5 Best Painters Near Old Bethpage, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The Old Bethpage, NY area is served by a strong group of painting contractors whose reviews share a common thread: crews that show up prepared, owners who stay involved from the first call through final walkthrough, and finished work that sends customers back for their next project. Reading through hundreds of reviews across the highest-scoring companies on Chooz Painters, several names rise to the top.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Based in Massapequa Park and licensed under Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692, owner Charlie Cascio and his crew have been serving Long Island homeowners for more than 12 years in business, backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty. What stands out from reading through the reviews is the variety of work customers trust them with - from kitchen cabinet painting and mahogany door refinishing to full exterior repaints on stucco and vinyl siding. Several homeowners describe Charlie personally following up during projects to confirm the work is going to plan.

• Crew members Rene, Oscar, Victor, and Gavin get called out by name, often by customers who request them for return projects
• Multiple homeowners describe leaving the house during the job feeling completely comfortable with the team inside
• Commercial work - including full gym and salon renovations - appears alongside standard residential projects
• All workmanship is backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

"We had about a half dozen painters come by and they were all crazy expensive. We decided to go with Charlie from Teall Painting and couldn't have made a better choice - the inside and outside of our house looks beautiful." - Greg S., Google Review

If you're preparing a home for sale or managing a larger renovation alongside painting, Teall Painting is a good choice.

While Teall Painting handles the full range of residential and commercial work, Interior Finishing NYC has built a specialty practice around decorative finishes that most contractors simply won't attempt. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, and at the time of our analysis they had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and has been in business for over 22 years, with all work backed by a three-year workmanship warranty. A recurring pattern in the reviews: customers describe contacting Dorian after other contractors turned down their project - from matching faux finishes after water damage to gilded ceilings and grasscloth installation on non-square walls.

• Customers describe Dorian helping them choose between limewash, Roman clay, and Venetian plaster rather than just arriving to execute
• Commercial clients - retail spaces, corporate offices, and co-op common areas - use him on a recurring basis
• Team members Jose, Amir, and Marvin appear regularly across reviews from separate customers on unrelated projects
• Serves both Manhattan and Long Island, making specialty finishes accessible for Old Bethpage, NY homeowners

"Dorian took on decorative plaster touch-ups that other reputable contractors were not willing to handle. He did an amazing job and we will gladly use his services again." - Avni S., Google Review

If you're looking for a specialty decorative finish - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, or wallpaper on a challenging surface - Interior Finishing NYC is a good choice.

Rounding out the three highest Chooz Scores for contractors serving Old Bethpage, NY, Big Expert Painting LLC earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis Erazo holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification - a practical credential for the older housing stock across Nassau and Suffolk counties. Reading through the reviews, what distinguishes Denis is his breadth of service. One reviewer called him same-day after a TV installation left a hole in the wall; Denis came, patched the drywall, painted it, and mounted the TV. Another hired him for a pool interior repaint, noting his specific knowledge of the specialty paint required.

• Multiple reviewers describe booking Denis again before the current job is even finished
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification makes them a well-suited choice for pre-1978 Long Island homes
• Services extend to marble flooring, gym flooring, crown molding, cabinet resurfacing, and bathroom renovation
• Reviews come from across Long Island, from Amityville and Copiague to Lynbrook and Huntington Station

"Big Expert Painting exceeded all my expectations! They were incredibly punctual every day, and the team worked with precision and professionalism throughout. My home looks absolutely stunning." - Melva M., Google Review

If you want an owner-operated crew that handles both the painting and surrounding prep and repair work, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good choice.

Also serving the Old Bethpage, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a structured approach with dedicated project managers who oversee everything from estimates through final walkthroughs. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and 100% recommended on Facebook, they hold an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-73176 through January 2028 and have over 18 years in business. Project managers David Maloney, Jason Eng, and Brendan each lead dedicated field crews, and office manager Trish Gates is specifically mentioned in reviews for keeping customers informed between visits.

• Painters Carlos, Amilcar, Fernando, and Hernando each appear across multiple reviews from entirely separate customers
• Jobs range from single-room refreshes to six-day whole-home projects with skim coating, floor refinishing, and staining
• One reviewer coordinated a full interior paint project from out of state without any issues
• Over 16 new reviews in the past three months confirm they are actively taking on projects right now

"I gave them a house key, that's how much I trusted them. These guys were way above my expectations - there every day for full days on my 2,300 square foot home." - Jeffrey N., Google Review

If you prefer the consistency of a structured crew with dedicated project management, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a good choice.

With a growing roster of repeat clients and referral-based work, JRT Pro Painters LLC earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 65 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. They hold an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-66725 and have spent 4 years building their following across Long Island. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas is personally mentioned across the majority of reviews, and what stands out is his involvement in helping customers make decisions - offering color advice, recommending specific products, and walking through the full scope before any work begins. One homeowner whose longtime painter retired found Brayan through Instagram and notes he accommodated a medical delay in the schedule without any issue.

• Crew members Milton, Antonio, and Alex appear across reviews from multiple different customers on separate projects
• Brayan's crew regularly goes beyond the original scope - spotting nail pops left by prior contractors and removing all debris from the site
• Jobs include interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, door and moulding replacement, deck staining, and ceiling repair
• Reviews span Syosset, Huntington, and communities across Nassau and Suffolk counties

"Brayan and his partner repaired my ceiling damage from a roof leak - replaced sheetrock and insulation, spackled, and painted the entire ceiling to perfection. You honestly can't tell at all where the damage was." - Louise T., Google Review

If you're dealing with a project that combines drywall repair with painting, or want an owner who actively advises throughout the process, JRT Pro Painters LLC is a good choice.

For projects where speed of completion matters as much as quality, Long Island Painting and Restoration has built a reputation for fast turnarounds that still hold up to close inspection. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews - every single review a five-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego and his crew have grown the business over more than 6 years almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. Andres gets mentioned in nearly every review, usually in the context of a thorough initial walkthrough where he goes room to room, answers questions, and offers color and finish recommendations at no extra charge. Crew sizes scale up for larger jobs: a six-person crew finished a full exterior paint job in a single day, and a 4-bedroom interior was completed in under 48 hours.

• Several customers come back for their second home after using Long Island Painting and Restoration for their first
• Projects include whole-home exterior repaints, cabinet painting, picture molding, staining, and restoration of century-old homes
• Crew members Nelson and Delmer receive specific call-outs alongside Andres on major projects
• Commercial buildings and apartments appear in the review record alongside residential work

"When his crew of six arrived, they took care of everything from setup to painting to cleanup. I am amazed they were able to finish such a big job in just one day!" - Keri S., Google Review

If you're on a tight timeline - moving into a new home, turning over a property, or finishing a renovation - Long Island Painting and Restoration is a good choice.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of workmanship is the most consistently praised theme across reviews of painting contractors in the Old Bethpage, NY area. Customers regularly describe finished walls that look seamless, painted cabinets that rival brand-new cabinetry, and exterior coatings applied over thorough prep work. Teall Painting, with a Chooz Score of 87.6%, draws consistent praise for precision on specialty surfaces - mahogany door refinishing, stucco exteriors, and cabinet painting jobs each appear alongside standard work, with multiple reviewers noting that the crew identified and addressed surface issues before a single coat of paint went on. Interior Finishing NYC, with a Chooz Score of 87.3%, handles technically demanding decorative work: limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, gilded ceilings, and wallpaper installation on challenging surfaces, each handled with a level of execution that brings reviewers back for additional rooms.

The same attention to craft runs through the other top-rated options. Big Expert Painting LLC, with a Chooz Score of 87.0%, has customers describing painted kitchen cabinets that look like they came directly from the showroom, and drywall repairs after water damage where the patched area is impossible to distinguish from the surrounding surface. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, with a Chooz Score of 81.5%, earns specific praise for challenging prep work - vaulted ceilings, built-in bookcases, and rooms with significant drywall nail pops that the crew addressed before any painting began. Across all these companies, multiple reviewers describe watching crews sand, prime, and fix imperfections before opening a can of paint.

• "Rene and Oscar were great - experienced, very professional, and the quality of work was exactly what we needed. I would highly recommend Teall Painting." - Michael P., Google Review
• "Dorian took his time to make sure every piece of the wallpaper was perfect. It came out way better than we ever dreamed." - William C., Google Review
• "They painted my kitchen cabinets and made them look like they came direct from the showroom. The entire job was done amazingly professionally and with great attention to detail." - Ronnie M., Google Review
• "Manny and his team have done an excellent job at my home. The dark blue den finish came out flawless, and the drywall prep work on the bedroom was done beautifully." - Joy L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Communication stands out as a key differentiator across reviews of painting contractors serving Old Bethpage, NY. Customers consistently describe owners and project managers who respond quickly, are clear about scope and timeline before work begins, and remain accessible throughout the job. Teall Painting, with a Chooz Score of 87.6%, draws repeated praise for owner Charlie Cascio's communication habits - multiple reviewers describe receiving updates on what the crew completed each day, having the scope reconfirmed before starting, and getting timely answers to questions mid-project. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, with a Chooz Score of 84.8%, brings a more structured communication model: project managers David Maloney, Jason Eng, and Brendan each handle customer contact throughout their jobs, and office manager Trish Gates is specifically mentioned in reviews for keeping customers updated between crew visits.

The owner-operated companies in the group tend to lead on direct accessibility. JRT Pro Painters LLC, with a Chooz Score of 84.3%, has owner Brayan Rivas Ticas described as genuinely helpful with color decisions before and during jobs - not just arriving to execute what's asked. Long Island Painting and Restoration, with a Chooz Score of 84.2%, earns consistent praise for Andres Gallego's estimate process, where he spends significant time walking through the scope, answering questions, and offering recommendations before committing to a price.

• "From day one we were in constant communication with Charlie about what was being worked on and what to expect that day. We are beyond thrilled with the finished result." - John C., Google Review
• "Bryan is great in helping you make the right decision on colors. He is very honest, reliable and dependable." - Khalida S., Google Review
• "David M explained the painting process and next steps perfectly on day one and suggested a nice color. The overall service from his crew was outstanding." - Solange V., Google Review
• "Andres was very responsive and quick. He was able to break everything down about the cost of the project, which I really appreciated." - Marielle A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness is one of the most mentioned themes in reviews of painting contractors serving Old Bethpage, NY, and the top-rated companies earn consistent praise for it. Teall Painting, with a Chooz Score of 87.6%, draws repeated remarks about crews arriving as committed and finishing within the estimated window - several reviewers describe their job wrapping up faster than quoted without any shortcuts in the finish. Long Island Painting and Restoration, with a Chooz Score of 84.2%, is particularly well-reviewed for fast turnarounds: a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home was completed in under 48 hours, a large apartment was finished in just a few hours, and exterior projects consistently finish ahead of schedule. Owner Andres Gallego scales crew sizes to match the timeline, which shows up repeatedly in the reviews as a differentiator.

Big Expert Painting LLC, with a Chooz Score of 87.0%, earns similar remarks: one reviewer was given a three-day estimate and the crew finished in two. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, with a Chooz Score of 84.8%, gets consistent praise from project managers who set clear timelines upfront, then deliver on them - customers describe arriving home each evening to crews who left the house clean and in useable condition even on multi-day projects. JRT Pro Painters LLC, with a Chooz Score of 84.3%, draws reviews describing full eight-to-nine-hour workdays from crews who arrive as scheduled and don't leave early.

• "Jose and his team arrived on time both days and left our home spotless. We are so happy with the finished product." - Michelle S., Google Review
• "They gave me an estimate of three days to complete and they finished in two. Moved fast and did a great job." - Chantel B., Google Review
• "The work was completed earlier than expected and came out better than we could have imagined, all for a reasonable price." - Taylor Y., Google Review
• "Andres and his painters finished my entire home ahead of schedule, were prompt every morning, and even worked late to assist. Highly recommend!" - Kiran K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Prep work and cleanup are recurring themes in the reviews of painting contractors in the Old Bethpage, NY area. The top-rated companies share a consistent approach: thorough surface preparation before any paint goes on, and a clean jobsite at the end of each day. Teall Painting, with a Chooz Score of 87.6%, draws repeated mentions of crews covering floors with plastic sheeting, builder's paper, and drop cloths before work begins. Multiple reviewers describe the crew leaving their homes spotless despite projects involving significant repair and prep on difficult surfaces. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, with a Chooz Score of 81.5%, has customers specifically describing crews who vacuum the room before painting, lay paper on all floors, move and cover furniture, and return everything to its original position once the job is done.

The same care appears at the other top-rated contractors. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, with a Chooz Score of 84.8%, earns consistent praise for leaving homes in useable condition at the end of each workday on multi-day projects - furniture moved, covered, and returned to its exact original spot. JRT Pro Painters LLC, with a Chooz Score of 84.3%, has multiple reviewers noting that crews removed all trash and debris from the site when they left, saving homeowners the cleanup work themselves.

• "They protected everything from paint spills and left the room completely spotless. They were on time each day and patient with our decisions. I cannot sing their praises enough." - Cindy R., Google Review
• "Manny and his crew vacuum beforehand, lay paper on floors, move furniture and cover everything with plastic before a single brush stroke. The finished result was flawless." - Sharon D., Google Review
• "Brayan and his crew thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up completely when finished. Their work was excellent." - Janette P., Google Review
• "They handled everything with care and went above and beyond to fix imperfections in my walls. All furniture was moved, covered, and moved back to its original spot when the job was done." - Brandi B., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value for money comes up frequently in reviews of painting contractors serving Old Bethpage, NY, often from customers who gathered four to six estimates before choosing. Teall Painting, with a Chooz Score of 87.6%, earns specific praise for itemized, no-surprise estimates - several reviewers describe the final bill matching the quote exactly, and one homeowner who had received multiple bids from other contractors specifically chose Teall after finding the combination of price and professionalism to be the clear standout. Big Expert Painting LLC, with a Chooz Score of 87.0%, gets regular remarks about Denis's willingness to work within a homeowner's budget, with repeat customers noting the same quality on projects of very different sizes - from a single porch column to a full whole-home interior.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, with a Chooz Score of 84.8%, comes up repeatedly from homeowners who got multiple estimates and describe Precision as the most competitively priced for the quality delivered. Long Island Painting and Restoration, with a Chooz Score of 84.2%, earns similar remarks - several customers note Andres's quote was the best they received when comparing multiple contractors, while still delivering a five-star result. At JRT Pro Painters LLC, with a Chooz Score of 84.3%, one reviewer noted the pricing wasn't the absolute lowest, but the combination of reliability, quality, and owner involvement made the decision straightforward.

• "Pricing was very reasonable and Charlie was thorough in reconfirming the scope before starting. Thank you, Teall Painting!" - Amy B., Google Review
• "After getting three estimates, Precision Painting was by far the most reasonably priced. The work was impeccable." - Helen G., Google Review
• "Brayan is very responsive and prices are incredibly fair. The painters were knowledgeable and did a wonderful job." - Sita P., Google Review
• "Price was the best compared to other companies I was quoted from. Very happy with the final results and would recommend." - N.G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Repeat business and referrals are among the strongest signals of a contractor's consistency, and they appear prominently across reviews of painting contractors serving Old Bethpage, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, with a Chooz Score of 81.5% and over 28 years in business, has built one of the deepest repeat customer bases in the region - reviewers describe relationships spanning 10, 15, and over 20 years, with multiple family members becoming customers on the recommendation of a relative. Big Expert Painting LLC, with a Chooz Score of 87.0%, has customers who have relied on owner Denis for over 7 years across projects of very different sizes, from small exterior repairs to full home interiors.

Teall Painting, with a Chooz Score of 87.6%, has multiple reviewers explicitly stating they are on their second, third, or already-scheduled next project with the company. JRT Pro Painters LLC, with a Chooz Score of 84.3%, draws similar remarks - one reviewer first hired Brayan in 2021 for an urgent pre-holiday project and has since returned for four more rooms plus drywall work. Long Island Painting and Restoration, with a Chooz Score of 84.2%, has customers who called Andres back specifically when they bought a second home. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, with a Chooz Score of 84.8%, draws the same pattern - one reviewer describes returning for a third project and noting that the crew brings ideas each time that push the results beyond what they expected.

• "This is my second time using Teall and I am very, very happy. They are very clean and very helpful. I would recommend them to anyone." - Patricia P., Google Review
• "Manny is a pleasure to work with. We have used him on a number of projects and him and his team do great work at an extremely fair price. We have recommended him to family and all have been very happy." - Tim C., Google Review
• "Dave and his painting crew are excellent. This is the third time we've used Precision Painting in our home. They share beneficial ideas so the results are far above what I expected." - R.S., Google Review
• "He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second home, he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys." - Christine L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook