11 Best Painters Near Central Islip, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Central Islip, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different strength to the table. Whether you need a full interior repaint, specialty finishes, or a quick exterior refresh, the top-rated companies on Chooz Painters consistently earn praise for reliable crews, fair pricing, and work that holds up over time.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Owner Charlie Cascio runs the operation from Massapequa Park and has built his company over 12 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County. What stands out across reviews is how many customers mention Charlie personally checking in during their projects, even when a different crew member is handling the day-to-day painting. Several reviewers describe receiving detailed, itemized estimates that left no room for surprises. If you want a contractor who keeps you informed from estimate to final walkthrough, Teall Painting is a good choice.

• Customers frequently mention being impressed by the virtual estimate process, which saves time and provides accurate quotes without an in-person visit
• Multiple reviewers highlight that the crew completed work faster than the quoted timeline without sacrificing quality
• Flooring and drywall services are available alongside painting, allowing homeowners to bundle projects with a single contractor

"I was lucky to find Teall Painting during a Google search. Charlie's response time to my initial inquiry was quite impressive. More impressive was the professionalism of the work. The finished job made my apartment look amazing." - Audrey Bolger, Google Review

For homeowners seeking specialty decorative finishes that most contractors simply do not offer, Interior Finishing NYC stands apart. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi, who holds a Bachelor of Fine Arts from the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, brings an artistic background to projects involving limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper installation. With over 22 years in business, the company backs all work with a three-year workmanship warranty. If your project involves decorative finishes or wallpaper, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong fit.

• Several customers describe hiring Dorian after other contractors turned down their projects, particularly for complex wallpaper installations and pre-war plaster restoration
• Dorian frequently provides quotes over phone or video call, making scheduling convenient for busy homeowners
• The team handles both residential apartments and commercial spaces including offices and retail locations

"Dorian and his team did an incredible job on our wallpaper. He is an artist! It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around." - William Curtis, Google Review

While Interior Finishing NYC specializes in decorative work, CRD Painting Inc has built its reputation on long-term customer relationships across Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo and his crew are the kind of painters customers call back year after year. With over 8 years in business and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License verified active through 2027, CRD Painting is a good choice for homeowners who want a reliable painter they can return to for future projects.

• Multiple reviewers describe calling Camilo back for a color change or additional rooms after being impressed with the initial job
• A family drywall business with 60 years on Long Island recommends CRD Painting to their own builders and customers
• Reviewers consistently note that Camilo works around their schedules, including accommodating tight move-in deadlines

"Camilo and his team are really the best at what they do. I hired him and his team to paint my new house top to bottom, and they did a perfect job. Great communication, clean up, and attention to detail." - Rahul Vyas, Google Review

Also serving the Central Islip, NY area, Big Expert Painting LLC brings hands-on ownership and competitive pricing. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis handles estimates personally, and several reviewers mention that he followed up weeks after the project to make sure everything still looked good. The company holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License plus EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes. If you own an older home that may have lead paint concerns, Big Expert Painting is a particularly strong option.

• Reviewers highlight that Denis responds to quote requests quickly, including on weekends
• Several customers describe hiring Big Expert for one room and then immediately booking additional projects after seeing the results
• Power washing services are available alongside painting for exterior projects

"We've used Big Expert Painting twice. Once to do drywall work in our kitchen and more recently, to repair and paint ceiling and walls. The guys are very professional and did a great job. We will definitely use them again." - Allie Scalza, Google Review

With over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. What stands out most in the reviews is speed. Multiple customers describe entire rooms finished in a single day, and multi-room projects wrapped up in under 48 hours, all without complaints about cut corners. Reviews span Google, Facebook, and Yelp. If you need a fast turnaround without sacrificing quality, Todd's Painting is worth calling.

• Customers praise Todd for suggesting paint colors and finishes that complement their existing decor
• Cabinet painting and power washing are frequently mentioned alongside standard interior and exterior work
• One reviewer noted their 100-year-old house looked brand new after Todd's crew finished the exterior

"Start to finish, Todd's painting was a great decision! Communication was prompt and concise. We are delighted with our maple cabinet makeover." - Donna DiNapoli, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Central Islip, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. They are 100% recommended on Facebook and accredited with the Better Business Bureau. With over 18 years in business, the company employs dedicated project managers like David Maloney and Brendan who oversee field crews. If you prefer a larger operation with dedicated project management, Precision Painting Plus is a solid choice.

• An architect who hired them for exterior painting and deck refinishing now recommends them to clients
• One homeowner handed over a house key for a multi-day whole-home repaint, trusting the crew to work independently
• Customers mention crews arriving on time every day and leaving the home in usable condition each evening

"Just had my ceilings and living room painted and I am impressed! Perfection is how I'd describe it! This company was so professional from start to finish and I will definitely be using them for my next project." - Kevin Kitson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Painting contractors serving Central Islip, NY consistently earn praise for the quality of their finished work. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe results that exceed their expectations, with particular attention to prep work, clean lines, and finishes that hold up over time. Teall Painting customers frequently mention how crew members take extra time on details like crack repair, spackle work, and surface preparation before any paint goes on. "Charlie and his team were professional from start to finish. Jose and his team arrived on time both days and left our home spotless." - Michelle Scaduto, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC stands out for specialty finishes like limewash and Roman clay, with one reviewer calling owner Dorian's wallpaper work "an artist" level of skill. "I cannot recommend Dorian and his team highly enough. His work is exacting, thorough, and artful, and he operates with integrity and kindness." - Claire Trempe, Google Review.

