11 Best Painters Near Islip, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Islip, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing something different to the table. Whether you need a full interior repaint, specialty decorative finishes, or a quick exterior refresh, the companies serving the Islip area consistently earn praise for their reliability, fair pricing, and quality results.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Owner Charlie Cascio runs a family-oriented operation out of Massapequa Park with over 12 years in business, holding Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692 and a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty. Reviewers frequently describe Charlie personally checking in during projects and keeping communication open from estimate to final walkthrough. If you want a contractor who treats your home like his own, Teall Painting is a strong choice.

• Painters like Jose, Victor, and Anthony are mentioned by name across unrelated reviews, suggesting consistent in-house crews
• Exterior projects including stucco, siding, and front door refinishing appear regularly alongside interior work
• Several reviewers hired Teall for a second or third project after being impressed with the first

"I would highly recommend Teall painting. They completed exterior painting for my brick house. They removed paint chipping and completely repainted the exterior front, chimney and shutters. The house looks brand new." - Michael Paolucci, Google Review

For homeowners looking for specialty decorative finishes like limewash, Roman clay, or Venetian plaster, Interior Finishing NYC offers an artistic approach most contractors cannot match. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi has over 22 years in business and backs all projects with a three-year workmanship warranty. If you have a complex decorative project other contractors have turned down, Interior Finishing NYC is a good fit.

• Dorian is physically present on most jobs, working alongside his crew rather than managing from a distance
• Reviewers in Manhattan co-ops praise how the team handles unexpected issues like hidden water damage

"Dorian and his team did an incredible job on our wallpaper, he is an artist! It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around." - William Curtis, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CRD Painting Inc. With a Chooz Score of 87.0%, over 90 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, and 5.0 stars on Yelp, owner Camilo has built deep loyalty across Long Island. Multiple reviewers describe relationships spanning 10 to 15 years. Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-59404 is verified active. If you value a long-term relationship with a contractor who remembers your home, CRD Painting is worth a call.

• Several business owners in the construction industry recommend Camilo, which speaks to the quality of his craft
• Cabinet painting and kitchen projects appear frequently, with reviewers describing results that exceeded expectations

"I highly recommend C.R.D. Painting. They do exceptional work in a professional way. His work is neat, precise and with attention to every detail. He has an eye of an artist." - Lisa Farrell, Google Review

With over 130 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, Big Expert Painting LLC also earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. Owner Denis handles estimates personally and holds Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 plus EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification. Reviewers highlight fast turnaround, with projects often finishing ahead of schedule. If you need a responsive, owner-operated crew, Big Expert Painting delivers.

• Several customers hired Denis for one room and immediately booked additional work
• Denis is known for answering calls directly, including on weekends
• Exterior projects including power washing and deck staining receive strong marks

"5 STARS!!! Dennis and team were outstanding! I already scheduled another two jobs for him next week at my house and referred him to two people." - Ken Smitelli, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Islip, NY, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Todd is a hands-on owner who personally works on most jobs, and cabinet painting is considered his personal specialty. If you want fast, reliable work from someone who takes pride in every project, Todd's Painting is a solid pick.

• Multiple reviewers describe entire interior projects completed in a single day
• Power washing, deck staining, and full exterior work make him a versatile one-stop option

"He's a true professional and I found his pricing to be very fair. One look at the inside of his truck and I knew that he was passionate about his business." - Paul Genova, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Quality and attention to detail are the most frequently mentioned themes across painting contractor reviews in Islip, NY. Customers routinely describe finished results that exceed their expectations, with many noting that walls, ceilings, and trim look better than when their homes were originally built. Teall Painting receives praise for handling specialty projects like mahogany door refinishing and stucco exteriors, while Interior Finishing NYC earns recognition for decorative techniques like Venetian plaster and Roman clay. "Renee from Teall did a great job painting my girl's bedrooms and our kitchen. Renee is open to feedback and is dedicated to satisfying his clients." - Cassandra Moussignac, Google Review. "Dori was prompt and very professional. His Venetian plaster work on my kitchen walls are unbelievable. I always get compliments from our guests!" - Charlie Vela, Google Review

CRD Painting Inc and Big Expert Painting LLC both hold perfect 5.0-star ratings across their Google reviews, with customers describing results that look flawless on close inspection. Todd's Painting stands out for cabinet work, which reviewers call a personal specialty of Todd's craft. "My kitchen cabinets and walls turned out more beautiful than I ever could have imagined!" - Elissa Lynch, Google Review (CRD Painting). "Painting cabinets is his personal specialty and he's a true master of his craft!" - Darlene Romashko, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is a strong suit across the top-rated painting contractors in Islip, NY. Teall Painting owner Charlie Cascio is described by reviewers as someone who keeps customers updated daily on progress and next steps. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi responds to nearly every Google review with personalized messages, and customers appreciate his responsiveness during the quoting process. "From day 1 we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and what to expect that day." - John Calvacca, Google Review. "Owner, Dorian, was tremendous to work with remotely for repainting corporate office. Communicative, effective and customer-service oriented." - K Fowler, Google Review

CRD Painting Inc owner Camilo earns consistent praise for being easy to reach and straightforward with scheduling and pricing. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge stands out for its project management structure, with territory managers like David Maloney walking customers through every step from estimate to final walkthrough. "Camilo was there every step of the way. He is so honest, neat, and organized." - Dee Kelly, Google Review. "From the estimate to job completion, Brendan was there. Communication was frequent and clear." - Theresa Westergard, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is a common strength among the top painting contractors serving Islip, NY. Todd's Painting is frequently praised for fast turnarounds, with several reviewers describing entire interior projects completed in a single day. Big Expert Painting LLC also gets credit for finishing ahead of schedule, with one reviewer noting a three-day estimate was completed in two. "Todd stopped by to give me an estimate, and the very next day he and his crew were at my house early and finished with everything before 5pm." - Jenna F., Google Review. "Dennis and his team gave me an estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B., Google Review

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge receives praise for meeting projected timelines on larger projects, with one reviewer confirming a 4-to-5 day estimate was completed right on schedule. Teall Painting reviewers note that crews arrive on time each morning and work long hours when needed to meet deadlines. "David told me in the beginning the job should take 4 to 5 days, and sure enough his crew was done on schedule." - Jean Augustin, Google Review. "Charlie and his team were punctual and worked long hours to finish the work." - Shai Bojsa, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup are themes that appear across nearly every company serving Islip, NY. CRD Painting Inc reviewers consistently describe floors and furniture being carefully covered before any painting begins, with homes left spotless at the end of each day. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earned similar praise, with one reviewer trusting the crew with a house key for a multi-day renovation across a 2,300-square-foot home. "Not only did they paint inside my house they also did some additional work outside, all while keeping my house clean and orderly." - Penny Sichel, Google Review (CRD Painting). "The painters were neat and thorough. The work team left the area cleaner than they found it." - Donald Sclare, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

Teall Painting is known for protecting finished floors with plastic sheathing, builder's paper, and drop cloths before any cans are opened. Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers describe Denis and his crew covering personal items carefully and sweeping up before leaving. "Jose and his team arrived on time both days and left our home spotless." - Michelle Scaduto, Google Review (Teall Painting). "They made sure they covered my personal items before starting and moved fast!" - Chantel B., Google Review (Big Expert Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair and competitive pricing is a recurring theme across reviews for painting contractors in Islip, NY. Big Expert Painting LLC frequently receives praise for offering reasonable rates without compromising on quality. Todd's Painting is also consistently described as fairly priced, with customers describing the value as exceptional for the quality of work delivered. "Denis was easy to work with and gave very competitive pricing." - Daniel Marques, Google Review. "His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient." - Brandon Shoman, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

CRD Painting Inc and Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge also earn marks for transparent and competitive pricing. Multiple reviewers across both companies describe getting several quotes and choosing these contractors for their combination of professionalism and value. "His prices are also fair and reasonable. I would highly recommend." - Edgardo Contreras, Google Review (CRD Painting). "PPP gave us an amazing price but more importantly the work was awesome and the communication was fantastic." - Andrew Matz, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google