South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC
About South Bay Painting and Power Washing
Todd Rumfola has built a business with over 150 five-star Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating through consistent practices and military-grade discipline. Todd texting customers the night before and morning of each job, master painter Jerry delivering flawless trim work that customers describe as art, crew member Rich arriving at 8am sharp every single day for week-long projects. Reviews mention painters covering every surface with drop cloths and plastic, detailed walkthroughs before starting work, and properties left "cleaner than when they started."
When Linda needed her home rescued after a previous contractor left the job half-finished with paint splatters everywhere, South Bay Painting didn't just complete the work. Todd personally assessed the damage, provided a fair quote despite the extra prep required, and Rich spent five consecutive days correcting every flaw while treating the home with respect. Two years later, when Linda's deck needed refinishing, she called Todd without hesitation, knowing the same reliability awaited.
Projects range from single-room refreshes to complete whole-house interior and exterior transformations completed in under a week. Customers mention Todd's honest assessments (telling Jacquie her house "didn't warrant a power washing yet" and to wait a year), Jerry's precision on Victorian trim work, and the team's habit of communicating every step. The fully licensed and insured veteran-owned company holds Suffolk County License #HI-61927, is lead-safe certified, and serves Nassau and Suffolk Counties from their East Islip base.
Updated: 12-10-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About South Bay Painting and Power Washing
Q: Why do so many reviews mention South Bay Painting and Power Washing's communication style?
Todd has built his reputation on proactive communication that customers rarely experience with contractors. Multiple reviewers specifically mention receiving texts "the night before and morning of" each scheduled day. Michael Arens notes Todd "responded to all my questions promptly and kept in touch. I was never left wondering." This military-precision approach to customer contact eliminates the anxiety homeowners typically feel during projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does South Bay Painting and Power Washing actually show up on time every day?
Punctuality is perhaps the most consistent theme across reviews. Nancy Koch describes Rich arriving "at 8am every day" for a seven-day project. Victoria Volpe confirms the crew was "always on time" across multiple projects over several years. Barbara Meddis, a repeat customer, emphasizes Todd "never disappoints" in reliability. The pattern shows scheduled arrival times are treated as commitments, not estimates.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What makes Jerry from South Bay Painting and Power Washing stand out in customer reviews?
Jerry consistently earns specific praise as a master painter whose work quality exceeds expectations. Christina Margiotta describes Jerry's work as having "such attention to detail" that transformed her kitchen. Claire Noto calls Jerry "the consummate professional" and specifically requested him for subsequent projects. Multiple reviews note his expertise with detailed trim work, cabinet painting, and achieving flawless finishes on challenging surfaces.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does South Bay Painting and Power Washing handle situations where work isn't actually needed?
Todd demonstrates unusual honesty by turning away work when unnecessary. Jacquie A. recounts that Todd "told me to hold off a year or two as my house didn't warrant a power washing" during her initial estimate two years prior. She appreciated this integrity and hired him when the time came. This approach builds trust and reflects Todd's philosophy of treating customer homes like his own rather than maximizing sales.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does South Bay Painting and Power Washing clean up properly after jobs?
Cleanup receives consistent praise across reviews. Kelly O'Hagan notes the team left her home "cleaner than when they started." Chris Avella mentions "immaculate cleanup each and every day" during a whole-house project. Reviewers describe painters using extensive drop cloths, plastic sheeting, and taking care to protect furniture, floors, and landscaping throughout projects. The military background appears to influence this attention to order.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Can South Bay Painting and Power Washing rescue projects that other contractors damaged or abandoned?
Several reviews specifically mention Todd's team fixing problems created by other contractors. Joseph Frisina hired them after "terrible experience with another contractor" and found South Bay's work "outstanding." Linda Vetrano chose them because she needed someone who "wouldn't juggle multiple jobs" after a previous bad experience. The team's willingness to assess and correct others' mistakes has become a notable part of their reputation.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do customers actually hire South Bay Painting and Power Washing repeatedly over the years?
Customer retention is remarkably strong, with multiple reviewers documenting years-long relationships. Joanna Castagnaro states she has "been using him for several years now" and will "keep going back year after year." Barbara C. has left multiple reviews spanning different projects. Victoria Volpe mentions using them for "interior, exterior painting, and power washing" across multiple occasions. The repeat business pattern validates the quality claims.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Is South Bay Painting and Power Washing's pricing competitive for Long Island?
While not the cheapest option, reviews consistently describe pricing as fair for the quality delivered. Gabrielle N. on Angi notes her estimate was "a thousand dollars cheaper than others" and called it "such a reasonable price." Multiple reviewers mention receiving detailed written estimates with no surprise charges. Todd's transparent pricing and willingness to explain costs builds confidence even when not the lowest bidder.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Updated: 12-10-2025