transparent estimate that lays out the full scope of work and costs before any work begins - reviewers consistently cite this as setting the right expectations from day one.
• Historic and ornate homes appear regularly in the review record, including a 150-year-old church and a long-tenured waterfront property requiring consistent seasonal maintenance.
• Crew leads Carlos and Antonio are named with praise across many separate reviews from different customers spanning multiple years.

"It is a privilege to write a review for CertaPro of Huntington, a team of quintessential painting professionals. The great experience began with Chris who provided a realistic, competitive estimate and offered some wonderful suggestions; and continued with the team of 6 painters that spent 6 days painting." - Mary Allen, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Locust Valley, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings over 28 years in business to every project, holding both a Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License and a Nassau County license. This company earned a Chooz Score of 81.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Crew leader Manny is the name most reviewers specifically request - and many customers who have used the company once call back without getting competing quotes the second time around. Projects like vaulted ceiling great rooms, cabinet refinishing, ornate moldings, and built-in bookcases appear alongside standard painting work. Homeowners looking for a company they can return to for years, with a crew that photographs their belongings before removing them for careful replacement, will appreciate what Anthony's Painting brings.

• Manny photographs wall art and decorations before removing them, so clients return to find everything placed exactly as it was before work began.
• Multiple reviewers have used the company across three to five different projects over several years of homeownership, returning without seeking competitive bids first.
• Complex wall conditions - peeling tape joints, nail pop-outs, vaulted ceiling surfaces - consistently receive detailed attention from the crew before any painting begins.

"Manny and his crew are real professionals. I had them paint for the second time and didn't even look around for another price. They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down, cover everything and go to work. Lots of time spent on preparation before painting." - Tom Wedell, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, BBB

Across the reviews for painting contractors serving Locust Valley, NY, professionalism and communication stand out as the qualities customers value most consistently. Elite Painting Services Plus draws repeated praise for owner Benny's responsiveness during the estimate phase and Kelly's office coordination, with reviewers describing the overall experience as seamless from first contact through project completion. At Teall Painting, owner Charlie Cascio earns consistent credit for his communication throughout multi-day projects, checking in daily and proactively updating clients on what was completed and what to expect the following morning. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi is praised for replying to inquiries quickly, providing accurate quotes over the phone or video call, and maintaining clear communication even when clients manage projects from a distance or while traveling.

"Benny was very easy to work with. He answered all of my questions and was always quick to respond. Tony and his crew were amazing. They were clean, precise and efficient. The job they did was awesome." - Julie Levin, Google Review

Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting receives specific praise for Sal Sciame's habit of stopping by job sites each day during active projects and returning calls immediately when questions come up. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's owner John Paulik earns similar marks, with reviewers noting he walks clients through the full scope of work before the first day starts and follows up after completion to confirm satisfaction. At Long Island Painting and Restoration, owner Andres Gallego is described as "always quickly responsive" across many reviews, often providing same-day call-backs and adjusting schedules to accommodate client needs. The consistent thread across these top-rated Locust Valley, NY contractors is that owner involvement doesn't stop at the estimate - the principals stay accessible throughout the project.

"Sal was amazing to deal with. He communicated every step of the way, which is a rare find in this industry." - Brittany Dursi, Google Review"John was always easy to get in touch with and made sure the job was moving along well. Excellent experience. Painting crew was on time every morning and worked cleanly and professionally." - Susan Holden, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanliness are among the most consistently praised qualities for painting contractors serving Locust Valley, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crew leader Manny arrives at every job with a clear process - photographing wall art before removing it, vacuuming surfaces, laying paper on floors, and covering furniture with plastic before a single brush stroke. Customers with vaulted ceilings, peeling tape joints, and nail pop-outs specifically praise how thoroughly the crew addresses problem areas before painting begins. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting draws similar feedback, with reviewers describing drop cloths, plastic sheeting, and protection from the front door through the active work area, furniture moved carefully by the crew and returned in order at the end of each day.

"On time, professional, went above and beyond, left room spotless. Would use again in a nano second." - armand interlicchio, Google Review

Elite Painting Services Plus gets credit for leaving homes spotless even on messy projects - skim coating, water damage repairs, and ceiling replacement work all draw praise for how cleanly the crew managed the workspace from day to day. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY reviewers highlight thorough prep as a consistent strength: scraping, sanding, spackling, and wood repair are called out as happening before any paint is applied, and multiple reviews note that no touch-ups were needed after the crew finished. At Teall Painting, customers praise how crews protected every surface with plastic sheathing and builder's paper, and cleaned up each evening before leaving - a practice that's specifically mentioned even on large multi-day exterior jobs.

"They protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless. They were on time each day, and were patient with our decisions. I can not sing their praises enough." - Cindy Rantal, Google Review"The CertaPro crew did a great job, they were professional, very detailed and addressed all of our concerns. Painting was excellent and left our property clean and beautiful." - Marc Brock, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Quality and craftsmanship are themes that appear in nearly every review for the top-rated painting contractors serving Locust Valley, NY. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi brings a fine arts background to specialty finish work - Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and limewash applications that reviewers describe as matching inspiration photos exactly and completing flawlessly within a single day. Several clients note that other contractors declined their specialty projects before Dorian accepted them and delivered strong results. At Elite Painting Services Plus, reviewers describe finished rooms as looking "brand new" after each project, with fine detail painting on trim, ceilings, and difficult surfaces called out as a consistent strength across both interior and exterior jobs.

"From start to finish, their professionalism, attention to detail, and commitment to quality were exemplary. I appreciated the respect and consideration shown by the team to our property." - Steven McDonald, Google Review

At Teall Painting, quality on non-standard projects is a recurring thread in reviews - a mahogany front door refinished to look brand new after two previous contractors had failed, and western red cedar siding restored alongside woodpecker hole repairs on a first-time homeowner's challenging home. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp customers note that quality extends to difficult surfaces including ornate apartment moldings, vaulted ceilings, and built-in cabinetry. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting reviewers frequently describe results as "looks like new construction" after whole-home repaints, with the crew's prep work quality called out as the foundation of every finished result. For homeowners in Locust Valley, NY with high expectations, these contractors have a review record that supports it.

"As first time homeowners my wife and I were a little anxious having our western red cedar home and deck restored and restained. The color was bleeding and some shingles had damage from previous woodpecker holes. I went out on a whim and contacted Teall - they did an incredible job." - Rhoderick Blasco, Google Review"Interior Finishing NYC did an excellent job - beautiful craftsmanship, attention to detail, and a truly professional finish. Highly recommended!" - Martin Speckmann, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is one of the most consistently praised qualities in reviews for painting contractors serving Locust Valley, NY. Long Island Painting and Restoration draws particularly strong praise for finishing ahead of schedule - a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home was completed in under 48 hours, and entire apartments were done in just a few hours. Owner Andres Gallego scales crew sizes to match project scope, allowing faster completion without cutting corners on the finished product. Reviewers at Elite Painting Services Plus consistently note that crews arrive when expected and complete projects within the stated window - even on jobs where the client kept changing color selections mid-project, the team adapted without missing the overall timeline.

"They finished my entire home ahead of schedule and were prompt every morning and even worked late to assist. Highly recommend!" - Kiran Kapoor, Google Review

At Teall Painting, owner Charlie Cascio's communication includes keeping clients informed about what will be done each day and what to expect the following morning - reviewers describe this transparency as a key differentiator from previous contractors who left them uncertain. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting draws consistent praise for promptness, with Sal Sciame described as providing same-day or next-day estimate appointments, and multiple reviewers noting the crew finished within the stated timeline every time. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's John Paulik is praised for working within tight client timeframes, with one reviewer noting a job that needed to be completed within a week - and the crew made it happen. For homeowners in Locust Valley, NY managing a move-in date or a renovation sequence, these contractors have a strong track record of finishing when they say they will.

"Perfect experience. Job ran on time with excellent results." - Nancy Beckmann, Google Review"The job was done quickly and efficiently. The crew was courteous and clean. They arrived early and got right to work. When the job was finished they looked over everything to make sure it was to my liking." - John Seddo Jr, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Transparent, fair pricing is a theme that surfaces consistently for painting contractors serving Locust Valley, NY. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting provides detailed written estimates that spell out the full scope of work with no surprise additions, and reviewers cite Sal Sciame's willingness to walk through every line item. Teall Painting customers who got multiple bids before choosing Charlie Cascio consistently describe Teall's pricing as the most competitive for the amount of work included. Elite Painting Services Plus draws frequent mention of reasonable pricing, with owner Benny often providing estimates the same day he visits and reviewers describing the price-to-quality ratio as strong after comparing other bids.

"The entire experience was fantastic! The price quoted was very good. The painters were on time and completed the job quickly and cleanly. The paint job was superior." - Bruce Abend, Google Review

Long Island Painting and Restoration's owner Andres Gallego provides itemized cost breakdowns during his room-by-room estimate walk-throughs, and reviewers consistently describe the final invoice matching the initial quote. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's John Paulik works with clients on budget and timeline from the estimate phase, with one reviewer noting CertaPro offered a senior citizen's discount. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp's Manny is repeatedly described as "fairly priced" across reviews spanning over two decades of homeowner relationships - with customers who have used the crew multiple times returning specifically because of the consistent value they receive. For homeowners in Locust Valley, NY getting competing bids, these contractors tend to come in with pricing that holds up to comparison.

"We had received multiple quotes from other companies, and Walker's was by far the most reasonable. Sal was always easy to reach and responsive." - Leslie, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Several of the top-rated painting contractors serving Locust Valley, NY specialize in work that goes well beyond standard wall painting. Interior Finishing NYC is built around decorative finish techniques - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, and gilded ceilings. Owner Dorian Golemi's fine arts training is reflected in a review record full of clients describing perfectly matched accent walls, multi-room color drenching, pre-war woodwork restoration, and complex wallpaper mural installations across challenging surfaces. Many clients note that other contractors refused their projects before Dorian agreed and delivered. Teall Painting also takes on specialty challenges - western red cedar siding restoration, mahogany door refinishing, stucco exterior painting, wainscoting installation, cabinet refinishing, crown molding installation, and deck staining all appear in their review record alongside standard painting work.

"Dorian and his crew are masters of their craft. I hired them to plaster and skim coat all the walls and ceilings in my apartment and they did a fantastic job for a fair price." - Armen Stevens, Google Review"I have a mahogany front door that faces south and gets abused by the sunlight. I have tried to have it refinished in the past and it did not come out good. The guys at Teall got the door sanded and refinished in a day and it looks like it is brand new!" - Steve Mazziotti, Google Review

For cabinet refinishing and built-in furniture painting, both Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp and Long Island Painting and Restoration appear in reviews handling these types of projects. Anthony's customers mention china cabinet painting, built-in bookcase finishing, and ornate staircase rail painting alongside standard interior work. Owner Andres Gallego at Long Island Painting and Restoration personally handles color and sheen consultation for cabinetry and molding projects, and his crew has completed full kitchen cabinet refinishing alongside whole-home repaints for multiple clients. For homeowners in Locust Valley, NY with specialty or restoration projects, these contractors have demonstrated they can handle work that more general painters may decline to take on.

"Dorian and his team did an incredible job on our wallpaper, he is an artist! It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around. He took his time to make sure every piece was perfect, it has come out way better than we ever dreamed." - William Curtis, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google