Homeowners in Bethpage, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors serving Nassau and Suffolk counties. Across hundreds of reviews, customers consistently highlight reliable scheduling, crews that protect furniture and flooring, and painters who take the time to address every concern before leaving the job site.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 89.0%. Reviews also span platforms including 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. With over 10 years in business on Long Island, owner Todd Rumfola runs a company where customers frequently describe calling back year after year for both painting and power washing projects. Several reviewers mention receiving a quote within hours of their first call, with Todd often arriving the next day to walk the property. If you need a responsive contractor who handles both painting and power washing under one roof, South Bay is a strong option.
What stands out in reviews is how many customers describe Todd as someone who personally follows up after the work is done to make sure everything looks right. Multiple reviewers also note that the pricing is straightforward with no surprises at the end.
- Crew members Rich, Jerry, and Alex are mentioned by name across many reviews, suggesting a stable in-house team rather than rotating subcontractors
- Several customers describe hiring South Bay for annual power washing maintenance, returning each spring or summer
- Reviewers frequently praise the communication speed, with same-day text and email responses a common theme
"We had our house power washed by South Bay. They did a fantastic job. They explained everything that had to be done and were careful not to harm the flowers and shrubs along side my house. Polite and efficient. Great price as well." - Joan Kyriacou, Google Review
When it comes to specialty finishes and decorative techniques, Interior Finishing NYC stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi studied fine arts in Tirana, Albania, and brings over 22 years in business to projects that include limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper installation. If you have a project that other contractors have turned down, Interior Finishing NYC is a good fit.
Reviewers consistently describe Dorian as personally present on the job site, working alongside his team rather than managing from a distance. Customers with complex projects, from pre-war apartment restorations to ceiling gilding, report that Dorian takes the time to explain his process and offers solutions for unexpected issues like hidden leaks or uneven surfaces.
- Multiple Manhattan and Long Island customers mention that Dorian provided quotes over phone or video call to save time before scheduling the project
- Wallpaper installation is a recurring specialty, with reviewers praising work on grasscloth, vinyl, cork, and large-scale murals
- The company offers a three-year workmanship warranty on all projects
"Dorian and his team did an incredible job on our wallpaper, he is an artist! It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around. He took his time to make sure every piece was perfect." - William Curtis, Google Review
For homeowners seeking a Long Island-based contractor with deep community ties, Teall Painting has earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and have been in business for over 12 years from their Massapequa Park base. Owner Charlie Teall personally handles every estimate, and reviewers note how detailed his written proposals are before any work begins. If you value a thorough estimate process and consistent crew quality, Teall Painting is worth a call.
A number of customers describe projects that go beyond standard interior and exterior painting. Reviews mention deck staining, western red cedar restoration, mahogany door refinishing, and stucco work. One homeowner who struggled to find a contractor willing to refinish a sun-damaged mahogany front door reported that Teall handled it in a single day with results that looked brand new.
- All painters reportedly have over 5 years of professional experience and go through background checks before joining the team
- Teall Painting backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
- Reviewers frequently praise the prep work, including plastic sheathing, drop cloths, and surface protection before any painting begins
"I was lucky to find Teall Painting during a Google search. Charlie's response time to my initial inquiry was quite impressive. More impressive was the professionalism of the work. The finished job made my apartment look amazing." - Audrey Bolger, Google Review
Repeat customers and long-term relationships define CRD Painting Inc. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% backed by over 90 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo has built relationships with customers spanning 10 to 15 years, with many reviewers describing him as someone they would never consider replacing. With over 8 years in business, CRD Painting is a solid choice if you want a contractor who treats every job like a relationship, not a transaction.
What comes through in the reviews is how quickly Camilo responds when something needs adjusting. One customer who changed her mind about a paint color after the job was finished called Camilo, and he returned the next day to repaint at no issue. That kind of flexibility and willingness to make things right is a pattern across the feedback.
- Several reviewers mention using CRD Painting across multiple homes, including vacation properties in Quogue and Sag Harbor
- A local drywall business with 60 years of experience recommends CRD Painting to their own builders and customers
- Reviewers consistently describe the crew as neat, covering flooring and furniture carefully and cleaning up as if they were never there
"I wasn't happy with the color I chose. I called Camilo and he came the next day and repainted the walls! I was ecstatic to say the least." - Karen Rauseo, Google Review
Also serving the Bethpage, NY area, Big Expert Painting LLC brings a hands-on approach led by owner Denis. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Denis is known for answering calls directly and providing same-day estimates, including on weekends. If you want an owner-operated company where the person who gives you the quote is the same person overseeing the work, Big Expert is a good match.
Customers describe a pattern of hiring Big Expert for one small project and then calling back for larger jobs once they see the quality. Several reviewers mention starting with a single room or ceiling repair and eventually having their entire home painted over multiple visits.
- One customer has relied on Denis for over 7 years across projects ranging from porch columns to full interior repaints
- Power washing services are frequently bundled with painting projects, giving homeowners a one-stop solution
- Reviewers describe competitive pricing as a consistent strength, with several noting they compared multiple bids before choosing Big Expert
"We've used Big Expert Painting twice. Once to do drywall work in our kitchen and more recently, to repair and paint ceiling and walls. They also painted the doors and handrails. The guys are very professional." - Allie Scalza, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Bethpage, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge handles everything from single-room refreshes to whole-home renovations. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2015. With over 18 years in business, they bring a structured approach with dedicated project managers like David Maloney and Brendan who oversee each job from start to finish. If you have a large or complicated project that needs strong project management, Precision Painting Plus is a reliable choice.
Several reviewers describe trusting the crew with house keys for multi-day projects, comfortable leaving the painters unsupervised while they went to work. Customers also highlight that the crew left the home in usable condition at the end of each day, even during week-long renovations.
- Crew members Carlos, Jose, and Amilcar appear across dozens of reviews from different customers, indicating a consistent in-house team
- One customer described having their entire 2,300-square-foot home repainted, including skim coating, with results that exceeded expectations
- Floor refinishing and staining services are also available alongside painting, reducing the need for multiple contractors
"The skillful crew just completed painting my entire home, and they were amazing! The crew arrived every day on time and were always very professional and patient. Their work was always done with much care." - Doreen Conte, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
