7 Best Painters Near Wantagh, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Wantagh, NY homeowners searching for painting contractors have several strong options serving the area. Across the review platforms tracked by Chooz Painters, the companies featured below share a consistent pattern: owner involvement from the first estimate, crews that stay until the job is right, and track records built over years of work on Long Island. Whether you need interior rooms, an exterior refresh, power washing, or a specialty decorative finish, these contractors cover a wide range of needs.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, one of the highest review volumes in the area. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, and their cross-platform presence is equally strong, with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Based in East Islip with over 10 years in business, South Bay holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and is lead-safe certified for work on older homes. Power washing makes up a significant portion of their business - reviews covering pavers, driveways, siding, fences, and decks appear throughout their feedback alongside interior and exterior painting. Owner Todd Rumfola personally handles estimates and typically responds within hours, with several reviewers describing arrival within a day or two of their first contact.

What stands out when reading through the reviews is how many customers have become long-term regulars. Crew members Jerry and Rich are called out by name in multiple unrelated reviews, and several customers describe loyalty going back three or more years. Todd is consistently described as easy to reach, responsive to texts and calls, and thorough in walking through the planned scope before work begins. If you're looking for a contractor who handles both painting and power washing and builds the kind of relationship where you call the same crew year after year, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC is a good choice.

• Owner Todd responds to quote requests within hours and typically sets up estimates within a day or two of first contact.
• Jerry and Rich are cited by name in dozens of unrelated reviews, a sign of a consistent, non-rotating crew.
• Power washing covers driveways, pavers, decks, siding, and fencing - not just painting.
• Multiple customers describe using South Bay for three or more consecutive years across different project types.

"Without hesitation we would highly recommend Todd and his company! Todd is a true professional who aims to please! He is dependable, easy to communicate with, great customer service, and does an A1 job! We have used Todd the past three years and consider him a friend!" - Barbara C., Google Review

For homeowners dealing with specialty surfaces or tricky project challenges, Teall Painting has carved out a reputation on Long Island for handling work that other contractors often pass on. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Based in Massapequa Park with over 12 years in business, Teall holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692 and backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Owner Charlie Teall handles estimates personally and provides detailed, itemized quotes that customers consistently describe as having no billing surprises at the end.

The crew has tackled mahogany door refinishing that prior contractors couldn't get right, western red cedar home restoration, stucco exterior repainting, wainscoting installation, and cabinet refinishing - alongside standard interior and exterior work. Referrals from general contractors appear in the reviews, pointing to a level of professional credibility that goes beyond homeowner feedback alone. If you have a specialty project or an unusual surface that's already been turned down elsewhere, Teall Painting is a good choice.

• Itemized, detailed estimates leave customers with no billing surprises when the job wraps up.
• General contractors refer clients to Teall - a sign of professional standing beyond typical homeowner reviews.
• The crew takes on specialty surfaces other contractors avoid: mahogany doors, cedar, stucco, wainscoting, and cabinets.

"I have a mahogany front door that faces south and gets abused by the sunlight. I have tried to have it refinished in the past and it did not come out good. The guys at Teall got the door sanded and refinished in a day and it looks like it is brand new." - Steve M., Google Review

When it comes to decorative and specialty finishes, Interior Finishing NYC stands in a different category from a typical painting contractor. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in techniques like limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and metallic applications - finishes that require an artistic background, not just painting experience. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Based in New Rochelle and in business for over 22 years, Interior Finishing NYC backs all work with a 3-year workmanship warranty.

Reviews describe projects that other contractors declined before Dorian accepted and delivered: faux finish matching on water-damaged walls, multi-wall mural wallpaper installations around challenging architectural features, ceiling gilding in commercial spaces, and grasscloth and cork wallpaper on irregular surfaces. Dorian also coordinates remote projects with clients who are out of town, working directly with building management during the job. If you're looking for decorative finishes, specialty plaster work, or complex wallpaper installation, Interior Finishing NYC is a good choice.

• Dorian accepts projects other contractors decline: faux finish matching, cork wallpaper on irregular surfaces, and ceiling gilding in commercial spaces.
• Remote project coordination is available for out-of-town homeowners and commercial property managers.
• Services extend beyond painting to drywall repair, skim coating, wallpaper hanging, plaster work, and framing.

"Dorian and his team did an incredible job on our wallpaper, he is an artist! It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around. He took his time to make sure every piece was perfect, it has come out way better than we ever dreamed." - William C., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Big Expert Painting LLC. Based in Amityville, they earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across every single review. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp, carry a Suffolk County Home Improvement License, and are EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified for work on pre-1978 homes. Owner Denis personally handles estimates, is available on weekends, and is mentioned by name across the vast majority of reviews.