CRD Painting Inc customers highlight careful attention to architectural details like wainscoting and moldings. "Camilo and his team painted our living room which has many different architectural details. Once completed I wasn't happy with the color I chose. I called Camilo and he came the next day and repainted the walls!" - Karen Rauseo, Google Review. Todd's Painting reviewers describe results on older homes that look brand new, and Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns praise from professionals, including an architect who now recommends them to his own clients. "Being a contractor myself, this is how every single home improvement contractor should aspire to be." - Brian S., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Communication is one of the strongest themes across reviews for painting contractors in Central Islip, NY. Teall Painting owner Charlie Cascio is mentioned repeatedly for keeping customers updated throughout their projects, with multiple reviewers noting they received daily progress reports. "From day 1 we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and what to expect that day." - John Calvacca, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi earns similar praise for responsiveness, with customers noting he replies quickly to initial inquiries and provides quotes efficiently over phone or video. "Dorian was very responsive and courteous, and did a great job! He was also more affordable than the other painters we called." - Tova Kalkstein, Google Review.

Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis is described as someone who answers calls directly and responds to requests even on weekends. "Denis came out himself for the estimate, did the work with his crew the next week, and called a month later to make sure everything was still working perfectly." - K.F., Google Review. CRD Painting Inc customers praise Camilo for clear communication about scheduling and scope of work, while JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan earns consistent mentions for being easy to reach and straightforward about pricing. "He responded, gave me a fair quote and worked with me on a medical delay I incurred." - Jim C., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and protection of the work area is one of the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Central Islip, NY. Teall Painting reviewers regularly describe coming home to find their spaces spotless after a full day of painting. "They protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless. They were on time each day, and were patient with all of my questions." - Cindy Rantal, Google Review. CRD Painting Inc customers echo this, noting that Camilo's crew covers floors and furniture before opening a single can of paint. "They came in and did an expert paint job through a large portion of our home in two days start to finish. They worked clean and fast!" - Sensei M., Yelp Review.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge takes cleanup seriously enough that customers trust them with unsupervised access to their homes. Multiple reviewers describe the crew leaving the home in usable condition at the end of each workday during multi-day projects. Interior Finishing NYC customers note the team keeps work areas tidy even during complex wallpaper and plaster jobs. "His team was professional, skilled, clean, and incredibly fast. They painted both rooms in a single day, and the cleanup was thorough." - Matt Ballen, Google Review. JRT Pro Painters LLC customers appreciate that the crew takes all garbage and debris with them when the project is complete.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Showing up on time and finishing when promised are common themes across reviews for painters in Central Islip, NY. Todd's Painting stands out for fast turnarounds, with multiple customers describing entire projects completed in a single day. "My 6yr old son said our house looks sooooo pretty and doesn't look like a haunted house anymore! Already preparing for my next project with Todd!" - Jacquelyn Riker, Google Review. Teall Painting customers consistently praise the crew for arriving on time each morning and completing work within or ahead of the estimated timeline. "They came when they said they were coming and completed the job when they said they would." - Eileen Leddy, Google Review.

Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers note that Denis schedules quickly after providing an estimate, often starting work within a week of the initial consultation. Interior Finishing NYC customers highlight that Dorian's team works efficiently, with several describing full apartment painting jobs completed in just a few hours. CRD Painting Inc earns praise for working around customers' schedules, including tight move-in timelines. "Camilo worked around my schedule to help accommodate when I could get the work done. He showed up on time and gave a fair price!" - New Beginnings Front Desk, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Central Islip, NY. Teall Painting customers describe receiving detailed, itemized estimates with no hidden costs. "We agreed on the price, which I thought was reasonable for the amount of work that needed to be done." - Angelina Harrington, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC is praised across multiple reviews for competitive pricing, with customers noting the combination of quality work and affordability sets them apart. "Very reasonably priced as well. I highly recommend." - Max Jacob, Google Review.

CRD Painting Inc reviewers describe Camilo's pricing as fair and consistent, with several long-term customers noting that rates have remained reasonable over years of repeat business. Todd's Painting earns praise for delivering more work than expected within the quoted price, with one reviewer noting they were able to add extra projects because the initial quote was so competitive. Interior Finishing NYC customers find the pricing reasonable for the level of specialty work involved, particularly for decorative finishes that require artistic skill. "He was also more affordable than the other painters we called." - Tova Kalkstein, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge project manager David Maloney is mentioned for providing competitive estimates that make the decision easy for homeowners.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Repeat business is one of the clearest indicators of quality among painting contractors in Central Islip, NY, and several companies show strong patterns of returning customers. CRD Painting Inc has some of the most loyal customers in the area, with multiple reviewers documenting relationships spanning over a decade. "We have been using Camilo from CRD painting for over 10 years. Top notch, neat, professional and fast service. Have referred many family and friends all with rave reviews!" - Steve Siero, Google Review. Todd's Painting has customers who have been calling back for over 30 years, and several reviewers mention hiring Todd for a second or third property after being satisfied with the first.

Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers frequently describe starting with a small project and then immediately booking additional rooms or returning months later for more work. Teall Painting customers mention being repeat clients and referring the company to friends, family, and even their own clients. "This is my second time using Teall and I am very, very happy. They are very clean and very helpful. I would recommend them to anyone." - Patricia Pajak, Google Review. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan has built a following of repeat customers who return for additional rooms and even new homes, with one customer describing hiring the company for four separate projects over several years. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers mention planning future projects before the current one is even finished.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook