Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Todd's Painting
When Craig O. needed his entire interior painted, including 17-foot cathedral ceilings and extensive repair work, Todd Valenti and his crew delivered results that made "walls and ceilings look like new." This pattern of transforming challenging spaces defines how Todd's Painting has operated across Suffolk County for over 30 years.
Owner Todd Valenti handles estimates and color consultations, helping homeowners avoid costly mistakes. One customer credits his expertise for saving them from having to repaint entirely. The company offers interior and exterior painting, kitchen cabinet refinishing starting at $140 per opening, taping and spackling, vinyl siding painting, and power washing.
Todd's Painting is licensed with Suffolk County as a Home Improvement Contractor, with credentials active through January 2027 covering painting, sheetrock/spackling, and power washing. The team provides a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee on all work. Based in Centereach, they serve all of Suffolk County, NY, with a reputation for leaving homes "cleaner than it was before" the project began.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Customers highlight remarkably fast response times. Sean F. describes how Todd "answered his phone on a Sunday morning showed up for the estimate that same afternoon called back Sunday early evening willing to start that following week." This pattern of weekend availability and same-day estimates appears throughout reviews, with many customers noting they received quotes within hours of their initial call.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cleanup consistently earns praise in customer reviews. Dawn Marie Bove reported her home was "cleaner than it was before" the painting started, noting the crew "covered the floor and any pieces of furniture." Amy G. described Todd as having "cleaned up after himself like he was never even here." Cassia C. added that "cleanup when the job was done was fantastic I didn't have to do a thing."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cabinet painting is a company specialty, and reviews reflect exceptional results. Keith Barbone described how Todd "spray painted kitchen cabinets" that now "look like they came from original factory." The service starts at $140 per opening and includes professional spray application for a smooth, factory-like finish. Multiple customers mention cabinet work as the reason they hired Todd for additional projects throughout their homes.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Free color consultations are a standout service that customers value highly. Karen fox credits Todd's expertise, noting he "recommended to change color" and that without his guidance "we would have had to repaint." Patty Toscano praised Todd for being "so patient with my indecisiveness on colors." These consultations help homeowners avoid costly mistakes and find colors that work for their specific spaces and lighting.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Long-term relationships define this company. Lori Lucia has used Todd's Painting for "30 years" while Barbara T. mentions her "Friends, Family and I have been using Todd's painting for Many years." Lisa S. started with her living room and dining room, and Todd "did such a great job I let him do my whole house." She then "recommended him to my friends and they loved what he did for them."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Owner Todd responds to feedback directly. When a recent customer raised concerns about protection procedures and pricing communication for additional coats, Todd responded publicly to address the specific issues. While resolutions vary, the owner's willingness to engage with criticism demonstrates accountability. Kerry Fitzpatrick noted that "Todd was wonderful through our project. He answered questions and concerns and moved at a very comfortable pace."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Value consistently appears in customer feedback. Cassia C. found "the price was very reasonable" for her whole-house project. Craig O. hired Todd for extensive work including "very high ceilings" and "a lot of repair work required" and emphasized that Todd "went the extra mile throughout the project." Customers frequently mention receiving fair pricing alongside quality workmanship.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Speed without sacrificing quality is a recurring theme. Danielle Buglino reported her "job done in 48 hours" while Sean F. noted Todd "finished a two day job in 1." Even complex projects move efficiently. Craig O. had his entire interior painted, including high ceilings and significant repair work, and praised Todd for being "very professional while still showing a fun sense of humor" throughout the process.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Todd's Painting holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License. Owner Todd Valenti is licensed under License No. HI-67840, issued January 17, 2023, and valid through January 1, 2027. The license covers painting, sheetrock/spackling, and power washing services. The business is registered at 40 Maiden Lane, Patchogue, NY 11772 with Suffolk County Department of Consumer Affairs.
-Verification Sources: Suffolk County DCA License Search
Updated: 04-07-2026