A recurring pattern in the reviews: customers hire Denis for a few rooms, are impressed enough to immediately book additional work, and then plan future projects before the crew even leaves. Denis also follows up after jobs to confirm satisfaction - a detail that comes up in multiple unrelated reviews. Crew members cover furniture and personal items before starting and clean up completely when finished. If you're looking for a reliable all-around painting crew with a track record of turning first-time clients into long-term regulars, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good choice.

• Denis answers calls and texts on weekends and provides same-day or next-day estimates.
• Multiple customers describe adding jobs mid-project because they were so impressed with the initial work.
• Handles drywall and sheetrock repair alongside painting - useful for water damage and ceiling issues.
• Some client relationships span over 7 years across multiple projects and property types.

"Denis and his team did an amazing job in my home. Originally I hired him for a few rooms and I was so pleased I asked him to return to do other jobs. His team was professional, clean, timely, and excellent quality. Also his prices were competitive." - Jackie H., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Wantagh, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings the structure of a larger operation with hands-on project management built into every job. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015), and are 100% recommended on Facebook. With over 18 years in business and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License valid through January 2028, they've built deep roots on Long Island.

Project managers David Maloney, Jason Eng, Brendan, TJ, and Matt Zicherman appear across reviews as dedicated points of contact for each job. David is mentioned more than any other team member, with customers describing him as present on-site each day and conducting final walkthroughs before considering work complete. The company also handles remote projects: one reviewer coordinated an entire repaint from out of state, and another trusted the crew with a house key throughout a multi-day, full-home renovation. If you're looking for a contractor with professional project management built into the process, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a good choice.

• Dedicated project managers - David Maloney being the most frequently mentioned - serve as consistent points of contact throughout each job.
• Out-of-state homeowners have coordinated entire paint projects remotely through the company's office.
• Crews clean up at the end of each workday, leaving homes fully usable throughout multi-day projects.

"Amazing coordination and communication with this team of professionals. I live out of state and working with PPP was simple. They did a fantastic job and I highly recommend their services." - Jim P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of workmanship is the most frequently mentioned theme across reviews for painting contractors serving Wantagh, NY. Customers consistently describe careful prep work, attention to edges and surfaces, and finished results that exceed what they expected going in. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC receives specific praise for the precision of their crew - reviewers describe Rich and Jerry taking care with surfaces and covering everything properly before starting, with Todd reviewing details before and after the job to confirm the customer's standard has been met. Teall Painting is similarly recognized for thorough prep, with customers noting that specialty surfaces like cathedral ceiling cracks, stucco exteriors, and mahogany woodwork get the same level of care as straightforward interior rooms.

Interior Finishing NYC attracts customers specifically for work that requires an artistic level of precision - matching faux finishes on water-damaged walls, aligning wallpaper across irregular surfaces, and applying plaster finishes indistinguishable from the surrounding material. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe Denis's crew as thorough on prep and cleanup, with one reviewer noting that the team swept up leaves they had tracked in - a small detail that stood out as going above what was expected. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, customers describe crews who stayed until every room was inspected and signed off, with project managers conducting their own final walkthroughs before considering work complete.

"Rich and Jerry did incredible! They turned our house into a beautiful home. The attention to detail, trust, professionalism was something you can't find these days." - John P., Google Review"Charlie and his team were professional from start to finish. From the thorough inspection/estimate to the finished product, the entire process was seamless. Jose and his team arrived on time both days and left our home spotless." - Michelle S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication quality is a major theme in reviews for painting contractors serving Wantagh, NY. The companies featured on Chooz Painters consistently receive praise not just for the finished work, but for how straightforward the entire experience is from the first call through the final walkthrough. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC's owner Todd is repeatedly described as responding to texts and calls within hours, sending estimates the same day as the site visit, and texting clients the night before and morning of each job day. Reviewers at Teall Painting highlight the daily updates from owner Charlie - including what was completed that day and what to expect next - a level of transparency that customers describe as rare among contractors.

For Big Expert Painting LLC, Denis's weekend availability is noted across multiple reviews, with customers describing quote responses on Sunday afternoons and follow-up calls weeks after the job was done. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge has a full office communication system in place - reviewer Trish is mentioned by name as an exemplary front-office contact who kept clients updated throughout the project. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian responds to virtually every Google review with personalized notes and coordinates with building management and out-of-town clients directly, handling logistics so the homeowner doesn't have to manage the project remotely.

"Charlie and his team were great to work with. From day 1 we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on/completed and what to expect that day. We are beyond thrilled with the finished result!!" - John C., Google Review"Brendan and his team were professional and friendly. They worked around our schedule and our needs given that we both work from home and have a dog that needs to be let out every so often." - Taylor Y., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Fair pricing is a recurring theme in reviews for painting contractors near Wantagh, NY, and several companies stand out for delivering competitive estimates without cutting corners on quality. Big Expert Painting LLC is one of the most frequently cited for value - multiple reviewers describe Denis's prices as lower than every other estimate they received, and customers consistently note that the finished work was worth more than they paid. Teall Painting provides detailed, itemized estimates that remove surprises from the billing process - customers say they knew exactly what they were paying for and were not asked for unexpected additions mid-project.

