Homeowners in East Islip, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong review records across multiple platforms. Whether you need a full interior repaint, exterior refresh, or specialized finish work, these companies have earned consistent praise for reliability, crew quality, and finished results.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with additional ratings of 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. With over 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County, owner Todd Rumfola runs a crew-driven operation where painters like Rich, Jerry, and Alex are requested by name across reviews. Several customers describe feeling comfortable enough to leave the house while the crew worked, a level of trust that shows up repeatedly in the feedback. If you want an owner-operated company where the same familiar crew handles your project from start to finish, South Bay is a strong choice.
What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe Todd texting the night before and morning of the job to confirm details. Painters arrive at 8am and stay focused throughout the day, with multiple reviewers noting how carefully furniture and floors are protected during interior work.
- Crew members Rich and Jerry are praised individually across dozens of reviews for patience, friendliness, and willingness to go beyond the scope of work
- Power washing and painting projects are frequently bundled together, with customers noting the convenience of a single company handling both
- Several reviews mention Todd offering same-day estimates after an initial phone call
"Todd is professional, kind, prompt and responsible. We have had him powerwash our home for several years, as well as paint a bedroom in our home. His prices are reasonable and his work exceptional." - Michele Maratea, Google Review
For homeowners seeking specialty finishes that go well beyond standard painting, Interior Finishing NYC offers an artistic approach rooted in formal training. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi studied fine arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and decorative wall treatments. With over 22 years in business and a 3-year workmanship warranty, this company handles projects that other contractors often turn down. If you have a complex decorative finish in mind or need wallpaper installed on difficult surfaces, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong fit.
Reviewers frequently describe Dorian as hands-on during every phase of a project. Multiple customers hired him specifically because previous contractors could not achieve the finish they wanted, and Dorian delivered results that matched their inspiration photos exactly.
- Wallpaper installation on cork, grasscloth, and vinyl surfaces draws consistent praise for precision and seamless pattern matching
- Team members Jose, Amir, and Marvin appear across reviews as a reliable, consistent unit
- Several customers describe Dorian providing quotes over video call to save time before scheduling an in-person visit
"Dorian and his crew are masters of their craft. I hired them to plaster and skim coat all the walls and ceilings in my apartment and they did a fantastic job for a fair price." - Armen Stevens, Google Review
With a Chooz Score of 87.6%, Teall Painting brings over 12 years in business and a crew that customers consistently request by name. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Their work is backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Charlie Teall, the owner, handles every estimate personally and stays in close contact throughout each project. If you want detailed, itemized estimates with no surprises on the final invoice, Teall Painting is a reliable option.
What comes through clearly in the reviews is how thoroughly Teall's crews prep before any paint goes on. Customers describe floors covered with plastic sheathing and builder's paper, furniture carefully moved, and surfaces taped with precision. The finished results on everything from kitchen cabinets to brick exteriors draw praise for looking brand new.
- Crew members Rene, Victor, Oscar, and Gavin each appear across multiple reviews from different customers on unrelated projects
- Exterior work including shutters, doors, chimney painting, and cedar restoration is well-represented in the review record
- Multiple customers describe receiving daily updates and clear communication about what was completed each day
"Charlie and his team were great to work with. From day 1 we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and completed and what to expect that day." - John Calvacca, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Big Expert Painting LLC. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis handles every estimate personally, answers calls directly, and frequently checks in during and after projects. If you need a straightforward, no-nonsense painting crew that shows up on time, finishes fast, and leaves the space spotless, Big Expert is worth a call.
Several reviewers describe hiring Denis for a single room and then immediately booking additional work because they were so pleased with the results. The crew works quickly without cutting corners, with multiple customers noting that multi-day estimates were completed a day ahead of schedule.
- Crown molding installation, door replacement, and trim work are offered alongside painting services
- Several Spanish-speaking reviewers praise Denis for bilingual communication and comfort throughout the process
- Customers describe Denis sweeping up tracked-in leaves and leaving homes cleaner than when he arrived
"Initially, I had Denis come to do three rooms of my home. We were so impressed that we had him and his crew come back to do two more rooms and patch up a few things around the house." - Sara Galante, Google Review
With over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting has built a loyal following across Suffolk County. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with reviews spanning Google, Facebook, and Yelp. What stands out most in the feedback is how fast Todd and his crew turn projects around. Customers describe receiving an estimate one day and having the entire job completed the next. If speed and reliability matter most to you, Todd's Painting delivers consistently.
Several reviewers describe Todd as someone who genuinely loves what he does. One customer noted that a single look inside Todd's organized work truck made it clear how seriously he takes his craft. His crew handles everything from interior repaints and cabinet refinishing to exterior staining and power washing.
- Kitchen cabinet painting draws particular praise, with customers describing results that exceeded expectations
- Todd personally returns to address any touch-up concerns, often within a day or two of being contacted
- Commercial painting projects appear alongside residential work, with one reviewer describing a flawless two-day commercial job
"He's a true professional and I found his pricing to be very fair. One look at the inside of his truck and I knew that he was passionate about his business and what he does for a living." - Paul Genova, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in East Islip, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge has over 18 years in business and earned a Chooz Score of 84.8%. They had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook, and hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015). Project managers like David Maloney and T.J. coordinate each job from estimate through final walkthrough. If you want a larger, well-structured operation with dedicated project management and competitive pricing, Precision Painting Plus is a solid option.
Customers who compared multiple estimates before choosing Precision Painting Plus consistently note that their pricing was the most competitive without sacrificing quality. The crew arrives on time daily, protects all surfaces thoroughly, and leaves the home in usable condition at the end of each workday even during multi-day projects.
- Exterior painting including teak furniture refinishing and deck staining appears alongside standard interior work
- Multiple reviewers describe receiving competitive pricing after getting three or more estimates from other companies
- Territory manager David Maloney is praised by name in numerous reviews for clear communication and follow-through
"I hired Precision Painting after getting 3 estimates. They are by far the most reasonably priced. I had the pleasure of dealing with David Maloney, the project manager. He was very professional and explained everything." - Helen Grygo, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
