Homeowners in Brightwaters, NY and the surrounding South Shore communities have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each offering a different combination of services, specialties, and customer experience. Reviews across these companies consistently highlight responsive communication, fair pricing, and crews that treat homes with care.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola is directly involved in every project, from the initial estimate through the final walkthrough, and his name appears throughout the review record. If you need power washing, exterior painting, or interior work and want an owner who personally answers calls and texts, South Bay is a strong choice.
What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe leaving their homes in Todd's hands without worry. Multiple reviewers mention Todd texting the night before to confirm arrival times, and several note that his crew members Rich and Jerry are requested by name for return projects. Customers who started with a simple power wash often come back for painting work the following year.
- Several customers describe pavers and siding that looked brand new after power washing, with one homeowner noting surfaces over 20 years old were restored
- Todd provides online proposals and invoices, making the business side of the process unusually smooth for a local contractor
- Repeat customers appear frequently, with some returning three or four years in a row for different projects around the house
"Working with South Bay was such a great experience! I reached out for a quote on a Sunday afternoon and received almost an immediate response. Todd came the very next day, provided the quote within an hour or so of being at our home and made the whole process easy." - Julia Sisco, Google Review
For homeowners looking for specialty decorative finishes that most painting contractors will not attempt, Interior Finishing NYC offers an artistic approach to interior work. Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper installation. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 22 years in business, Dorian and his team serve Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and Long Island. If you want a finish that goes beyond standard flat or eggshell paint, Interior Finishing NYC is a good fit.
Reviewers frequently describe projects where other contractors refused the work before Dorian accepted it. His team handles everything from grasscloth wallpaper on challenging surfaces to ceiling gilding in commercial spaces. Dorian often provides quotes over the phone or by video call, saving customers time, and his crew members Jose, Amir, and Marvin appear consistently across reviews as a reliable unit.
- Multiple customers describe lime wash and Roman clay results that matched their inspiration photos exactly
- The company offers a three-year workmanship warranty on all projects
- Dorian personally works on site alongside his crew for most projects rather than managing remotely
"We hired Dorian and his team to paint our living room and guest bedroom in lime wash paint. His team was professional, skilled, clean, and incredibly fast. They painted both rooms in a single day, and the results are amazing." - Matt Ballen, Google Review
Customers who value hands-on leadership and long-term relationships keep coming back to Big Expert Painting LLC. Owner Denis personally handles every estimate, often responding the same day, including weekends. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. They hold a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and EPA Lead-Safe Certification. If you are looking for a contractor who answers the phone directly and follows up weeks after the job is complete, Big Expert is worth calling.
What reviewers mention most often is how quickly work gets scheduled and completed once Denis provides the estimate. Several customers describe having rooms finished in under two days, and a number of reviews mention Denis calling a month later to check on the work. The company handles everything from basement repairs to full exterior painting and crown molding installation.
- One customer was so impressed after having three rooms painted that she immediately booked two more and plans to hire them again
- Denis and his team handle power washing, deck staining, and carpentry repairs in addition to painting
- Customers consistently describe the crew as clean and organized, with personal items carefully covered before work begins
"Dennis and his team did a great job. Very friendly and listens to your request. They made sure they covered my personal items before starting and moved fast! Gave me an estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B., Google Review
With over 10 years in business and a loyal customer base that spans decades, Todd's Painting has built a reputation for fast turnarounds without cutting corners. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Reviews span Google, Facebook, and Yelp. If you need a project completed quickly, whether it is a single bathroom or a whole-home repaint with cathedral ceilings, Todd's Painting consistently delivers ahead of schedule.
Several customers describe projects completed in a single day that they expected to take much longer. One reviewer had her entire interior, including 17-foot cathedral ceilings, painted over three days. Todd handles both residential and commercial work, and reviewers who have known him for years describe consistently reliable results across very different types of projects.
- Multiple reviewers mention Todd helping with color selection and making the decision process easier for first-time painters
- Kitchen cabinet painting is a frequently praised specialty, with customers describing results that refreshed the look of their kitchens
- Todd personally corrects any touch-up concerns within a day or two of being notified
"I haven't had my house painted in 20 years and was nervous about cleaning the walls, moving furniture and the mess it would be. Todd helped me figure out the easiest way to choose colors and figure out the pets! He made the whole experience stress-free." - Christine Curzio, Google Review
Also serving the Brightwaters, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings nearly two decades of experience and a strong focus on protecting customer property. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau and has been named a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. If you want a crew that treats your home like their own and leaves everything spotless, Precision Painting Plus is a solid option.
Manager Chris appears frequently in reviews for his professionalism and responsiveness, and crews led by Cristhian receive consistent praise. Customers who started with a single room often return to have their entire home painted, and referral chains appear throughout the review record with neighbors, friends, and family members hiring the company after seeing results firsthand.
- One customer had the exterior of a 230-year-old house painted and described the full process from color consultation to completion as professional and thorough
- Crews handle furniture placement after the job is complete, with several reviewers noting they were surprised at how clean the space was left
"Our 230-year-old house was in serious need of an exterior paint job. After speaking with three painting companies, we decided on Precision Painting Plus and we are extremely happy with our decision." - Jim Gabriel, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Brightwaters, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration is led by owner Andres Gallego, who personally spends hours walking through homes before work begins. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 6 years in business, their reputation has been built almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. If you need a large project completed quickly with a full-size crew, Long Island Painting and Restoration regularly finishes ahead of schedule.
Reviewers describe a company that scales up crew sizes for bigger jobs, with one customer noting a six-person crew completed a whole-home project in a single day. Andres provides detailed written estimates with full cost breakdowns, and foreman Nelson and crew member Joey are mentioned by name for their spackling and wall repair skills. Several customers have hired them for second homes after being impressed with the first project.
- A customer who just bought a home covered in bright orange and pink paint had the entire house repainted and described it as looking brand new
- Commercial clients also praise the company, with one describing a building exterior project as professional from start to finish
- Andres remains reachable throughout projects and responds quickly to estimate requests
"After doing endless research we finally decided to go with Long Island Painting and Restoration. Andres came by and went room to room while also answering our questions. His attention to detail and transparency made us feel confident we made the right choice." - Verenise Gerardini, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