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, reviewers who had gathered multiple competing estimates describe Precision as extremely competitive - in some cases the most reasonably priced despite the scope of work involved. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC receives repeated mentions of reasonable pricing for both painting and power washing, with several customers noting they were surprised by how fair the estimate was before seeing the finished results. Interior Finishing NYC is noted for fair pricing given the specialty nature of the work, with reviewers who had received higher quotes from competitors describing Dorian's rates as comparable despite his additional fine arts training and specialized techniques.

"We agreed on the price, which I thought was reasonable for the amount of work that needed to be done." - Angelina H., Google Review"After receiving multiple estimates his price was extremely competitive and the decision was easy." - Joe C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Timeliness and scheduling reliability are well-documented across reviews for painting contractors serving Wantagh, NY. Several companies consistently finish ahead of schedule or within the original estimate, and on-time arrival is a recurring theme across multiple businesses. Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out for speed on larger jobs: crews scale up in size to keep timelines short, with reviewers describing entire apartments completed in hours and whole-home projects wrapped up in a single day. Teall Painting customers note that crews arrived on time both days of their project and stayed late when needed, with several homeowners describing jobs finishing faster than the original estimate suggested.

At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Todd regularly provides same-day or next-day estimates and sets specific arrival windows he consistently meets, with multiple reviewers mentioning a text the night before to confirm timing. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge crews are consistently described as finishing within the projected window, with project managers providing daily progress updates so homeowners are never left wondering where things stand. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis provides estimated completion times upfront - one reviewer received a 3-day estimate and the crew finished in 2 days.

"Andres was easy to work with. When his crew came, there were six of them. They took care of everything from the set up to the painting to the cleanup. I am amazed that they were able to finish such a big job in just one day!" - Keri S., Google Review"I was in a jam and needed my apartment repainted quickly. Charlie and his team were super responsive, handled all communication easily and in a timely manner, and made the process a breeze!" - Kate H., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and preparation are consistently praised across reviews for painting contractors near Wantagh, NY. The companies that serve the area take post-job and daily cleanup seriously. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers specifically describe being able to use their home normally at the end of each workday throughout a multi-day project, with furniture moved back into place and floors clear before the crew leaves each evening. Big Expert Painting LLC's crew carefully covers personal items and furniture before starting, and multiple reviewers describe the post-job cleanup as thorough - one customer noted that Denis's crew swept up leaves they had tracked in, an unsolicited step that left a strong impression.

At Teall Painting, prep work is a recurring theme: customers describe floors and surfaces covered with plastic sheeting, builder's paper, and drop cloths before any painting begins, with the crew cleaning up at the end of each day throughout the project. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC receives similar praise, with reviewers specifically noting that the crew protects flowers and shrubs along the foundation during power washing before working nearby. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers consistently describe the crew handling all setup and breakdown, so the homeowner has nothing left to deal with after the team leaves.

"They made sure they covered my personal items before starting and moved fast! Gave me a estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B., Google Review"They are all very skilled in what they do and very clean with no mess ever left behind." - Mike S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Several painting contractors serving Wantagh, NY offer specialty services that go well beyond standard interior and exterior painting. Interior Finishing NYC is the standout in this category - owner Dorian Golemi, a fine arts graduate, specializes in decorative finishes including Roman clay, Venetian plaster, limewash, marmorino, and metallic applications. Reviewers describe completed faux accent walls that matched inspiration photos exactly, ceiling gilding in commercial spaces, and wallpaper installations across challenging surfaces including grasscloth, cork, and multi-wall vinyl murals with complex architectural features. Dorian is also one of the few contractors reviewers specifically mention accepting projects that two or three previous contractors had already turned down.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC offers full power washing services alongside painting - driveways, pavers, decks, fencing, and siding - making them a dual-service option for homeowners who want both done by the same crew. Teall Painting handles a range of specialty projects including mahogany door refinishing, western red cedar home restoration, stucco exterior repainting, wainscoting installation, and cabinet refinishing. Big Expert Painting LLC handles sheetrock and drywall repair alongside painting, including ceiling repairs from water damage and skylight removal, so homeowners with structural issues don't need to bring in a separate contractor first. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge also handles deck staining, floor coatings, and detailed crown molding work alongside standard painting projects.

"I needed someone to do wallpaper hanging, some drywall repair and gilding in my home. It was hard to find a contractor that does all of the services we needed, especially gilding contractor in NYC. Luckily we found Dorian. The work was handled professionally." - Kha A., Google Review"Teal Painting did an excellent job painting all my shutters and doors! They came when they said they were coming and completed the job when they said they would." - Eileen L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook