12 Best Painters Near Brookville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Brookville, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors serving the North Shore and greater Long Island area. From whole-home interior refreshes to specialized exterior restoration, the top-rated companies in this area share a common thread: owner involvement, consistent crews, and projects that finish on schedule.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp. Based out of Massapequa Park and serving Nassau and Suffolk County for over 12 years in business, owner Charlie Cascio handles every estimate personally and stays in direct contact with customers throughout each project. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers mention feeling completely comfortable leaving their homes while crews work unsupervised, a sign of real trust. If you have a specialized project like cabinet refinishing, cedar restoration, or stucco work, Teall Painting is a good choice.

The company backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee, and holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692. Several reviewers also note that Teall was significantly more affordable than competing bids while delivering equal or better quality.

• Multiple customers describe being referred by friends, coworkers, or general contractors, and then referring others themselves after seeing the results
• Reviewers regularly name individual painters like Victor, Rene, Gavin, and Jose, praising their skill and professionalism by name
• Both residential and commercial clients report positive experiences, including a salon renovation and fitness studio projects

"Teall Painting did a wonderful job painting my huge bedroom and spackling all the imperfections and there were numerous ones! They showed up on time, price was reasonable. The owner Charles makes sure you're completely satisfied, he really takes pride in his companies workmanship." - Lori Gillam, Google Review

For homeowners who want a company with deep roots and a proven track record of repeat business, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has earned serious loyalty over more than 25 years in business. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.7% with over 245 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Reviews also span 4.8 stars on Yelp with over 25 Yelp reviews and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 80 Angi reviews. What makes Walker unique is the sheer number of customers who come back four, five, or even ten or more times. If you value consistency and want to build a long-term relationship with your painter, Walker Painting is a strong fit.

Co-owners Dave Walker and Sal Sciame are both actively involved, with Sal handling estimates and checking in on job sites daily. The company holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H3807630000 with zero complaints and zero violations. Customers frequently mention that Walker also handles carpentry work like crown molding, base molding, and shutter replacement alongside painting.

• Elderly homeowners highlight that Walker crews help move furniture, take down pictures, and handle heavy lifting without being asked
• Reviewers describe Sal providing same-day or next-day estimates and starting jobs within days of approval
• Several customers mention choosing Walker after getting multiple quotes, noting the pricing was competitive for the quality delivered

"What an amazing job Walker Painting did in my home. From first contact with Sal to the painters Juan, Martin and Ivan. What a magnificent, clean, precise job. I will definitely use Walker again and will recommend them to everyone." - Deirdre Noonan, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Brookville, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a project-management approach that sets them apart. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook, and have been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015. With over 18 years in business, they hold Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-73176 verified active through January 2028. If you have a large or complicated project that benefits from dedicated project management, Precision Painting Plus is a good choice.

What stands out in the reviews is how many customers mention specific project managers by name, particularly David Maloney, Jason Eng, and Brendan, who each oversee their own field crews. One reviewer who is a contractor himself praised the company as a model for how home improvement should work. Out-of-state homeowners also report smooth experiences managing projects remotely through the company's communication process.

• Customers consistently describe furniture being carefully moved, floors covered, and workspaces left clean at the end of each day
• The company handles specialty work including skim coating, garage floor epoxy, wallpaper removal, and cabinet refinishing
• Multiple reviewers mention getting competitive pricing compared to other estimates, with no surprise charges

"After doing my due diligence and based upon their amazing reviews, I reached out to Precision Painting Plus for the interior painting of my new home. I knew this was going to be a tremendous project but they made me feel so comfortable from start to finish." - Shelley Oliva, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Painting contractors serving Brookville, NY consistently receive praise for the quality of their finished work. Customers describe results that exceed expectations, with many noting that rooms and exteriors look brand new after completion. At Teall Painting, reviewers highlight the company's ability to handle challenging projects that other contractors struggle with, including mahogany door refinishing and western red cedar restoration. "My kitchen looks brand new! Excellent work. The crew was fantastic, arrived early, stayed late, cleaned up daily." - Rita Linchitz, Google Review. Meanwhile, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns consistent praise for prep work that leads to lasting results. "Its about the prep and the time they took filling holes, sanding and skimming where necessary made all the difference. Our walls look like new!" - Anne Carfora, Google Review.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge also receives high marks for workmanship, with one reviewer describing the finished product as "Perfection - is how I'd describe it!" - Kevin Kitson, Google Review. Across all three companies, customers note that painters take their time rather than rushing, paying close attention to edges, trim work, and surface preparation. Several reviewers across Brookville, NY area contractors describe bringing painters back for additional projects specifically because of the quality of the first job.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Brookville, NY. At Teall Painting, owner Charlie is known for providing detailed estimates and keeping homeowners updated throughout each project. "From the initial visit with Charlie to Victor coming to complete this job, everything ran very smoothly and professionally." - Barbara Rosen, Google Review. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting follows a similar pattern, with co-owner Sal Sciame personally visiting job sites daily. "Sal came every morning just to make sure I was happy - never had a contractor do that before." - Susan B., Yelp Review.

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the project management structure means customers always have a named point of contact. "Communication was frequent and clear. I always knew what point they were at." - Theresa Westergard, Google Review. Across the board, reviewers in the Brookville, NY area note that these companies respond quickly to initial inquiries, provide quotes within hours or by the next day, and remain accessible by phone or text throughout the project. Several customers specifically mention that the professionalism they experienced matched or exceeded what they would expect from much larger contractors.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Cleanup and prep work are recurring themes in reviews for painting contractors near Brookville, NY. Teall Painting crews are described as covering floors and furniture with plastic sheathing and drop cloths before starting any work. "They protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless. They were on time each day, and were patient with all of our questions." - Cindy Rantal, Google Review. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting goes a step further for customers who need extra help, with crews moving furniture, taking down drapes, and handling heavy items for elderly homeowners. "We are elderly and really couldn't handle moving items and taking down pictures. Walker was just so accommodating." - Francine Lischner-Call, Google Review.

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, reviewers describe crews leaving homes in usable condition at the end of each workday, even during multi-day projects. "They didn't leave until we inspected each room." - J Miller, Google Review. Across all three companies, the pattern is consistent: floors are covered, furniture is moved or wrapped, and daily cleanup is standard practice. For homeowners in Brookville, NY concerned about disruption during a painting project, these contractors make the process as low-impact as possible.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Homeowners near Brookville, NY frequently comment on the value they receive from top-rated painting contractors in the area. At Teall Painting, multiple reviewers mention that Charlie's estimates came in lower than competing bids while the quality matched or exceeded expectations. "We had about a half dozen painters come by and look at the job and they were all crazy expensive. We needed a full interior paint job and Teall came in at a great price." - Greg Schaeffer, Google Review. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting also earns praise for transparent pricing, with co-owner Sal providing detailed contracts that outline exactly what work will be performed. "Quick, clean, efficient and a great price. Awesome company to work with." - Paul Lochner, Google Review.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers describe receiving competitive estimates and no surprise charges. "PPP gave us an amazing price but more importantly the work was awesome and the communication was fantastic." - Andrew Matz, Google Review. Across the Brookville, NY area, reviewers suggest getting multiple estimates, as several customers note they chose their contractor after comparing three or more quotes. The top-rated companies in this area tend to offer detailed, itemized estimates rather than vague ballpark figures, which helps homeowners understand exactly what they are paying for.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google