12 Best Painters Near Bay Shore, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Bay Shore, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different strength to the table. Whether you need a full exterior repaint, decorative plaster finishes, or a quick interior refresh, the companies serving this part of Long Island consistently earn top marks for reliability, clean work, and honest pricing.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.6%. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and back all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty. What stands out in the reviews is how often customers mention owner Charlie by name, praising his responsiveness from the very first phone call through final walkthrough. Multiple homeowners describe receiving detailed estimates that addressed every concern before work began. If you have an older home with exterior paint issues or specialty surfaces like brick or stucco, Teall Painting is a strong fit.

• Several reviewers hired Teall after other contractors could not match existing finishes or handle unusual surfaces
• Customers frequently mention feeling comfortable leaving crews unsupervised in their homes
• Exterior projects, including chimney and shutter repaints, appear regularly alongside interior work

"I would highly recommend Teall Painting. They removed paint chipping and completely repainted the exterior front, chimney and shutters. The house looks brand new and I could not be happier." - Michael Paolucci, Google Review

For homeowners seeking specialty decorative finishes like limewash, Roman clay, or Venetian plaster, Interior Finishing NYC brings an artistic approach rarely found in typical painting contractors. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi trained at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and with over 22 years in business, he offers a 3-year workmanship warranty on all projects. If you want a finish that goes beyond standard flat or eggshell paint, this is the company to call.

• Multiple customers describe hiring Dorian after other contractors turned down their projects
• Reviews highlight wallpaper installation, grasscloth on difficult surfaces, and pre-war woodwork restoration
• Dorian personally works on site alongside his crew rather than managing remotely

"Dorian and his crew are masters of their craft. I hired them to plaster and skim coat all the walls and ceilings in my apartment and they did a fantastic job for a fair price. I just had them come back for more work." - Armen Stevens, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for C.R.D Painting Inc. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. With over 8 years in business, owner Camilo has built a following of customers who come back year after year. What reviewers mention most is how clean the crew leaves their homes after each workday, with floors and furniture carefully protected throughout. If you value a long-term relationship with a painter who treats every visit like their reputation is on the line, C.R.D is a solid choice.

• Several customers describe using C.R.D across multiple homes and referring friends and family
• Reviewers praise detailed work on moldings, wainscoting, and trim that other painters rush through

"Over the last 2 years, they've painted every room in our house. I can't say enough wonderful things about Camilo and his team. They do quality work, are very neat and clean, they show up on time and have fair prices." - Sarah Clark, Google Review

With a hands-on owner who answers calls directly and often responds to quote requests the same day, Big Expert Painting LLC has earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% backed by over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes. Customers describe a pattern of being so impressed with one project that they immediately book additional rooms. If you want a responsive, owner-operated crew for a straightforward interior or exterior repaint, Big Expert delivers.

• Reviewers consistently note that Denis follows up weeks after project completion to check satisfaction
• Several customers hired Big Expert for water damage repair and ceiling work alongside painting
• Spanish-speaking homeowners praise bilingual communication throughout their projects

"Originally I hired him for a few rooms and I was so pleased I asked him to return to do other jobs. His team was professional, clean, timely, and exceeded expectations." - Jackie Hernandez, Google Review

With over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% and is known for fast turnarounds without cutting corners. Customers describe getting estimates one day and having entire rooms finished the next. Todd handles everything from interior repaints and cabinet refinishing to power washing and deck staining. If you need a project completed on a tight timeline and want a painter who has been doing this long enough to get it right quickly, Todd is a reliable option.

• Cabinet painting is a standout specialty, with multiple customers praising kitchen cabinet results
• Power washing services are frequently bundled with exterior paint projects
• Customers describe Todd personally suggesting colors and finishes that elevated the final result

"My house came out great! They were responsive, punctual and pricing was fair! My 6yr old son said our house looks sooooo pretty and doesn't look like a haunted house anymore!" - Jacquelyn Riker, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Bay Shore, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings over 18 years in business and a Chooz Score of 84.8%. They hold over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook, and are accredited with the Better Business Bureau. Their team structure stands out, with dedicated project supervisors overseeing field crews on every job. If you have a larger whole-home project and want a company with established systems and accountability, Precision Painting Plus fits the bill.

• Customers describe crews arriving each morning, working efficiently, and leaving homes in usable condition every evening
• Territory manager David Maloney is praised repeatedly for clear communication and fair estimates

"I've owned a number of homes before. These guys were way above my expectations. I gave them a key because I was working, trusted them completely, and came home to a perfect job every single day." - Jeffrey Negrin, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Professionalism and communication are the most commonly praised traits among painting contractors serving Bay Shore, NY. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe painters who answer calls promptly, provide detailed estimates, and keep homeowners informed throughout every phase of the project. Owner-operated companies dominate the area, which means the person giving your quote is often the same person overseeing the work.

Teall Painting stands out for owner Charlie's hands-on communication style. Customers consistently describe receiving updates throughout multi-day projects, with one reviewer noting they were "in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and what to expect that day." - John Calvacca, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC takes a similar approach, with owner Dorian handling estimates remotely via phone or video to save customers time, then personally working alongside his crew on site. "Owner, Dorian, was tremendous to work with remotely for repainting corporate office. Communicative, effective and customer-service oriented." - K Fowler, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC earns praise for owner Denis answering calls directly, including on weekends, and C.R.D Painting Inc customers highlight how clearly Camilo communicates about scheduling and expectations before work begins. "The communication regarding quotes and scheduling was clear cut and very impressive." - Tom DiEmidio, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge uses a structured project management approach, with territory manager David Maloney coordinating between homeowners and field crews. "I spoke with 3 other companies in my attempt to pick the best for my project. Precision stood out above the rest." - Linda Simonson, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Quality of workmanship is a consistent theme across reviews for painting contractors serving Bay Shore, NY. Customers describe results that go beyond basic painting, with detailed prep work, careful color matching, and finishes that hold up over time. Several companies are praised for handling specialty projects that other contractors declined.

Interior Finishing NYC receives some of the most specific quality praise, with customers describing decorative plaster, limewash, and faux finish work that other painters simply do not offer. "Dorian and his team were incredibly helpful. The faux finishing accent wall came out as a work of art." - Prince Julien, Google Review. Teall Painting earns similar marks for exterior work, with reviewers describing brick repaints, cedar restoration, and shutter refinishing that gave older homes a completely refreshed appearance. "From the initial visit with Charlie to Victor coming to complete this job, everything ran very smoothly. The job turned out beautifully." - Barbara Rosen, Google Review. Todd's Painting has built a particular reputation for cabinet refinishing, with multiple customers calling it Todd's personal specialty. C.R.D Painting Inc customers highlight how the crew handles molding and trim work with precision, while JRT Pro Painters LLC reviewers praise drywall repairs and skim coating that make damaged surfaces look new. "Bryan and his team just finished painting our kitchen cabinets and I can't believe how good they look. Absolute kitchen makeover for so much less than replacing cabinets." - Michael S M, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Timeliness and efficiency are among the most frequently mentioned positives in reviews for painters serving Bay Shore, NY. Customers describe crews who arrive when expected, finish projects ahead of schedule, and manage multi-day jobs without dragging them out unnecessarily.

Todd's Painting is especially noted for fast turnarounds. Multiple reviewers describe receiving an estimate one day and having entire rooms completed the next. "Had multiple rooms that needed painting and was looking to get it done ASAP. Todd and his team more than delivered." - Jenna Fanelli, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe similar efficiency, with one reviewer noting a basement wall and ceiling damaged by water were repaired and painted in under two days. C.R.D Painting Inc crews are praised for completing large interior projects in just two days start to finish. "They came in and did an expert paint job through a large portion of our home in two days start to finish." - Sensei M., Yelp Review. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge handles longer, multi-day projects with a system that keeps homes livable throughout, with crews cleaning up each evening. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan earns praise for punctuality, with customers noting the crew arrives on time and stays focused throughout the day. "Brayan from JRT Pro Painters was fantastic. He was punctual, knowledgeable and super clean." - Monica Oliveira, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Cleanup and prep work are consistently highlighted in reviews for painting contractors serving Bay Shore, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe floors protected with drop cloths, furniture carefully moved and covered, and job sites left spotless at the end of each workday.

C.R.D Painting Inc receives some of the strongest cleanup praise, with customers describing homes that look untouched after full interior repaints. "Covered all my flooring and furniture and cleaned up after they left each day like they were never even there." - Anthony LoCurto, Google Review. Teall Painting crews are praised for protecting finished floors with plastic sheathing and builder's paper before any painting begins. Reviewer Priya Sridevi noted that Victor painted kitchen cabinets with careful attention to surrounding surfaces. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers describe multi-day renovations where crews left homes in usable condition every evening. "They were at my house for 6 days and they left each day with our house in a useable condition, cleaning up every day." - Frank R., Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC and JRT Pro Painters LLC both earn consistent marks for neat, organized work sites. Multiple reviewers across all companies note that they would not have known painters had been working if not for the fresh paint on the walls.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Fair pricing appears regularly in reviews for painting contractors serving Bay Shore, NY. While no company advertises as the cheapest option, customers across multiple contractors describe receiving competitive quotes that matched or beat other estimates, with the quality of work justifying every dollar spent.

Big Expert Painting LLC customers frequently mention reasonable pricing alongside strong results. "Very reasonably priced as well. I highly recommend." - Max Jacob, Google Review. Teall Painting reviewer Michael Paolucci specifically called out the pricing, noting the cost was "very attractive" for an extensive exterior brick repaint including chimney and shutters. C.R.D Painting Inc is described by multiple reviewers as offering fair prices without sacrificing quality. "The best painter on Long Island, bar none. Their prices are also fair and reasonable." - Edgardo Contreras, Google Review. Todd's Painting customers praise the value, with one reviewer noting Todd's prices are "awesome" for the level of craftsmanship delivered. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers describe receiving multiple estimates and finding Precision to be the most reasonably priced, with reviewer Helen Grygo noting she chose them after comparing three different companies. Interior Finishing NYC handles specialty decorative work at a price point customers describe as fair for the artistic skill involved.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Repeat business and customer loyalty are a defining pattern among painting contractors serving Bay Shore, NY. Across multiple companies, reviewers describe coming back for second, third, and even fourth projects, often bringing family and friends along as referrals.

C.R.D Painting Inc shows some of the strongest repeat customer patterns, with multiple reviewers documenting relationships spanning years. "This is my 3rd time using this crew and I don't want to use nobody else." - Israel G, Google Review. Todd's Painting has customers who have relied on Todd for decades, returning for projects across multiple properties. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe a similar pattern, with reviewer Joseph Meyer noting he has used the company for three separate projects and plans to keep calling. JRT Pro Painters LLC reviewers mention returning for second and third projects, with one customer describing having her entire house painted room by room over multiple visits. "I've hired them for several jobs. Very professional, on time, easy to deal with and straightforward about pricing." - Kristen D., Google Review. Teall Painting customers describe booking their next project before the current one is even finished, while Interior Finishing NYC benefits from customers who return specifically for Dorian's specialty finish work. "I have been working with Dorian and his team for over 10 years. By far the best painting contractor I have worked with." - Jose Maganaaa, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook